Would You Accept an Online Proposal?

Japan
January 2, 2007 10:32pm CST
Recently, i've started many heaps of friends on the internet! I feel quite close to some of them and I want to know more about them. While I haven't developed a deep relationship with any of them - yet - I would like to know how people would feel if they were proposed to online? Imagine you knew the person very well but their proposal was on messenger rather than in person. Would you accept?
9 people like this
138 responses
• United States
3 Jan 07
Never. People can claim to be anything they want to, even men claiming to be women and vice versa, under the anonymity of the internet. There is no way I would trust someone online to be exactly what they claimed to be until I met them in person, especially when it came to a subject as serious as marriage. To err on the side of caution is simply the best act of self preservation you can exercise.
1 person likes this
• India
3 Jan 07
I completely agree with you. You can never trust a person...whom u have never met...atleast not in today's world.
• Zambia
3 Jan 07
It all depends on what you are looking for on the net. I have seen relationships that have evolved from the Internet. I actually met a lady online. I'm in Zambia and she is in USA and we got to met. And I have met some fellow locals that I met on the Internet. However, I agree that others may claim to be what they are not. And some have ulterior motives. One just has to be cautious on going about it all.
• India
3 Jan 07
Buddy, do not accept the online proposals for marriage/love/date, which will end in great loss! As there's no face to face deal in the internet community, people use it as a medium to cheat others. Try to speak to people face to face who propose you and then come to a conclusion dear!
@t3ChNo (31)
• Philippines
3 Jan 07
you really can't trust someone regarding this matter in the cyberweb
1 person likes this
• United States
3 Jan 07
I agree with you there!
@banta78 (4326)
• India
3 Jan 07
Hello fren, i don't you are serious. I mean through internet we can only chat with the other person, get to know each other to an extent but to really find if the other person is genuine and not a prankster ( who knows guy might act as girl and vice versa!!). Besides i feel we can only find out if we genuinely like the other person only after face to face interaction by meeting in person. As we know so much about the other person's body language, there looks and physcial attributes, mental attributes, mannerisms, by meeting in person and i like it that way. so for me i would only like to chat online, make good friends but nothing serious unless i meet in person. Moreover long distance relationships formed online is not easy to maintain in real life unless people move in together.
1 person likes this
3 Jan 07
It's very flattering that you feel that way, but unfortunately I'm happily living with my partner of 7 years, and would not be open to any such proposals. Don;t be too despondent, though. However, be careful, as many internet users are not 100% honest and open, some even invent complete new lives for themselves under the veil of anonymity offered by the web. That said, there's no reason you can't continue to make new long-distance friendships - a bit like a PenPal, but faster. PS Don't bother with short-skirts, they only attract shallow men. the kind you wouldn't want to know for long.
1 person likes this
@goratiu (11)
• Romania
3 Jan 07
It's very important to meet the person before your next step. I have a friend who met his girlfriend online and after 6 months they met eachother. They are still together for more than 3 years and probaly they will get married.
1 person likes this
• United States
3 Jan 07
I agree. You can certainly meet someone online that you will eventually marry, but you SHOULD meet them before taking such a great step. The ironic thing is, even though I agree that it is important to meet first, I had an online boyfriend and accepted his proposal without ever having met. It was a strange situation. Highly dependent and slightly obsessive-- it wasn't a very healthy relationship, I don't think. He agreed to it, apparently, because he thought that that was what I wanted and was going along, and I agreed to it because I have a hard time saying no and I didn't want to hurt his feelings. I do think we took it seriously, eventually... But we didn't really know each other. That is, he knows me very well, even now, but only about certain things... I shared some parts of myself with him BECAUSE we hadn't met. I don't know what would have happened if we had. Like I said, we were very dependent on one another in an unhealthy way. Very jealous, not really happy... It was the type of relationship one enters out of depression in order to distract yourself from whatever pain you happen to be feeling, and in order to avoid loneliness. Of course I'm babbling on. I want to explain it, I suppose. We thought we needed each other. We thought we knew each other-- and did, to a certain extent. But talking online takes away something-- touch, body language, all of that. Even with web cam or voice chat, you're missing something. They don't always show exactly what you would see in the real world. You can't REALLY know someone from online conversations. You can't pick up on some of their habits, you can't read subtle clues from their body about certain things... Just think of how often someone might misunderstand what the other is saying, based on his or her interpretation of the written text. Tone conveys a LOT. Anyways, the original question was if you would-- and I did, so yes. But I also know that I was really waiting to meet him, before I considered any of it real. Today, I have a hard time even considering him to have been my first "real" boyfriend. I'm with someone else now, and I view HIM as being the first, in most aspects of what a relationship is. Internet dating doesn't work out, if you can never meet that person. (Well, there were other issues involved, but there's no need to bring those into this.) So, yeah... It wasn't the smartest thing to do, but I think I accepted it as a placeholder, so to speak. Once we met and got to know each other in real life, we could make it all real. Of course, that never happened.
