Carrie Underwood: Is she too Skinny?

I haven't seen her lately, but you're right that she was fine when she won. I think that it is really sad how women today think that they have to be bone-skinny to be attractive. To be honest, those women who are so close to anorexic (or who really are) look quite unattractive. Will we ever get back to the days of old when being a bit on the heavier side is viewed as attractive, lol? I understand that that was due to wealth being looked at as attractive and that it was the rich who had the money to eat well, but still. How nice would it have been to live back in those days! ^_^

I agree, I saw her last night on the Grammy's and her face is too thin. Such a pretty girl, I hope she doesn't get ruined by the whole Hollywood mindset.

I think she was beautiful when she won American Idol, but U noticed she lost weight at some of the music award shows...Actually, I thought her legs looked like she'd been doing a lot of working out, I didn't find her too skinny...She looks nothing like Nicole Richie...She probably did what most of us would do if we made that much money, she probably has a personal trainer, and maybe even a personal chef....I know I would if I could...My diet downfall is eating when I don't have time to cook...She's still beautiful, but not too skinny in my opinion, and has a great voice too!

No, she looks great. On American Idol she was healthy in the since that she weighed to much.. Water weight. She got money and got more famous she got a trainer and a dietician to help her eat right and burn her water weight and excess fat on her body. Now her body fat is non-existent and she looks great. She is toned and cut. On all of her award shows her legs and arms are very fit. She lost the fat so now she was able to work on toning which is easily done once you lose excess fat, and water weight.