Tasting Reese's Oreo peanut butter cup

@JohnRoberts (109441)
Los Angeles, California
November 11, 2026 4:00pm CST
I had never heard of this flavor until plucking one out of a Halloween bowl. Everyone is familiar with the traditional Reese’s peanut cup. The round dark chocolate covered candy with the unique tasting peanut butter flavored filling base. Delicious. The Oreo connection sounded promising. The major difference is the top is white chocolate not dark and does not taste as good. The filling tastes the same as usual. You can detect some microscopic crunchy bits which must be the ground Oreo cookie but no Oreo flavor whatsoever. This candy is a dud and best to stick to the original.
10 people like this
11 responses
@rakski (164840)
• Philippines
5h
I would say I want to taste that but reading your review, nah, I will pass
1 person likes this
@Deepizzaguy (126685)
• Lake Charles, Louisiana
5h
Reese's peanut cup is pretty good to eat.
1 person likes this
@snowy22315 (214935)
• United States
7h
I find these companies go too far messing with the original formula.
1 person likes this
@toniganzon (82859)
• Philippines
6h
This is the first time I've seen a collaboration between Reese's and oreo. Not sure I could find it here. I'm not fan a of Reese's though but my son would like it.
1 person likes this
@Juliaacv (57907)
• Canada
6h
I used to love Reece's peanutbutter cups, but I have to say that they are far too sweet for me these days. I can believe that the ones you show are sweeter, there is actual confectionary's sugar in white chocolate, that would make it sweet enough for most of us to gag just at the thought of it.
1 person likes this
@Traceyjayne (15285)
• United Kingdom
6h
I would keep these separate too ….
1 person likes this
@kareng (83598)
• United States
1h
I'm glad I read this because I was wanting to try them myself! I'll skip it now! Thanks!
@AmbiePam (133043)
• United States
4h
This wouldn’t even tempt me.
@RasmaSandra (102288)
• Daytona Beach, Florida
7h
At one time I ate so much peanut butter I could not even look at a jar, But I was once a bit fan of Reese's. Too bad the Oreo connection doesn't work,
1 person likes this
@teamfreak16 (48785)
• Denver, Colorado
4h
I haven't seen these yet. I know because I always try anything Reese's. I guess I'll stay away if I see any.
• United States
3h
Originals are often the best