PIERGIORGIO WELBY: EUTHANASIA OR NOT?

Tweet

Piergiorgio Welby has muscular dystrophy and is paralysed An Italian court has adjourned to decide whether to allow a terminally ill man to die, in a landmark case. The man, Piergiorgio Welby, has muscular dystrophy and is paralysed. He wants doctors to be allowed to turn off his artificial respirator. The high-profile case has sparked fierce debate in mostly-Roman Catholic Italy, where euthanasia is illegal and the Church forbids it. The judge is expected to deliver her verdict within a week. Mr Welby is confined to bed, is fed through a tube and speaks through a computer that reads his eye movements. He appealed to President Giorgio Napolitano in October for euthanasia to be legalised so that he could then request it. He wants his artificial respirator turned off and to be given sedatives to ease his pain until he dies. The case hinges on whether Mr Welby is being forcibly administered life-sustaining medical treatment - which is against Italy's constitution. Prosecutors told the court on Monday that Mr Welby had the right to have the respirator turned off, but that doctors also had the right to turn the machine back on if he was suffering."The problem in this case is to know if we are really faced with a case of prolonging life by artificial means," Javier Lozano Barragan, president of the Vatican's pontifical health council, told La Repubblica newspaper. Prime Minister Romano Prodi's centre-left government is divided over the issue. His coalition includes Catholics as well as socialists, who have come out strongly in favour of Mr Welby's right to refuse treatment. The centre-right opposition is against switching off Mr Welby's respirator. Euthanasia and doctor-assisted suicide have been legalised in the Netherlands, Belgium, Switzerland, but remain illegal in much of the rest of the world. Do you think that switch off machine in this case is a murder? I think that in this case nothing can be done by medicine, because Welby is at the end of his life and every day is a day of pain. he survive because he can breathe artificially.. but is this life? It's a different question from Terry Schiavo case. in this case Welby want to die. What do you think about this case?