8 year boy is punished for stealing bread

boy punished for stealing bread - 8 year old boy punished for stealing bread.
India
January 10, 2007 7:51am CST
a boy is punished in iran for stealing bread. he lost his hand due to this. the punishment was a car rolled over his left hand.all this happen in front of lot of people and in the name of islam. no religion give permission for such brutality. what do u think about it?
5 responses
@kiwimac (323)
• New Zealand
12 Jan 07
You are aware that this is an urban legend and that the photo was actually of a group of street performers? Try the following URL: http://tinyurl.com/qz2mc
@aiguy01 (588)
• United States
12 Jan 07
Good catch!
27 Jan 07
that is againts islam and muhammad pbuh teachings if that was true the people who did this should be punished
@navinshan (3933)
• Canada
10 Jan 07
I have to say this in middle east countries like iran, in the name of islam, they have a very rigid laws and regulation by which they have severe punishments for those who commit crimes, if a boy is stealing a bread , they should understand that he is poor and is unable to afford it, and should let him go, instead what is the purpose of chopping his hand, i don't think there re going to gain anything out of this.
@ghalayini (122)
• Australia
18 Jan 07
That is horrible. I cannot understand that being done to a fellow human being, regardless of their religious situation.
@SirPyan (429)
• Malaysia
27 Jan 07
Hmmm, first time I heard something like this. May I know which source you got the news? Car rolled over his hand? Sounds like unauthorized public justice to me. But the truth is, in Islam, you don't get you hand cut for stealing bread. If they do, the authorities which allows this has already against the teaching itself. There are many conditions to be met before someone being if he is found stealing, and in Islam, stealing food IS NOT one of it. I believe, if the news is correct, the person who heartlessly punished the boy was doing it himself out of stupidity and irrational judgement. He is guilty of doing damage, and in Islam, the criminal of such crime will be punished equal to the damage he has done. In this case, he will lost his hand.