WRONG For Illegitimate POTUS to Fill STOLEN SCOTUS Seat
By anniepa
@anniepa (27955)
United States
April 7, 2017 1:45pm CST
Today the unthinkable happened, something that will touch all our lives or that of someone we love in one way or another at some time. Neil Gorsuch was confirmed to the Supreme Court, a lifetime appointment, for the seat that should have been filled over a year ago by President Obama's choice, Merrick Garland. Garland wasn't even given a hearing despite the fact that lawmakers from both parties had sung his praises in the past, because Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell said "the people" should decide who got to fill the seat vacated by the unexpected passing of Justice Antonin Scalia. Apparently the people, the majority of the people and a truly huge Electoral College majority, who had voted for President Obama twice didn't count. It was said that no President had ever placed a SCOTUS Justice at that late date in his Presidency, that it shouldn't happen since the election campaign had already begun and that Vice President Biden had said three decades ago that this shouldn't happen but the TRUTH is this particular situation had never come up before. I agree it would be wrong for a sitting President in an election year to appoint a new Justice to replace one who had decided to retire since that would look like an attempt to pack the court. In other words, say Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg had announced she was going to retire early in 2016. That could certainly be seen as an insurance move to make sure a Democratic President could name her replacement just in case a Republican won the coming election. THAT'S the type of situation Biden was speaking of hypothetically. However, nobody had predicted that Justice Scalia would suddenly pass away. I was sad to learn of his passing despite disagreeing with virtually all of his opinions but his seat isn't "preserved" for an ultra-conservative despite what the Republicans have implied. Also, everyone now seems to have forgotten that some of the Republicans had said that if Hillary Clinton were elected they'd hold the seat open for her entire Presidency if they retained the majority in the Senate. NOW the Democrats are the villains for filibustering.
To make matters so much worse we now have a person in the White House whose Presidency is very possibly...I'd say PROBABLY...illegitimate. So we'll have a Supreme Court Justice on the bench for possibly four decades or more in a stolen seat and put there by a so-called President who was put in the White House under false pretenses. Not to mention the fact that Gorsuch is a plagiarist! It was said by several people throughout this process that Gorsuch was the "best" choice the Democrats could hope for, that the others on Trump's list are more extremist in their views. Since he consistently rules against workers, women and minorities in favor of corporations and others in powerful positions I find that quite frightening. In his dissenting opinion he wrote that a man should have been fired since he chose not to kill himself or risk killing who knows how many innocent people when the brakes on his truck froze in sub-zero temperatures and he'd already waited hours for help to arrive. He finally abandoned his trailer and went to get warm after symptoms of hypothermia had set in. He returned after getting warm and nothing had happened to his trailer, by the way. Luckily the other judges, every one of them, ruled in his favor. He also ruled in the majority to give Hobby-Lobby the right to dictate what forms of birth control their employees or dependents could be covered for.
Gorsuch is replacing Scalia who was very conservative so the make-up of the court won't really change right now but with the next vacancy it will be tilted far to the right and the big losers will be the American people.
1 response
@dlr297 (5409)
• United States
8 Apr 17
First if Garland would have gotten a vote he would not have made it because the votes were not their..So why waste everyone's time, with something that would not have happened....The seat was not stolen....Even 4 Democrats voted for him....
The Hobby Lobby rule was the right call. They should not have to provide insurance that says it is ok to murder a child...and he has ruled against corporations and sided with what you call the little guy on many cases, but you are just not hearing about it...But if you would have watched the actual hearings you would have heard them talk about them also...
President Trump is the President....Their is nothing illegitimate about it.....
@anniepa (27955)
• United States
9 Apr 17
First of all, welcome back, I hope your move went well. If I remember what you said right, you now live in a state with a good Governor and 2 great Senators. Good for you!
There's no way anyone can possibly say Garland wouldn't have gotten confirmed if he'd been treated the way the Constitution dictates. Look at nominees of Presidents from both parties and you'll see there is usually no problem for them to get confirmed, almost always with over 60 votes. All of the Republicans in the Senate aren't partisan jerks like McConnell and many of them had publicly stated earlier that Garland would be an excellent choice. By your reasoning it would be a waste of time for any President to bother nominating someone if the opposite party is in control of the Senate.
