Why can't we be in charge of deleting posts in our own discussions?
By sunshinecup
@sunshinecup (7871)
January 1, 2007 7:20am CST
I think it would solve so many problems if we had the ability to delete those posts we spend so much time on reporting, as long as they were in our own discussion. This would get rid of the irrelevant responses as well as the copy and past jerks that are running wild on here.
Then if someone feels they were unfairly removed, Mylot could investigate those complaints, which I am sure would be fewer than the ones they are looking into now. It's like flipping it.
What do you think? Dumb or a good idea?
5 people like this
29 responses
@Asylum (47893)
• Manchester, England
1 Jan 07
I can see the benefit with what you suggest, but there are downsides to this as well.
It would be far too easy for someone to remove responses that did not agree with their opinion or they disapproved of, which is not in the interest of either the site or the members. Despite your suggestion of an appeal proceedure, quite often the respondant may not be aware that their post has been deleted and thus would be unable to rectify the situation. How often have you found it difficult to trace the response you made to a popular discussion? This would also increase the workload for Mylot admin who would have to mediate in such a case.
I accept that the present system is not perfect, but the site is improving and the problems are diminishing as time goes by.
3 people like this
@re08dz (1941)
• Australia
1 Jan 07
While in theory this is a great idea, because there's money involved it would end up causing way too many problems.
People may start deleting posts that didn't agree with their opinions, or because they didn't like the responder etc. then throw in the fact that it means people aren't credited so they're losing money well I shudder to think of the repercussions :-)
Perhaps if there was someone to restrict the visibility of those posts until they can be verified as okay or deleted by the admin etc.
2 people like this
@sunshinecup (7871)
•
1 Jan 07
Oh I like that much better! That way instead of us watching those posts get to set there with credit, they would go in a holding cell, until approved by Mylot. Yes, yes, yes, much better idea!
2 people like this
@whiteheather39 (24403)
• United States
1 Jan 07
Never thought of it that way. Good response!
2 people like this
@thinkingoutloud (6127)
• Canada
2 Jan 07
There are websites out there, primarily directed at kids and teens, where posts are definitely moderated before they become visible, mainly to protect young people from viewing inappropriate content. Many times it's a budget issue for the website owner as to whether or not they can actually afford to pay enough moderators to read every single post. With the amount of posting activity on myLot, I can see that it would definitely have to be a consideration :)
Having said that, a common counterpoint is "then just use volunteers as moderators." This, as much as it sounds super, has been proven time and time again to be really ineffective, for many of the same reasons that have already been posted here -- subjective moderation (where people delete any post they don't agree with), preferential treatment (where posts are left up to boost certain members' post counts) and even plain old poor quality moderation because people don't always take volunteer work seriously (not showing up to do their work, not bothering to actually read the content).
It's a tough call for a site owner to decide which way to go.
2 people like this

@swaroop_sv2003 (531)
• India
1 Jan 07
I don't think it is a good idea to delete others irrelevant reply in ours discussion. Its always better to report abuse for such replies. If we go on deleting such replies ,those who post those replies is not affected in any way and they may go on posting such replies. I feel that mylot payment is based on the quality of ones post instead of number of post (which i am not yet sure about). Not only that if the author who started discussion got the right to delete any stupid reply, how much replies will he or she deletes? If it is the report abuse then any mylot user can report abuse on any irrelevant replies they comes through.
2 people like this

@JC1969 (1224)
• United States
1 Jan 07
sunshinecup,
I have to agree with you hear. It is really frustrating because many who have violated numerous myLot writers guidelines have been doing it for quite a while and have not been removed. I have come across several people in recent days who have way over 1000 for their rating, and yet the majority of their posts are plagiarized, copyright infringed, and other violations. They are still members and it is also likely that they have even seen a pay-out from myLot. This means myLot has actually been paying these scammers. I know I have reported many people who are engaging in violations and many are still here. I think myLot is slow to react on our complaints, and maybe they need more manpower to address the abuse problems.
@swaroop_sv2003 (531)
• India
1 Jan 07
Is mylot admins so generous to pay those people who post replies which is marked abuse? No response from mylot may be because they have to check out all those abused posts and then take an action. Why i said this is because many users have found their number of posting getting reduced and this i hope is because mylots is reacting against those whose posts have been marked abuse by other users. Maybe the idea of delete button would be a good additional feature in mylot.
2 people like this
@sunshinecup (7871)
•
1 Jan 07
The problem with the way it is now, many are gettin really angry, and fairly so. Many loyal posters are following the rules, yet others are not and the reporting on those, are not being addressed. Not to mention from the eyes view, violators ARE getting credit and keeping it. Violations from personal attacks to copying others posts are setting in place for days now. No response from Mylot to those that have reported them. Something has got to change.
2 people like this

