Medical Testing: Is It Necessary?
By Alice Henry
@IreneVincent (15960)
United States
May 12, 2017 11:41am CST
Did you know that it is estimated that more than $200 billion is spent each year in the United States alone for unnecessary medical tests?
No one is suggesting that a person should disregard medical advice, especially if a person has symptoms which are questionable, but many doctors are recommending against some of these tests because they can sometimes be dangerous and in most cases completely unnecessary.
For example: Over $2.5 billion is spent on PSA screening for prostate cancer, which many doctors say, actually does more harm than good.
Pap tests for women who have had hysterectomies and women over 65 with no history of cervical cancer are unnecessary according to the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. I asked my doctor.
Many other procedures are also deemed unnecessary, such as biopsies, yearly electrocardiograms, exercise stress tests, bone density tests, MRI scans and other imaging tests for lower back pain, and are often misleading.
The WISE thing to do, is ask questions. LOTS of questions! And make sure you know the whys and wherefores BEFORE you agree to any medical test.
You especially want to know if there are any possible side effects. If a doctor suggests a test to you, ask WHY?
What will the test accomplish?
Will the results be conclusive?
Is there an alternative to the test?
The reason I’m writing this, is because one of the doctors that I visited recently, suggested that I have a PET scan. I won’t go into details about my health issues, but I decided to do some research and decided that I would NOT have the scan, at this point. I decided to get a second opinion.
Obviously, each person has to decide for themselves, what tests they will agree to have. But, I just think that most of the tests that doctors order are completely unnecessary, based on what I have researched for myself.
What do you think?
6 people like this
5 responses
@dragon54u (31633)
• United States
12 May 17
A lot of docs want their patients tested to cover their own butts so that the patient can's sue them later for not thinking to exhaust every test. Then they complain that they do unnecessary testing.
I agree with you, though, that people need to be involved in their own care and not just trust what a medical professional says. I have always been that way and when I change doctors I come right out and say I am not a passive patient and if they have trouble with that I'll find someone else. I've never had a doctor be displeased when I say that. In fact, they like it because an informed patient makes better decisions and is less likely to sue if something happens to go wrong that is no one's fault but nature and circumstance.
2 people like this
@IreneVincent (15960)
• United States
13 May 17
Rarely can a patient actually sue a doctor anymore, because of all the forms that have to be signed by the patient before receiving any treatment. These forms relieve the doctor of any possibility of being sued.
1 person likes this
@RasmaSandra (98072)
• Daytona Beach, Florida
12 May 17
I totally agree with you and for this reason my hubby and I count our blessing everyday when we do not have to see the men in white coats. Hope everything will be OK and you won't need a test.
1 person likes this

@RasmaSandra (98072)
• Daytona Beach, Florida
13 May 17
@IreneVincent well blessings to you and wishing for you the very best
1 person likes this
@IreneVincent (15960)
• United States
14 May 17
@RasmaSandra Thanks, I'm hoping for good results. I'm a cancer survivor now for SIX years, but who knows what tomorrow may bring.
1 person likes this
@IreneVincent (15960)
• United States
13 May 17
I had some blood work done and I'm waiting on the results of that right now. Perhaps I will know something next week.

@prashu228 (37518)
• India
12 May 17
I agree doctors write all those unnecessary tests and finally negative report
1 person likes this

@prashu228 (37518)
• India
13 May 17
@IreneVincent I dont think we have such thing here
1 person likes this
@IreneVincent (15960)
• United States
13 May 17
Many tests are unnecessary. No wonder health insurance is so high in the USA. What about India? Do you have to pay for health insurance?
1 person likes this
@IreneVincent (15960)
• United States
14 May 17
@prashu228 No health insurance? Does the government pay for health care? A lot of doctors here in the USA are from India.
@IreneVincent (15960)
• United States
12 May 17
At my age, I'm always thinking about it. Every time I see a doctor, that's what they want. Tests. I think its a racket, to tell the truth. Just my humble opinion.
1 person likes this
@responsiveme (22923)
• India
12 May 17
I think you are right.. Some tests are given so that the lab earns some cash
1 person likes this
@IreneVincent (15960)
• United States
13 May 17
Not only does the LAB get paid, but the doctor gets paid when you go back to see him/her for the results. Each office visit generates another charge for the patient.
1 person likes this







