which is your favourite / the best album by metallica?

@shogunly (1403)
Libya
January 9, 2007 8:38am CST
i personally think it's the "and justice for all" album , inspite of the "black" album being their most famous and successful one . although i'm no expert, i think the "justice for all" album has some of the best pieces written for the electric guitar EVER made . the feel and atmosphere of the songs is unique and the music often faithfully conveys the message the lyrics stand for . i also think the band has been on a steady downhill after the "load" album , maybe from unsuccessful attempts to become more mainstream ,compromising the "flavour" fans were used to .
1 person likes this
15 responses
• United States
9 Jan 07
I'd have to say I agree and justice for all is the best
1 person likes this
@shogunly (1403)
• Libya
29 Jan 07
you obviously have great taste .thank you .
• India
9 Jan 07
mine is "ride the lightning".....\m/
@shogunly (1403)
• Libya
27 Jan 07
Hey ride the lightning is great ! I love every one of the songs on the album , except maybe "fight fire with fire " , the best is "fade to black" it makes me really calm (and angry and sad) . call of cthulu great instrumental ."trapped under ice" also one of the best songs on the album .
@kaki_388 (162)
• India
18 Sep 07
difficult 2 pic really..most f deyr earlier albums r damn gud...ride d lightnin..n justice 4 all...black album....luv alla dem....id have 2 chose a best of f deyrs wid about 30 tracks really...luv dese guys..rock on guys!!
1 person likes this
• India
21 Jan 07
i think and justice for all and master of puppets both are their best albums and my favs too..
1 person likes this
@k73hrx (81)
• Indonesia
10 Jan 07
it's hard to decide. every album is superb. my first album is Black album, and it's a great album. but soon after i listen to Justice, i realize that Black is not their greatest. i love load and reload too, and garage inc. "Low man liryc" is so touchy. and i luv "Turn the page" and "Astronomy" although those are cover song. if you guys don't mind, i choose all metallica album as my fav...:D
1 person likes this
• Italy
9 Jan 07
I DON'T LIKE METTALICA,BUT SOME TIMES LISTEN THEY
1 person likes this
@netinet7 (43)
• Israel
2 Feb 07
i Dont Like metallica but some times i listen they mucik...
@Eisenherz (2909)
• Portugal
4 Feb 07
That's a bit conttradicting there..
• Saudi Arabia
29 Jan 07
In my opinion, ReLoad is really the best, look at the lyrics the music it is the closest to perfection i love all of their works and i do believe that some the old stuff has 2 be revisited using the new guitars and drums i guess that must be discussed in detail
@shogunly (1403)
• Libya
1 Feb 07
That's a great idea , raven . Although I do not agree on the best album , I think this deserves best response .
@acc3nture (139)
• Philippines
27 Jan 07
i also am for the AND JUSTICE FOR ALL album for its cool sounds and heavy metal-natured tracks, especially their song ONE, we played that song in our annual BATTLE OF THE BANDS competition back in high school days, it opened the sleeping rockers out of students there. i still have their album in my cd collection
@shogunly (1403)
• Libya
27 Jan 07
ONE is one of the best songs Metallica ever made and has been chosen as one of the "100 BEST GUITAR SOLOS" ever . A nice aspect in the music of the song is who it starts with a sad,lamenting ,slow melody as the story of the ex-soldier is told , then transforms into a fast loud play towards the end as anger becomes the theme of the lyrics .
@fast4ward (228)
• Canada
27 Jan 07
I love every metallica album but my favorite one has to be ...and justice for all for the general quality of the music/lyrics.
@shogunly (1403)
• Libya
27 Jan 07
I think so ,too . SHORTEST STRAW !!(pullled for YOU !!)
• India
27 Jan 07
Hmmm.. my opinion is a lil different frm urs. I personally think their first album 'kill em all' was their best. There's some crazy guitar work in tat courtesy dave mustaine and even cliff is brilliant. Metal militia, four horsemen, seek and destroy, hit the lights..dese are among my favourites
@shogunly (1403)
• Libya
27 Jan 07
Its a great album , raw and crude guitar . But the solos are nowhere NEAR ..justice for all....!
• India
2 Feb 07
yes i do agree with u..justice 4 all has awsum guitar fills...the lyrics are exellent too i also like kill em all and black album.
@shredded (38)
• India
2 Feb 07
justic for all has got some and master of puppets really cool....but am not too much into their music.....keep on rocking where ever you guys are....lets make a rock out for a better place to stay........\m/....
• India
1 Feb 07
Yah justice for all rocked and i dont think some one can be as great as metallica, da guitar makes ure heart pump adrenaline everywhere in the body;)
@dbeast (1498)
• India
29 Jan 07
i like them all.anything by metallica is real cool.i love the black album.i feel the master of puppets too is good.they have some awesome tracks on them.and justice for all is not bad too but i prefer the black album anyday.it has a mixture of tracks ranging on different emotions.rock on.