@Thomas73 (1467)
• Switzerland
1 Jan 07
Your idea is indeed very good, but it's also a door open to all sorts of abuse. As was said above, some people may delete responses that they "don't like" or go against their opinion, which would reduce vastly the freedom of speech on myLot. The current system seems to be working, so "why fix it if it ain't broke?", as the saying goes.
The admins of myLot seem to be doing a pretty good job.
2 people like this
@swaroop_sv2003 (531)
• India
1 Jan 07
You got a very good point out there. Many types of replies may come up in a discussion. If a person did not like any reply for his discussion then he would surely delete it.
3 people like this
@JC1969 (1224)
• United States
1 Jan 07
The problem isn't just the frivolous small "yes" and "no" discussions and responses. There is a bigger problem with members who plagiarize and copyright infringe from other websites which is a serious offense that can get myLot into alot of trouble legally if they keep these posts on their site. Also, another problem comes from members that copy and paste a response that someone else already made and try to pass it off as their own. Then there are other members that will use a generic made up response that is irrelevant to the discussion, but they will post it as their response in every discussion.
You see there are numerous abuses going on here at myLot, and because there are so many who are here to scam myLot for money, it is hard to report them all, and it is even harder for myLot to address all the abuses they are being reported.
These people, in many cases, have already been paid by myLot because myLot didn't discover or receive an abuse report. For this site to be responsible, we must all do our share of reporting violations. It will hopefully weed out the people here scamming for earnings.
2 people like this

@sunshinecup (7871)
•
1 Jan 07
I have to agree with everyone, abuse would most likely occur. I like re08dz, suggestion much better. Mylot decided what does and does not get deleted, but the post in question goes in to a holding, without credit to the poster and out of site until they make that call. It could automatically happen, when we report the abuse.
2 people like this

@vibhu12321 (381)
• India
1 Jan 07
nice topic man , really nice one ,
because i also wants to delete some
of the topics started gy me because
of one reason or the other.i search
a lot how to delete topic but cant
delete them,.
2 people like this
@anjuscor (1266)
• India
1 Jan 07
I really think your idea should be implemented on Mylot. Even though we are demanding for many features in Mylot, i believe that it would help All the users and number of users will get increased. It will help a lot fo users in many ways, so Mylot will also grow with all the features in. This is what i think, to satisfy Customer's needs and to grow well, Mylot can implement this idea.
2 people like this
@dutchess67 (917)
• United States
2 Jan 07
I couldn't agree with you more! I get so aggrivated when I get spam responses to my questions. Last night I had 1 guy that was going aaround posting happy new year crap on everything he could find. That sort of thing shouldn't be allowed at all.
2 people like this
@SarahEC (545)
• United States
2 Jan 07
I think it is a good idea. Maybe as the site gets more and more members they will give us more options. I also think it would be nice to be able to search the replies to a topic so you don't have to go through pages and pages to get to your post if you don't remember what page it was on.
@hiitssomu (657)
• United States
1 Jan 07
this is can be a good idea, but what if you delete all the replies you have got for your discussion. You should not have the judgement for which reply is relevant and which is not, that can only be done by the readers of the discussion. you may always say that i didn't like this reply, isn't it ? it may lead to kind of scam after sometime, what will happen if you know some user personally and want not to show any reply from him/her! let decide the good response by the reader, not by the owner of the discussion.
2 people like this
@Priceless (1277)
•
1 Jan 07
Its a bad Idea. Others would spend time posting, And their post may deserve a nice amount of cash, But because you don't agree with their views they miss out, If the post is really insulting or spam or whatever their is a report button, and a opinion to give a negative rating, Those are the features you should use, it would also be very hard on the system seeing as we'd all then be called moderators, And people who have very individual views would miss out on loads so no. This is a bad idea and it will never be established.
2 people like this
@edelweiss (1929)
• India
1 Jan 07
because posts involve payments assosciated with them, so a person cannot be given control of deleting others posts. and when it comes to that then people will rather start their discussions than responding to others posts.
2 people like this
@whiteheather39 (24403)
• United States
1 Jan 07
What a great idea..We could really help make myLot a first class site by policing our own discussion.
2 people like this
@iknowitall (455)
• United States
2 Jan 07
Yes i wish we could I would like to delete all my good discussions that no one responded to just to get th clutter up....
1 person likes this




















