Silent treatment

Nairobi, Kenya
April 29, 2022 2:28pm CST
Is it wrong to give someone a silent treatment if they hurt you? I usually do that to my friends and then later on I decide to just talk to them. So I have this friend whom I gave the silent treatment when we were at school on march. I decided to forget about what happened and I talked to her this April. But she doesn't want to start the conversation (we communicate through the phone) so I think she got mad because I gave her the silent treatment. We still don't talk and I decided to cut off our communication. Anyway I just want to hear what your opinion is on giving someone the silent treatment
6 people like this
9 responses
• United States
29 Apr 22
It's true that remaining silent will prevent a person from saying things that could harm or ruin a friendship but by remaining silent, it also sends a message directed at the feelings of the other person. As you've found out, the fallout from the silent treatment can have a similar effect as speaking out in anger or when hurt. If it's a real friend, it's better to risk saying something. Discussing differences may be possible. You never said what prompted giving this person the silent treatment. If something was said by this person and you just cut off communication and then decided to forget about it, it's likely that they haven't forgotten. The silence hurt them as badly as any words could have. I have been married for 37 years and there are times when remaining silent is prudent but a lengthy duration of the treatment is not in the best interest of the relationship.
3 people like this
• Nairobi, Kenya
30 Apr 22
@vikingswest1 when I do that I only want the person to show that they care about me. I just got hurt by somethings she did to me and said about me. I just wanted to get her attention that's all but I guess I was wrong. Probably when we ever get to meet face to face we will get to talk about that issue. I will just have to force myself to stop doing that to people whenever they do something wrong to me but I normally do that to people I like or love. If a stranger or someone I don't like says something bad to me I will definitely talk back.
2 people like this
@sulynsi (2671)
• Canada
30 Apr 22
Really well said We're coming up on our 38th, too
2 people like this
• Nairobi, Kenya
30 Apr 22
@sulynsi what dou you mean by 38 the?
1 person likes this
3 May 22
I think sometimes we can act out in emotion so i can understand not wanting to talk right away, but its important to discuss things and talk them out with friends or lovers to be able to build a stronger bond and taking a little time can help u not express so much with anger, because sometimes it can change the way something sounds to other people. Its a very sad thing to lose a friend, im sorry things went the way they did
2 people like this
4 May 22
Hello @Lexyanne and welcome to myLot. The first thing you should do when you get a chance is to follow the link I have provided to read the site FAQ and Guideline pages so you can become familiar with them. Links to earning information can also be found at the same place.
Have questions about myLot? Help is here!
1 person likes this
• Nairobi, Kenya
4 May 22
@bunnybon7 (50973)
• Holiday, Florida
5 May 22
Well leaving it be for a while may be all you can do. Over time it will work out or you will find a friend to replace this one in your life.
1 person likes this
• Nairobi, Kenya
7 May 22
@bunnybon7 I hope Soo.
1 person likes this
@sulynsi (2671)
• Canada
29 Apr 22
It is not a bad idea to walk away from an argument, before it gets out of control. Proverbs 6:20 says; 'Where there is no wood, the fire goes out, And where there is no slanderer, quarreling ceases' So silence can be a good thing - but refusing to calmly talk out problems is not the way to go. Jesus made the following recommendation: “If, then, you are bringing your gift to the altar and you there remember that your brother has something against you, leave your gift there in front of the altar, and go away; first make your peace with your brother, and then, when you have come back, offer up your gift.”?—Matt. 5:23, 24. But do it privately, and to make peace. “.. go lay bare his fault between you and him alone.' Matthew 18:15
1 person likes this
@sulynsi (2671)
• Canada
30 Apr 22
@Hildasalom I agree - each circumstance is different - if someone has a pattern of abusive or even criminal behaviour, not only would it be wise to not be in communication, but it is wise to not even physically be in their presence for the purpose of giving them the 'silent treatment' I think of that expression as applying to someone with whom you've had a closer relationship, spouse, family or friend. A person at work who mistreats you is hardly going to care if you simply don't talk to them. As I understand the expression, the silence or refusal to communicate is intended to show displeasure with the offender and to punish them. Only someone close to you would care if you blocked them out. So, it follows, that if the relationship is important enough that the silent treatment can be effective, then it is likely a relationship that is valuable enough to work on.
1 person likes this
• Nairobi, Kenya
30 Apr 22
@sulynsi It depends with what the person has done to you, sometimes it is not that easy. Maybe even the other person is the one at fault and doesn't want to make things right.
1 person likes this
• Nairobi, Kenya
30 Apr 22
@sulynsi I am going to change somehow on how I deal with issues, I think it is better if I communicate to get it off my chest.
• Nairobi, Kenya
9 May 22
Silent treatment is not good unless you both do not want to talk to each other. You can both talk again when you are ready to talk to each other. But when someone tries to start the conversation, it is good to answer even if you do not feel like talking so they will know you are not mad at them. If your friend was near you, you can buy a sorry card or make a sorry card then buy a chocolate and give it to your friend or deliver to their home. When your friend reads the sorry card and eat the chocolate it will mean she is not mad at you and she has accepted your apology. Good luck.
1 person likes this
• Nairobi, Kenya
10 May 22
Ok
1 person likes this
@Fa_Maverick (9458)
• Australia
4 May 22
Childish, abusive and passive aggressive behaviour especially if the other person has no idea what they did wrong. Tell them what they did wrong and then distance yourself dont just ignore them and leave them to play detective as to what they did wrong. It can contribute to people developing anxiety issues by the way.
1 person likes this
• Nairobi, Kenya
4 May 22
@Fa_maverick How can it lead to anxiety? That your opinion but sometimes you get too hurt to talk to them
• Australia
4 May 22
@Hildasalom my ex would give me the silent treatment after I did something "wrong" now when my partner goes silent without explanation I get uncomfortable and feel like I have done something wrong. It is a power trip. Ive had people assault me and yet I still have never given the silent treatment.
1 person likes this
@snowy22315 (170019)
• United States
29 Apr 22
It is considered to be abusive, but it kind of depends on how long it goes on. It is better to stay silent than unload with anger and vitriol in my opinion.
@snowy22315 (170019)
• United States
30 Apr 22
@Hildasalom Not a personal example. It isn't mature communication.
1 person likes this
• Nairobi, Kenya
30 Apr 22
1 person likes this
• Nairobi, Kenya
30 Apr 22
@snowy22315 I don't see any abuse in that, maybe what that person did to you hurt you so much that you don't even have anything to talk about with them.
1 person likes this
@Deepizzaguy (94581)
• Lake Charles, Louisiana
29 Apr 22
Advice that I have read about on Twitter is that being silent is better since if you show the person that the words that they use meant to harm you will not have effect if you do not answer them in the same mean way since you give them power to harm you. Silence is golden.
1 person likes this
• Nairobi, Kenya
30 Apr 22
@Deepizzaguy I also agree to that since sometimes arguing with someone is sometimes pointless. If their real intention was to hurt you they feel good since they know you are deeply hurt when you answer them back.
1 person likes this
5 May 22
Well, as a person with anxiety, I can tell you it kind of messes me up when someone is cold to me or gives me the silent treatment. I also get a lot of anxiety talking about something that bothers me. I don’t think is great to give the silent treatment. You should try to comunícate with your friend and be honest about needing space to think about your feelings, rather than just disappearing.
1 person likes this
• Nairobi, Kenya
7 May 22
@mcma143 I guess so....I didn't think it in that way.