Dhoni or Dinesh Kartik?

dhoni is eligible for wk now in india team

Dhoni is better in one day cricket but in tests I think Dinesh Kartik is the one who seems to be more suited due to his class.

i think dhoni is best with bat n gloves....

Depends on what form of the game India are playing.....for the ODI's definitely Dhoni is a better choice but for test matches,Dinesh Kaarthik maybe the better choice

i think so dhoni is the eligble wicketkeeper

Dinesh Karthik is the best wicketkeeper for Indian team at the Present. Dhoni should also be in the team as a batsman fielder. Dinesh has proven his keeping abilities in the last test vs South Africa, with his stretching catches and the enthusiasm and enrgy behind stumps. Such a killer instinct is missing in Dhoni. But he is a good batsman and should be retained as a batsman.

i think both are good and both should be in the team, what do you say?

dude Dhoni is the man.he performs consistently.i dont want to take anything away from karthik but dhoni's the best man for this job.

i will surely go for dhoni.he had proven his talent before by holding the record of most runs ever by a wicketkeeper.he had highlighted india with his wicketkeeping performance and his sixes.this jharkhand boy is off for a new start of his career and has got the break through.wish him good luck in future.

offcourse Dhoni is the man