The Muslim Veil - What do you think??

October 6, 2006 10:04am CST
In England today a MP stated that he would rather the muslim burka (veil) be discarded completely. What are your thoughts? Please give clear reasons & have a proper debate not just spam!! I think that muslims should dress how they want. Especially in England I feel that generally all cultures, races, religions are living together peacefully and have done for many many years. Comments like this only let the few hardened racists to come out and be openly discriminate. I feel that if this was allowed to happen, then next it would be the sikth mans trban etc Qoute from article found in metro newspaper: "" Jack Straw today waded further into the Muslim veil row by saying he would like the garments to be discarded completely. The former Foreign Secretary sparked controversy last night when he revealed that he asks female visitors to his constituency surgery to uncover their faces, to improve 'community relations'. But asked today if he would rather the veils be discarded completely, Mr Straw said: 'Yes. 'It needs to be made clear I am not talking about being prescriptive but with all the caveats, yes, I would rather.' ""
2 responses
6 Oct 06
In honesty. I would also ‘rather’ burka’s be discarded, that’s my personal opinion, just because I believe it doesn’t mean I’ll necessarily have it inflicted on those who choose to wear it. I agree, it is a lot easier to approach a Muslim woman without a full veil with just idle passing chat than it is one with that is just revealing the eyes . A lot interpret it as ‘body language’ not to be engaged, is it meant to be? I have no idea. The presence of a smile has many social attributes, I fail to see how society is really meant to integrate when passing a woman who has a full veil and you can’t offer nor have returned the simplest of friendly gestures? How do you feel about it?
6 Oct 06
Many of the women leave their eyes open - the eyes often show a smile etc you don't need to see the face or mouth... How many times as you are walking about with your daily life, shopping, in a supermarket, in a cafe etc do you actually stop and say hello to a complete stranger or actually stop and smile?? Even at a doctors surgery how often do you say anything to a stranger, most I've said is excuse me!! Surely its the same as when a person has loads of peicings - are you intimidated to talk to them? should they have their peicings removed? The same can be said with loads or tattoes over face etc.. I think more than the whole social devide its now a trend to say anti islamic things just to get publicity. I think we have come to a stage now where we should have moved on from the prehistoric attitudes of the past and just accept anyone as long as they are not harming you. Women in Veils won't hurt you, won't intimidate you, won't bat an eye lid at you! They are more likely to give an elderly person a seat on the bus, be polite towards you and open the door for you. I live in a multi cultural society and I have find this to be the case. I have no problems at all with these women who I often meet when picking up my children from school - to be honest they are just like any other parent, sister, wife or mother!
@sedel1027 (17846)
• Cupertino, California
6 Oct 06
I am not a fan of the burka either. I think that they hide a woman's beauty like ti is a shameful thing. I do see his point because burka’s do hinder personal communication since you cannot see the persons facial expressions. I also believe that the burka was created to make women feel inferior to men which is the wrong message to send.
6 Oct 06
I once asked a close friend of mine why he "made" his wife wear the burka. This is what responce he gave me: First of all he said that his wife wanted to wear the burka and he had no objection to it and supported her, he also added that many muslim women choose to wear the burka rather than get asked to wear it, so it was more a matter of personal choice. The other thing he added was this which I thought was rather sweet: Say for example you have a beautiful diamond, that is yours to keep & cherish... would you put it on show so that people would be envious, or may feel jealous or that they may want it for themselves? I say No, I would probably hide it, put it safe and chrish it. So he said the same way a muslim women is the diamond of a household. And therefore if they choose to cover their beauty they should do!! For many muslim women it is hard due to just wear the scarf in public so surely we should admire them for wearing a whole burka, for themselves and their beliefs. It is only the most pious of the muslim women who wear these burka anyway... You will find some very pious christian women used to do the same a long time ago. Except If i'm right it was more a thin scarf that was used.