@CyborgMC (173)
• United States
3 Jan 07
Hell no. In fact, I'm even skeptical about meeting up with someone that you met online. Too many drawbacks. A large percentage of communication is through body language, you can be incredibly deceptive through just words alone, even talking on the phone is not as good as face to face when it comes to avoiding misunderstandings. And if someone you knew for real tries to propose to you online, or through a messenger, I don't know, that's kinda cheesy. Unless doing it that way holds some real special significance for the two of you, that strikes me as really lazy and lame. You'd better tell him to man up and give you a real propossal!
3 Jan 07
lol no not online unless youve acctualy met the person we heare these storys everyday about funny chacrters online so be carefull!!!
• India
3 Jan 07
Never. People can claim to be anything they want to, even men claiming to be women and vice versa, under the anonymity of the internet. There is no way I would trust someone online to be exactly what they claimed to be until I met them in person, especially when it came to a subject as serious as marriage. To err on the side of caution is simply the best act of self preservation you can exercise.
• India
27 Jan 07
I accept for friendship not for marrige ...
• Northern Mariana Islands
3 Jan 07
It depends, If I like her of course I will accept. Some people are like that they dont have the courage to say it face to face. That's why in my place there are many spinster because they dont know how to court or just dont have the courage to say to the girl so they end up old and alone. At least now there are many ways to express your feelings, you can express it by a song, by cards, by flowers, you see nowadays there are many options. Here in my place of employment(CNMI)everybody is very open. Just one look and you are already engage. There are many Japanese women working here and I find them very sweet and approachable. I guess that's what happen if you stay in an Island for a long time everybody become's your friend.
@xprmnt (35)
• Greece
3 Jan 07
I agree, It always depends. How well you know the person before the email. But I would always prefer when its done in person
• India
27 Jan 07
If i know her well and understands me ,then i would accept her proposal.
@rhie0216 (289)
• Philippines
26 Jan 07
i rather not accept, i mean even if i am a man, i do believe that there is only true people in a chat. Seldom you will find people who are really sincere and honest with themselves, they usually hide in those nicknames and you wouldn't even be sure if what they are telling you are really true.
• India
20 Jan 07
If found suitable in all respects, I can accept. But there is a little chance of accepting online proposal. Once meeting is essential to know fully each other.
• India
27 Jan 07
why not? no problem at all online discussions is very important, those who are using internet, send about u, take about her, share your ideas, views, thoughts, tell him about ur family if some one can do and tieup thier understanding, never tell a lie between discussion, if transparancy is there than no problem to accept online proposal.
• United States
27 Jan 07
Hi Kumiko, I'm glad to have stumbled upon your question because I was proposed to on MSN Messenger by my now-husband! It was exactly two years ago when it happened. I was in Singapore and he, in California. It was shortly after I had flown to California to spend Christmas and New Year's with him. I guess you could say that we had a good two weeks together because he decided he wants more so he proposed. Of course, he called me after we got offline to propose over the phone. He was so nervous that he fumbled over his speech. I politely asked him to prepare a better one and call me back another day. And he did - two more times before I said, "Yes." We have a good laugh whenever we reminisce about this. It sure is a good conversational piece at cozy social gatherings and a great story to tell our future generations!
• United States
28 Jan 07
I definitely wouldn't except an online proposal. I am to much of a traditional person. He would have to do the whole down on one knee thing.
@shyam221 (519)
• India
19 Jan 07
not one shot i will take some time to decide and after some time i will take decision depending upon the reaction of partner online with me...... it might be fake some time so have to take care of it.do have to find all the correct information about partner and accordingly you have to react to matter... but 50 % of the things are aways fake so be prepare for that........
• India
20 Jan 07
no.. bcz i dont believe in those all things////
@sanjeev9 (115)
• India
19 Jan 07
ya its right to accept online proposal because in online proposal u can also know about the person's nature and behaviour so online proposal is also right
@darkraze (43)
• Philippines
19 Jan 07
Absolutely not! A gentleman will never do that. I believe that proposals should be done personally to a lady. It would be a memorable experience coming from someone you love dearly. Besides, personal proposals are more sincere than those online. It is also possible that he may not be the one who sent the proposal. Imagine the embarassment. Good Luck! ^-^
• India
19 Jan 07
i ll accept it only if i know all the things i want to know abt her and she knows all the things abt me and it should be two way love...
• Greece
20 Jan 07
what do you mean by "imagine you knew the other person very well?" its not possible to accept a proposal without ever being with someone in person. feel him, touch him, spend a day...