Should men and women also be equal in a relationship when it comes to money?

Philippines
February 15, 2007 9:32pm CST
People always say that in a relationship,money should not be a problem but I have this friend who's thinking of thinking of breaking up with her bf. Her problem or situation is that she feels that from the start of their relationship, which is now almost 2 years, she has been the one who usually spends when they go out. When they go out for movies, dinner,transportation, or hanging out with friends, she is the one who usually pays. Although she doesnt really mind because she earns more than the boy, she has been thinking lately that she wants to save more money and is hoping that her bf would be the one who will spend more than her. Besides, she's thinking that it is the natural thing that the guy should spend in a relationship for the girl and not the other way around. She's planning of talking to her bf about it but she's afraid that her bf's feelings might get hurt. What do you think should she do about this? Should she just find another guy who can provide for her more?
13 people like this
67 responses
• United States
16 Feb 07
Of course they should. She shouldn't be spending all the money on their dates. It makes me feel like the guy she's dating is some sort of freeloader that would rather have her spend money on him, instead of treating her out to things. I think she should drop him fast because if he's not willing to pay for outtings, then he's not worth it.
2 people like this
• Philippines
16 Feb 07
I dont think the guy is a freeloader type of guy or at least not completely because sometimes he also pays if it's not too expensive and he would also buy simple gifts for my friend during special occasions.
1 person likes this
@cfromh (29)
• Philippines
16 Feb 07
then there u go. if she's complaining bout their expenses, the best and simplest solution would be to cut it off. not the relationship but the outings, the dinners, the movies. considering the guy also helps out on cheap dates. why not rent a movie instead of actually going to movie theaters. prepare the dinner by themselves instead of going to restaurants. etc. that would not only make it cheaper but, in my opinion, more romantic...
• United States
16 Feb 07
I totally agree with you cfromh. Spending time together making dinner is a good way to enjoy each others company, not to mention a good way to save money. Staying in and having your own movie night is another good way to save more money. Maybe they shouldn't go out as often if money is an issue.
2 people like this
• United States
16 Feb 07
If they are living together then it should be 50/50 but if it is dating I think he should pay most of time if he is trying to impress her. I think she should talk to him about it because she probably would hurt his feelings a lot more by just breaking up with him and he does not know why.
2 people like this
• Philippines
16 Feb 07
Yes, she is thinking about talking to him about it but afraid that his feelings might get hurt and would think that she just cares about the money..
2 people like this
@blog_seo (32)
• India
16 Feb 07
honestly it depend on situation and depend on how much money idividual have.and also mitual understading matter a lot good topic man like it cheer
2 people like this
• United States
16 Feb 07
I don't understand why she would allow 2 years to go by without saying something about this. It seems she has ideas about how things should be, yet has allowed the opposite to happen for two years? My question would be to her, why now? I think they should talk and should have long before now. I by no means think he is a freeloader or anyone is necessarily in the wrong. But why allow something that bothers you go on so long without having a conversation about it?
2 people like this
• Bermuda
16 Feb 07
I think the money the man makes he gets to spend however he wants...and the money the woman makes she can spend it however she would like...and split the bills....that seems like a great way for me....unless one is a stay at home parent..then they should get an allounce!..and a decent one too....but not too over the top!
2 people like this
• United States
16 Feb 07
Well, I was just wondering why she allowed to let herself spend for everything (or shall we say spend much more than the guy). I guess the guy would have gotten used to this and must be thinking that it's okay for her to do this. In the case of the guy, I was wondering why he didn't even try to at least ease her girlfriend's financial burden by helping her out somehow. I think they coexisted, until the time that the girl realized that her spending for the relationship is giving negative effects. I think they should talk about this because they allowed each other to play such roles in their relationship. I pity the girl because maybe she loves him and would like to please him. If the guy loves her, then he should listen to her and help her out. If he doesn't do that, then there are many fish in the sea.
@lingli_78 (12822)
• Australia
16 Feb 07
well, naturally especially in my culture, it is definitely the guy who always has to spend in a relationship... i just wondering why she has to wait until 2 years before she realises it and want to have a chat with her bf... i think it is a little bit too late... it is not a money issue anymore but a principle issue... it looks to me that her bf is a freeloader and t rying to make use of her which is not good... i will definitely give him up if i have a bf like him...
1 person likes this
• Nigeria
16 Feb 07
In relationships there should always be equality thats what love is all about caring for each other i think that if the couples are both financially equipped then the financial responsibilities can be shared between them..
1 person likes this
@SanDslnrs (268)
• United States
19 Feb 07
I agree, I think just cut out all the extra outings etc. Maybe then can make an arrangement to where 1 time she pays, 1 time he pays? It's terrible that money can affect our relationships, but it does. I'm in that situation too. I live with my ex husband...he makes me pay half the rent, which is ok, but it's way more than I can afford and I have a child also whom I don't get any child support for. Anyhow, he is insistant that I pay half otherwise I am just using him. I have been with him for 17 years now off and on. He made 3x the money I made at 1 point too. I treat when I can and he does treat me also to dinner etc.
