My five year old

girl in window - girl looking out window
United States
December 30, 2006 11:50pm CST
I have a five year old daughter who is beginning to lie a lot. She understands why we are not suppose to do this yet she still can not keep from doing this. I have tried many ways to make her stop and none of these have worked for me. Please help me to find a way to make her stop lying all of the time.
2 people like this
4 responses
@madlees (1377)
• India
15 Feb 08
Have you ever scolded your daughter when she came out with the truth when she did something wrong ? If you had, it must be still there in her inner mind. The scare of getting scolded or punished make kids lie. You have to tell your baby that "if you tell the truth you'll not get scolded or punished but if we find out you lied about anything you'll get scolded or punished" Something like this might have happened which is there. Try to find out what it is and correct it. It might as well help her to come out with the truth. My kids have been like due to fear about getting scoldings from me. After I told them and made them understand the point, they have never. you can also try this one out.
@rosey3223 (1566)
• United States
16 Feb 08
I have to disagree. My child has been lying since he was able to talk and now he is 8. For the first 4 years that he did it I talked to him because he was little and I knew from my own experience that scolding him would scare him and I didn't want him to be scared of me...I wanted him to know that he could talk to me and come to me when ever he needed me!! So I talked to him and explained to him that it was wrong and the consequences that came from lying. BUT HE STILL LIES!! So, I have no clue anymore!!
@raghwagh (1527)
• India
31 Dec 06
Baby Girl - An innosent baby girl
I think that you must explain your daughter the disadvantages of telling lie and benifits of being true.Also you must tell her some examples as to what happens when one tells a lie.Also Whenever she tells a lie tell dont scold her but tell her that she spoke untru and everyone knows it and she should not do the same thing agai.Also keep a friendly relation between you and her.She should feel comfortable to take with you, so that she will not speak lie.Currently she seems to be afread of you because of which children speak lie.Create a confidence within her and dont always scold rather explain her by having a good talk with her.Be a good friend rather than a strict mother.
1 person likes this
• United States
1 Jan 07
thank you very much and I think that I will defiantly try this and once again thank you for your advise
@rosey3223 (1566)
• United States
16 Feb 08
Oh my gosh!! I've been dealing with this with my 8 year old since he's been old enough to talk!! I don't know why either because I've never lied to him!! Not even about Santa Claus!! I've told him that it's not nice and yada yada yada, but he STILL LIES!! Now I think it's more out of pure habit and also the fact that he's scared to get into trouble (which we've already told him that lying gets him into even MORE trouble) than anything else. I wish I knew what to tell you or knew how to help, but since I'm going through the same thing I don't think I can. However, he is starting to go to counseling so maybe they will help me understand why he is doing this and give me some tips on how to make him stop. Then I can come back here and try to help you!! Who knows!!
@rosey3223 (1566)
• United States
16 Feb 08
That's how mine is/was too!! I mean so bad that if I asked him if he wiped his butt after going #2, he'd say "no". But then you look in his underwear and there is the evidence that he didn't. Now I've scolded him for not wiping, but have never scolded because he lied about it!! I just don't understand what the point was of lying in the first place if you know darn well that I either know better or that I'm gonna catch you in the lie!! Now he's so bad at lying that I can just tell right off the bat if he's planning on lying or not...now to me that's REALLY sad!!
• United States
16 Feb 08
i never lie to my kids either but for some reason she thinks that she has to and it is always about stupid stuff that doesn't even matter.
1 person likes this
@chertsy (3797)
• United States
16 Feb 08
I wonder if this would work. Since she's not grasping why your not suppose to lie, maybe turn it on her. Out of the blue, say to her, sweetie want to go to ( her favorite place ) then once she's ready, sit her down and explain to her that your not taking her to her favorite place, then bluntly say sorry but I lied. Then sit her down and ask her if she feels hurt over this, and if she says yes, then say, sweetie, now you know how mommy feels when you lie to me. I know this will break your heart to do this to her, but if you don't, she will think it's funny and next thing you know you will hear some crazy tales. I should know, I used to be like your daughter, lol. When I was around 4, I told a really wild tale that my dad actually believed and was mad at my mom. That was the end of my fibs/ white lies/wild tales, because I was upset that I had made my dad upset. It was a good one to boot. I told my brothers when they got home from school that my mom left with a man, and he took our to go shopping before my dad got home. Well, my mom did go shopping, but she went with my aunt. Well, when dad got home, my brothers told him what I said. Oh my goodness my dad was mad. What stunk, I had to do the walk of shame and go tell my dad the truth. Luckily I was little and he didn't punish me to bad, just told me that my lies hurts those who I tell the lies to. Maybe what I said helps, honestly I hope it does.