An Atheistic Bible Study Of Genesis Chapter Twenty Seven Jacob Steals A Blessing
@arthurchappell (44941)
Preston, England
August 30, 2017 3:30am CST
Isaac is growing old and infirm. His eyesight fades, and fearing death is imminent, he decides it is time to bestow his final blessing on his older son, Esau. (Isaac actually lives on for several more chapters yet).
Isaac summons Esau and sends him on a simple routine hunting mission, to bring him back some game for one of his favourite meals. When the quest is completed, Isaac promises to bestow his blessings on the lad.
Rebekah, Isaac’s wife, overhears the conversation between Esau and Isaac, and immediately puts quite a wicked scheme into play. She goes to Jacob, the younger son, who has already duped Esau out of the family inheritance, and gets him to pretend to be Esau before his father, with game food she has already prepared, so that Jacob will receive the blessing instead of his brother.
Jacob wears furs and some of his brother’s clothes so he can smell like his hairy brother Esau, and feel like him too if he comes into physical contact with Isaac.
Isaac has suspicions as the scam plays out, asking immediately just how Esau has returned with the catch so quickly after setting out. Jacob attributes it to good luck and blasphemously to God’s divine guidance, which really ought to anger God, but the Creator makes no effort to intervene to save Isaac and Esau from the scam.
Isaac kisses Jacob and blesses him, convinced that he Is Esau. The poetic blessing is a promise that he, Jacob, will be revered by his descendants with a threat to curse any harming any of his descendants while reward await those who honour Jacob’s name.
As soon as Jacob leaves his father’s side, the real Eau inevitably gets home with the awaited captured game, and he is shocked that Isaac won’t bless him too. Isaac tells him that the now bestowed blessing cannot be revoked and as Jacob already has Esau’ birthright, Esau forfeits any right of grievance against his superior brother who now has full divine and legally binding entitlement to lord it over Esau.
In effect, Isaac simply lets Jacob get away with blatant identity theft. Isaac curses Esau to live apart, never find happiness, be denied Heaven, and have to live by violence and sword. Esau is a victim of extreme domestic abuse.
Esau starts openly considering the murder of Jacob, so Rebekah advises Jacob to flee to Haran, and live with her brother, Labon, until Esau calms down.
After Jacob leaves, Rebekah degenerates into simple racial prejudice. She tells her blind husband that she has decided that Hittite women are repulsive and that she is worried now as Jacob might marry a Hittite. She fears that such a marriage will make her own life unworthy of living.
Jacob & Rebekah are seen as Holy Patriarchs and religious role models but their behaviour in virtually destroying Esau is really quite disgusting. Esau’s murderous fury is quite understandable and God is bizarrely silent given that Jacob makes such binding unbreakable oaths in his name. Isaac’s indifference to correcting his mistake or challenging Jacob and Rebekah for their deception is equally repulsive.
Religionists say atheists have no morality while being prepared to set characters like these up as virtuous.
Arthur Chappell
2 people like this
3 responses
@Bluedoll (16770)
• Canada
30 Aug 17
Did you uncover a secret past?
There I'm joking.
Okay, did someone say that you or to you that atheist's have no morality and you have set out to prove that humans are all the same, imperfect. Was this the intent of your article? If so you have made your case and made your point valid. Congrats.
The way you go about justifing your claim though confirms my belief. Atheism is a religion. Church is in. The bible school does preach. At the end of the day everyone makes up their own mind as to what they believe or who they want to follow. For me, I will not follow atheism but as it seems do continue to have dialogue with those that do. - which is no joke
There I'm joking.
Okay, did someone say that you or to you that atheist's have no morality and you have set out to prove that humans are all the same, imperfect. Was this the intent of your article? If so you have made your case and made your point valid. Congrats.
The way you go about justifing your claim though confirms my belief. Atheism is a religion. Church is in. The bible school does preach. At the end of the day everyone makes up their own mind as to what they believe or who they want to follow. For me, I will not follow atheism but as it seems do continue to have dialogue with those that do. - which is no joke1 person likes this
@arthurchappell (44941)
• Preston, England
30 Aug 17
Atheism isn't a religion but a life lived without a religious belief or conviction @Bluedoll
@Bluedoll (16770)
• Canada
30 Aug 17
respectfully @arthurchappell on that point we do differ I just don't want to accept that as a complete definition though I've read this often around the internet.
Don't you think bible study is just that bible study? I don't think it is fair to suggest that someone might have little or no morality based only on their study habits. However any belief we might have that is bible based in my mind can be considered religious in nature simply because the bible is a religious book.
By this I mean we all believe in something we might read. If anything atheims questionings on biblical events should be a good thing if they promote more study and thinking about those events. Questions are good for studies.
I must admit I've not studied chapter twenty seven that intently to comment further though. Sorry about that. Just thought I would share some of my thoughts with you on what you wrote.
1 person likes this
@arthurchappell (44941)
• Preston, England
30 Aug 17
@Bluedoll we could take moral notions from Harry Potter or Thomas The Tank Engine - many Christians however believe the Bible has an exclusive control over our morality which is nonsense

@sumofalltears (3988)
• United States
31 Aug 17
t appears that God is always the exception to the rule in both practice and lack of participation. I have heard it said that God created us in his image, so I guess that explains what happening in the world today.
1 person likes this
@teamfreak16 (43655)
• Denver, Colorado
30 Aug 17
What horrible people, and yet they are revered.
1 person likes this