Hobby-Lobby is all wrong, they don't have the right to dictate what BIRTH CONTROL their employees can get. We're not talking about abortion here, we're talking about contraception. I DID watch the hearings. Did you? Do you think he was right in his dissent about the fired trucker? Sure, there were some cases in which he ruled for the worker rather than the corporation but they were few and far between. His answers were mostly very vague and I think we both know he was lying when he said Donald didn't ask him his views on overturning Roe V Wade since Donald himself SAID that would be a litmus test for anyone he nominated.
We're going to see, hopefully soon, how legitimate he is. My bet is the entire administration will be tossed out and maybe we'll get a whole new election. That's if he doesn't get us nuked before then.
@dlr297 (5409)
• United States
9 Apr 17
@anniepa Yes I am getting moved in...The unpacking and arranging is going slow, but it is coming along... We moved to Va. Do not know a whole lot about the politics here yet. But i do know that Trump took this area, still see a lot of his signs out...
As for the supreme court nomination they did what they said they would they let the people decide by who was elected, an Trump won....Hopefully he will also place a few more Justices to the court so it gets back to holding up the constitution again.
Hobby lobby has the right to say no to murder. and follow their religious beliefs...and the people that work for them can go else where to get their insurance if they do not like what the employer offers...
How do you know he was lying....And what he said was that the President did not ask him to overturn Row Vs Wade... Row Vs Wade needs to be overturned, and the constitutional right to LIFE needs to be given back to the very innocent child that is being murdered.
How can you say he is not Legitimate when he won the election. No votes were changed that was already proved, and their is no proof that their was any collusion.....Hopefully Rice, and anyone else involved in the leaks of information will be held accountable for what they did...
Our President is putting the USA back where it should be with the world...We all know that something has to be done about ISIS, and with N. Korea....and with Iran....and in Syria,,,,,,,,,He also has to deal with all the Illegals here...He also has to deal with our failing Health care system, and our failing schools..Get good manufacturing Jobs back here..Build back our crumbling infrastructure.
Who do you think is going to nuke us ??????? Russia maybe...( Because they are so buddy, Buddy) All the world leaders he has met with so far have talked favorable of him.
1 person likes this
@anniepa (27955)
• United States
14 Apr 17
@dlr297 "The people" already HAD decided when they elected and then REELECTED President Obama. His term didn't end in 2015, he remained President until January 20 of 2017. You said "they did what they said they would" so what's your opinion on what they SAID they'd do if Hillary Clinton had won? Would you have agreed with them if they'd let that seat and any future vacancies to remain unfilled until a Republican became President?
If Trump gets any more picks we're all screwed in so many ways, all of us except straight rich white men who "say" they're Christians. Hobby-Lobby, which is in my state unfortunately, does not have the right to deny coverage for birth control. BIRTH CONTROL IS NOT MURDER. I'm assumng he was lying since Donald made it clear many times that he'd only pick nominees for SCOTUS who were in favor of overturning Roe V Wade, which is settled law and is none of anyone else's business. Do you think if the mother's life is at risk she should still be forced to carry a pregnancy to term? How is THAT "pro-life"?
He's illegitimate if the Russians influenced the election and they're still investigating who colluded with them. That's called TREASON. Susan Rick didn't "leak" anything, that's been made clear over and over, nobody suspects her of doing that. She did her job as National Security Advisor which entails looking over intelligence gatherings, some of which had the names of Americans "masked", and in order to make sense of the intel it was necessary for her to go through the steps of getting permission to unmask those names. She didn't "leak" them to anyone else. Donald is the one who needs to be held accountable for his lies and false accusations against her and President Obama.
Trump is not "my" President and never will be. He's making us an embarrassment to the rest of the world. I'm all for fixing our crumbling infrastructure as have been all of our recent Democratic Presidents but the Republicans in Congress have always refused to spend the money. Donald's plans, if he even has any, are just shady ways to give tax cuts and credits to his rich buddies for jobs that are already planned. He's so far over his head it's pathetic. He didn't know health care was complicated and now he says he didn't know dealing with North Korea was so hard. He's an incompetent idiot who can't even run an Easter Egg Roll!!
Speaking of North Korea and who's going to nuke us, turn on the news, the world's two craziest leaders are about to play with their nuclear toys. I'm sure the Trumps don't care because they no doubt have their gold-plated bunker well stocked and ready for them to hunker down in.