• United States
16 Feb 07
I feel that, in a realtionship, each should contribute the same percentage towards things. I mean that each should contribute say 10% of their earnings towards things they share. So, if the girl makes $1000, $100 would go in the pot; if the guy only makes $500, he would contribute $50. That way, the burden is the same for each and relative to their income, not determined by the cost of activities. It makes it easier to budget, too.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
19 Feb 07
this is a very good idea..thanks! yes, i guess maybe if they can each allot a portion of their earnings to spend during their dates, then both of them wont feel that they are spending more than the other. Plus, i also think that the money spent should be limited to the amount that was put in the "pot" so they wont have to spend more than they should.
• Philippines
16 Feb 07
i'm a conservative type, and i believe, if they're still dating, and not married yet, the guy should spend more. but if it's the other way around like in your friend's case, the best approach here would be for your friend to talk to her boyfriend about it, so that there will be no miscommunication in their relationship. it's not right to just break up with him without discussing things over. It becomes a different story once they get married, because there will then be a total commitment to each other, and that they will work out every aspect of their married life, be it financial, or dealing with other concerns of their family life.
1 person likes this
@limitup (324)
• United States
17 Feb 07
No, the guy should not spend more just because he is a guy. You ladies wanted equal rights. Well, now you got em.
@zynijh (44)
• Philippines
16 Feb 07
in this kind of relationship money doesn't matter too much...you were only spending during dates and occassions...it is not actually a problem... you were just in a stage of getting to know each other better...it is your choice not to spend or bear the expenses...what matters most if it continuously to happen when you got be married... where money matters most....thinking that you will have kids to raise...are you ready to bear that responsibility alone?....you definitely have to decide...its not a game to play....
2 people like this
@gullu1562 (216)
• India
16 Feb 07
I personally feel it is a man thing when both go out for everything But the story which you are putting forth tells me that the boy is simply enjoying at the behest of the girl who cares more for the relationship but I feel the girl should stop spending for the boy
@apple20 (39)
• Philippines
17 Feb 07
for me.. on my own opinion.. i thinks it better to talked to his bf..say what she feel and and what she think about it.. be natural to open the topic..no things will be solved if she gonna zip her mounth and don't speak out..it a matter of good communication and how she deliver it to his bf.
1 person likes this
• India
16 Feb 07
Ofcourse man... why should she always pay.... moreover according to me, what do I feel is that they should be equally paying rather it wouold be preferable if the boy pays more , and he is supposed to, afterall no matter what the girl earns, but she defintley is the boy's responsibilty
1 person likes this
@lisado (1227)
• United States
16 Feb 07
I would probably get upset if he expected me to foot all of the bills and if they stay together it will probably stay that way if she doesn't say anything. She needs to talk to him about it. She might make more, but it shouldn't mean that she should pay for everything. Even if he picked up the tab once in a while that would be nice. I never expected my (now) husband to pay for everything, but he did. A relationship isn't about money, but if they love each other. If it is bothering her that much, she needs to get over it, move on or talk to him about it. He might not understand that it is upsetting her. I'd talk to him first, before making decisions to break it off. That is going to hurt him way more than just asking why he isn't pitching in with the bills. If he gets mad that she talked about it, they might be better off seperate.
1 person likes this
@sripriya (450)
• United States
16 Feb 07
Well!in the situation you have presented I think the girl is right!Since both of them are earning they should share the expenses in every way!I think she can convey her situation to her boyfreind in a polite way instead of keeping all her complaints in her heart and seething inside!If the boy rectifies and takes more responsibility it is well and Good or else it is no use being with someone who is shrinking away from responsibilities!Correct me if Iam wrong!
1 person likes this
• United States
16 Feb 07
I can understand why your friend might be a little frustrated if she is the one always spending when they go out. I don't think it is enough to break off a two year relationship unless there are other things she is unhappy with in the relationship also. Maybe her man doesnt have the excess money? And in that case why go out when they both could do with the extra money in their pockets? I dont agree that it is a natural thing that a guy always spend in a relationship.. Why would it be natural? Because women are women and men SHOULD spend?? I dont agree with that.
1 person likes this
• Malaysia
16 Feb 07
As we know that in a relationship, usually guys are the one who spend when go out with their gf. It is still alright if the gurl spend when go out with their bf once in a while. But in my opinion, since the salary of the guy is lower than his gf, i think they should cut off some of the unnecessary expenses. The guy should take initiative to pay when go out with her gf. If he really does not have much money to pay, i think it is better for him to talk or communicate with her gf earlier before they go for any occasions. Your friend should talk to her bf and solve this problems together but not break up with him whitout giving him any reasons. She should directly go in the main point when talk to him but your fren shouldn't hurt him and too direct when talk about this problems.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
16 Feb 07
I think your friend should be honest to tell her boyfriend about her concern of spending more on their dates. The boyfriend might just think that it is very much fine with her when she spends when they are going out, because she is not actually complaining about it. Money matters is important in a relationship. If this is not resolved at this stage, it can even be worse when they get married. But there is also no straight rule that the guy should just be the one to spend in a relationship. Its a matter of talking to each other on how they can actually split the expenses, so as to how they can save together. In our case, my husband is the one who saves a lot and I do the spending most of the time. I do pay for all the expenses in the house because that is the formula that works for us. I'm the type of person who doesn't know how to save, but knows exactly how to spend. My husband is in turn the one who saves for our family so we compliment each other. Your friend should talk to her boyfriend. I don't think it's a wise idea to just find another guy who can provide for her more. Is it the only thing she needs in the relationship?