Have you ever noticed that people who say "Charity begins at home" sometimes mean it rather TOO literally?

@boiboing (13153)
Northampton, England
September 28, 2015 11:38pm CST
I saw an interesting discussion on Facebook recently about the Syrian refugee crisis. The point it made was that suddenly lots of people are trotting out the old "Charity begins at home" line when faced with the need for European countries to support the refugees. The poster of this discussion pointed out that the very same people suddenly got a (publicly expressed) conscience about the homeless, the poor, and the needy in their own country that hadn't been something they cared about just a week or two before. If you don't have the heart to care about people drowning in the Med and walking hundreds of miles for a better future, chances are you don't really care about the homeless back home either. Charity begins at home tends to mean one of two things. Either "I only give money to charities that are directly relevant to me" or more extremely "It's my money, I need it more than other people do so they can forget getting a penny out of me". I know full well that not everyone can afford to make charitable donations and that's fine. Like many things in life, giving away money is a luxury that not everyone can indulge in. I understand the need to protect yourself and your family first. BUT don't then trot out all this "Charity begins at home" nonsense like some sanctimonious prig if you're the kind of person who is still recycling last year's paper poppies and taking a detour to avoid anyone with a collection tin. If you don't have the resources to help others, I understand but if you simply don't WANT to help others, it's your choice. Just don't try to dress it up as anything other than not caring enough.
15 people like this
8 responses
@indexer (4852)
• Leicester, England
29 Sep 15
It was back in the 17th century that the English churchman Thomas Fuller said: "Charity begins at home, but should not end there." That sentiment is just as true today as it was nearly 400 years ago, but the second part of that quote is often ignored.
5 people like this
• Preston, England
30 Sep 15
I knew the quotation but I had no idea it was from so long ago. I thought it sounded so 20th century. We learn so much here.
1 person likes this
@boiboing (13153)
• Northampton, England
29 Sep 15
I didn't know that but that's a really powerful twist. No wonder people have been dropping it! Thank you.
3 people like this
@Auntylou (4264)
• Oxford, England
10 Dec 15
Because the word charity means caring , the full quotation is most meaningful
2 people like this
• United States
29 Sep 15
{peekin' from 'hind a rock} 'tis it safe to come out now?? {looks 'round wildly fer lightnin' bolts} i don't facebook, so aint privy to those callous folks ya mention. but, (always a but, aint there?) the eldest son 'n i were jest visitin' 'bout this sorta thingy jest the other eve. it seems most odd to me that folks'll jump on the band wagon to help those that're so far 'way, yet won't e'en check on their neighbor. aint sayin' those folks don't need all the help they can get, jest sayin'.
3 people like this
@boiboing (13153)
• Northampton, England
29 Sep 15
That's fine - don't hide. These are supposed to be discussions not agreements. Unlike someone who really turned nasty on me for answering a 'what do you think?' post with an opinion she didn't like, I won't ridicule people who don't agree with me. Generally though, I do think those who care about other countries are more than averagely likely to care about their own countrymen.
4 people like this
• United States
29 Sep 15
@boiboing hmm, i was tryin' to tickle yer funny bone a bit - apologies fer my failure to do such. i dunno. the mother-in-law is purty much my only reference fer such. she's quick to mail a check out to folks 'cross the country, yet ridicules those less fortunate in her town. outside 'f church potlucks, she'll not lift a finger fer the locals
2 people like this
@boiboing (13153)
• Northampton, England
29 Sep 15
@crazyhorseladycx oh don't get me started on churchy folk who are all show and no heart.
2 people like this
• Preston, England
30 Sep 15
Charity begins at home is a euphemism for not giving to any charities.
2 people like this
@boiboing (13153)
• Northampton, England
30 Sep 15
Absolutely - you got that one right on the nail
2 people like this
@valmnz (17099)
• New Zealand
30 Sep 15
Over the years I've come to decisions as to which charities I support and which I don't simply through lack of funds. Some people do find it hard to say no, I was one of those once. Personally, I would prefer to see donated money go a little closer to home, we have plenty of needy here, some of whom I do donate to.
1 person likes this
• Grand Haven, Michigan
30 Sep 15
Exactly.....Just be honest about it. I will at least respect honesty, even if I don't agree with what someone is saying. This counts for the homeless also. Show me a sign that says "Can't work.Need Food" and I'll pass you by. Show me one that says "I REALLY need to get high right now" and you get a Fiver! lol
1 person likes this
• Grand Haven, Michigan
1 Dec 15
@paigea For me, honesty always sounds a little weird. Need usually comes off as cliche. I prefer weird because it's so rare! lol
2 people like this
@Auntylou (4264)
• Oxford, England
10 Dec 15
That might be a more truthful way of begging!
2 people like this
@paigea (35716)
• Canada
28 Nov 15
That is funny. Honesty trumps need it seems.
2 people like this
@paigea (35716)
• Canada
28 Nov 15
Hey, I recycle last years poppies all of the time. Ok, that is my extreme, hate waste, attitude. I did indeed wear an old poppy but I put a donation in several boxes. Especially where the cadets were manning the boxes. I collect poppies that people have dropped all over the place and save them for giving out at school to students who don't have one. Any way now that I have defended my reuse of poppies I have to say I agree with the points you've made.
1 person likes this
@boiboing (13153)
• Northampton, England
28 Nov 15
I don't have the tiniest issue with your poppy recycling. I'm a bit sad because last year they did some beautiful 100 years commem metal pins for the start of WW1 and I really liked mine but I can't rewear it without looking like a cheapskate.
1 person likes this
@boiboing (13153)
• Northampton, England
28 Nov 15
@paigea That's a good plan.
1 person likes this
@paigea (35716)
• Canada
28 Nov 15
@boiboing re wear it and also wear a new one.
1 person likes this
@gregario888 (1276)
• Aurangabad, India
29 Sep 15
It may also be a somewhat terse way of suggesting that you'd better look up to the far end of your nose and no further. Better take care of your own messes than start acting high and lofty, here and there.A sort of, crossed transaction.
1 person likes this
• St. Petersburg, Florida
12 Dec 15
I think it hurts some people to think that money is leaving to help those a world away, when just down the street there is a family that struggles due to illness or other situations, and they do not qualify for help. I don't think compassion knows about miles or geography. I think we mostly give when it touches us to do so, and often that means skipping someone we do not know, even in our own neighborhood. I like to think that because of our taxes over a lifetime, everyone has contributed a lot of money to help other countries, as our government does send aid to areas that have been it by earthquakes and floods. Our government also does help those who are hungry, in our country and other countries. We do a lot of good, even though the money comes from "the government" which is you and me. So we cannot really say that someone doesn't help others. They do through their taxes, whether they like or even know about it.