cell phone for your daughter

Spain
February 17, 2007 3:02pm CST
I have a 11 year old daughter. She has asked me a cell phone many times. I am not sure if I have to buy it for her, because of her age. What do you think I should do?
1 person likes this
5 responses
@judyt00 (3497)
• Canada
17 Feb 07
Your first question should be why does an 11 year old need a cell phone Your second should be why does your particular 11 year old think she needs a cell phone. Don't you drive her everywhereshe goes? and doesn't the school she goes to call you if she asks them to. Cell phones have become a tatus symbol for preteens, See, my parents love me more than yours do. However, saying that, recently my daughter dropped her 12 year old som off at thelocal pool to swim with a few of his friends, to be picked up in an hour and a half, and the pool unexpectedly shut early because of a filter problem,and insisted that everybody wait outside in - 22 celcius weather. if some good samaritan hadn't let the boys use his phone, and wait with them, letting them get warm in his car while HE stood outside in the cold, they may well have been seriously injured from frost bite. He now takes his dad's phone with him when he goes anywhere. By theway, my daughter shuttled 5 boys home that day whose parents didn't bother picking up
2 people like this
@pagibig (297)
• Philippines
17 Feb 07
i have a 6 year old brother, i gave him a cellphone, but i control his use. he can only use his cellphone AFTER his homework and during weekends. I think it is fine to give your daughter a cellphone, it would be really nice if you give it to her as a reward for a job well done. if her grades are up or if she has been good around the house. That way, she'll know that if she's good, then she'll be rewarded for it. Don't view a cellphone as something negative, you can use it to motivate her. Just find a way to regulate her and to make sure she doesn't abuse the privilege. Whenever my brother messes up in school, for example he got a zero on his seatwork, we confiscate his cellphone until he get a good mark on his next seatwork. he knows that his cellphone is a reward, and it motivates him to do well. and don't buy her the fancy ones, just the practical once where she could text message and at least call. hope this helps :D
2 people like this
@naren152 (46)
• India
17 Feb 07
children are not that innocent what we always think they are..! it all depands on how you get along withyour daughter! if you can explain her in a way that she likes that not to do any unnecessary work in mobile phone, it is advisable to give her one.! changing world needs changed minds too..! what do yousay..!
1 person likes this
@Sasselle (698)
• Australia
17 Feb 07
I think it would depend on if she would have an actual need for a phone. A lot of teens [and pre-teens] seem to have phones but they don't go anywhere much except school and home and the occasional trip out with friends. I'm not sure what phones are like in your area but there are a lot of options worldwide for teens such as those phones that you can only dial 1 or 2numbers that are already preset in the phone or ones that are prepaid so that you can't have a huge bill run up. I think it's shocking how young some kids have a phone - I don't see what a 5 year old [or even 6 year old like the post at the top] even need a phone for!!! It's not like they are going down to the mall with friends or anything - they should still be supervised by their parents at all times!
@pagibig (297)
• Philippines
17 Feb 07
well as other posts said, a cellphone has become a status symbol. Most of my brother's classmates have cellphones, he sends them messages. a way to socialize with his friends. Also my dad who is out of the country calls him on his phone. it gave my brother a sense of responsibility as well. He learned to regulate his cellphone credits, he learned to make sure that he charges his battery, he learned that if he doesn't keep his grades up, then his privilege will be taken from him. Although i agree that he doesn't have much need of a cellphone, i used it to motivate him. We have to accept the fact that teens and pre-teens and even kids MIGHT want to have what the next kid has. Why not give him what he wants BUT with certain conditions.
1 person likes this
• India
17 Feb 07
cell phones have become now a parcel of mans life so buy her one and see that she does not use it for wrong purposes
1 person likes this