The Biggest Loser; Positive goal for the overweight or self-esteem killing trash

@Kaorin (756)
Australia
December 24, 2006 3:53am CST
I can see both sides of th argument. In case you don't know, The Biggest Loser is a weekly television show in which very overweight people are put in a situation where they lose weight on a 'farm' type setting, where all their challenges are based around exercise and such. I can see that the show is meant to promote healthy weight and a healthy lifestyle, and these overweight people are learning this while the audience is too. Also, the end result, where the overweight people generally lose a HUGE amount of their weight, is a goal for other people watching at home; a sort of 'if they can do it, do can I' However, I can also see how badly this show is biased against people who are overweight. The contestants are not really viewed as whole, happy people until the end, where they have lost most of their excess weight. They are viewed as somehow incomplete, hindered, or lonely people while they are carrying their extra pounds. I've known a lot of peole that got very angry at the underlying message that 'everyone will feel better when they are thinner'. I can see and agree with both aspects of this show; however, do you have a particular opinion of the show and how overweight people are represented in it?
1 response
@cooky28 (739)
• Australia
24 Dec 06
yes there are some real chubby ones on the program i think it would very uncomfortable to be that size
@Kaorin (756)
• Australia
24 Dec 06
True, but however it's not really what I was was asking. Do you think that the show is biased against being overweight as they protray the overweight contestants as unhappy and incomplete about themselves until they become thin?