Old Or New?

@Mickie30 (2631)
December 24, 2006 11:06am CST
Did you prefer the old Charlie and the Chocolate Factory or the new one with Johnny Depp? I prefer the old one.
6 responses
@karixie (121)
• Philippines
20 Oct 07
Of course the new one for it is the version from my generation. However, I would give applause to the old one for producing such movie even if advanced and improved props and sets still weren't present then.
@Mickie30 (2631)
27 Oct 07
Hi yeah I know what you mean the old one is my generation, but I still really enjoyed the new one as well.
@ersmommy1 (12596)
• United States
9 Nov 07
How funny to come across this question while watching Willy Wonka and the Chocolate factory with my 4 yr old. (the old one) My Favorite! and my daughters! the remake scared her. While watching the dvd she begged oh please put in the other one mommy. We own it. Highly recommend the Sing Along portion in the special features !
@helchi (3)
• Brazil
17 Apr 07
i prefer the new version one of the largest reasons is me to be the actor's johnny depp fan but in my opinion the film has more mystery than the first,the willy wonka is shadier (as it would be a man 15 years alone in manufactures with a lot of oompa luumpas) but everything depends on taste,if the person likes film more well in the style "cheerful" she has to choose the first,but if you goes one more style "same being more infantile taste of a little of sense " she has to choose the second.
@emeraldisle (13143)
• United States
24 Dec 06
I never saw the second one but mostly because from the commercials I saw it just didn't look that good. Also from others I heard on line they told me not to bother wasting my time with it. I loved the original and maybe eventually I'll try and watch the remake. If I do I hope it's better then the commericials led it to be.
• India
24 Dec 06
didnt watch the new one but loved the old one. it was my fav when me was a kid
@makem0ney (293)
24 Dec 06
yes i think the old one is alot better