do u think peter jackson should have directed movies like harry potter?

@vik24587 (144)
India
January 6, 2007 9:44am CST
u all knw peter jackson is director of lord of rings, do u think he can do much better with movies like harry potter and star wars?
5 responses
• United States
7 Jan 07
I think Peter Jackson would have done great directing Harry Potter. If he was directing it, they might have had the same director all the way. But dont even try to touch Star Wars. That is George Lucas all the way. He made those movies what they are.
1 person likes this
@vik24587 (144)
• India
9 Jan 07
but atleat the movies would have in order!
@Kalachia (230)
• United States
7 Jan 07
OMG I'm glad I saw this question! I've thought that Peter should've done the Harry Potter movies since the first one disappointed me. I'm not saying they're as bad as I thought before I actually paid attention to them, but comparing the work done on LoTR to HP, I know it would've been tons better. The animation, the actors, hell, even the script probably. And Peter wouldn't have left out key parts of the movies either, most of which are important to the story line.
1 person likes this
@Gruzzle (294)
9 Jan 07
An interesting Idea, how about some others like Sam Raimi or David Fincher. They could do a really dark version. Or maybe Tony Scott for amazzing action sequences.
@vik24587 (144)
• India
10 Jan 07
well we have already seen dark visions now i think we need some action and new type of graphics
@httpme (49)
• France
9 Jan 07
why not.but,then,maybe its kinda scary adventure type of harry potter =D just look at LOTR,its an adult film.compare with harry potter,its for children and teenagers.
@waynet (2650)
6 Jan 07
No, he does just fine without having to do other peoples franchises/ideas, he's more on the lines of a director now that can afford to do any film he would like to do and I'd rather look forward to something original as opposed to what other people may expect or want him to direct.