Is it o.k. to Marry your Friends Ex?

@WAHSIS (216)
United States
February 20, 2007 12:34pm CST
Do you think Marrying your friends Ex is breaking the unwritten code? She or He has been your friend for a long time but they have been separated for a while now. Do you think it is okay knowing it will be upsetting to your friend? Would you do it or not and why do you feel this is okay?
1 person likes this
17 responses
@LadyLeene (584)
• United States
20 Feb 07
I know a lady who has been married for nine years to a man who was divorced from one of her college friends, and they are all STILL really good friends. I think the key here is just maturity and in being honest with each other. Marrying your friend's ex does not HAVE to be a betrayal; but if your friend will perceive it that way, then you do have to pick which one of them is more important to you.
3 people like this
@WAHSIS (216)
• United States
21 Feb 07
Evidentally the friend was not as important as she married him irregardless of the consequences. She was also afraid of being alone. She has been Married Numerous times before.
• United States
22 Feb 07
Oh, for Heaven's sake! That's not true. Yeah, she had been divorced once, but she lived alone for 27 years. It's ust that once they all hit middle age, they had more life experience and were able to accept each other more easily. It did partly help that the man's first wife actually ended up leaving him because she realized she was a lesbian; but when Cate talked to her friend about whether or not it would be okay with her if she married Aaron, the friend was delighted that they would be happy together. Yes, if that wasn't the case, Cate would have had to choose one or the other. You shouldn't project your beliefs onto other people, though. It just shows your immaturity.
@TriciaW (2441)
• United States
20 Feb 07
wow that is a hard question. On one hand she let him go on the other she is your friend and how would she feel. I would be open and ask her how she would feel. That way if she says yes and then later doesn't like it she can't really object because she told you it was ok. If she says no then you have to decided how important her friendship is. If it were my friend I would have to wonder why they broke up. Friends are usually a like in many ways so what ever happened in her relationship with him would in happen in yours? A tough call but being open and honest about it with your friend may be the best answer you could receive. Good luck!
2 people like this
@WAHSIS (216)
• United States
21 Feb 07
I feel the same way about it. If he was bad with the first wife why would he be good to the new wife. He is still the same old butt-head he was before. Even though she was warned about him she still went against the friend and married him anyway because she had the opportunity.
@crazy_me (588)
• Philippines
22 Feb 07
It depends. If the guy and my friend parted ways a long time ago and my friend is not in love with him anymore and they had a good parting, then I guess I would date my friend's ex-boyfriend and probably marry him. But if dating her ex would upset a good friend of mine, then I would not date the guy. If the guy is really serious with me anyway, he would talk to my friend and make my friend understand our situation. If one of my friends date and marry one of my ex-boyfriends, I would not mind at all. I had a nice parting with each of my ex-boyfriends. And most important of all, I am already very happy with my current boyfriend, so if my friend and ex-boyfriend are happy together, then I would be happy for them too. :)
@WAHSIS (216)
• United States
27 Feb 07
Yes in that case I would be happy for them too. But this was not the case in this situation.
• India
22 Feb 07
no is is not a good idea to marry our friends ex
1 person likes this
@WAHSIS (216)
• United States
27 Feb 07
I totally agree!
• Philippines
22 Feb 07
not all but if you ask me i would rather not to marry my friends x it's a very difficult situation for me. ilove my friends more than i love my bf
@WAHSIS (216)
• United States
27 Feb 07
Good for you! You can be my friend now.
@catcai (1056)
• Philippines
27 Feb 07
I dont mean to be harsh but, people do it all the time... so why not? sometimes they dont even wait for you to get seperated with your partner before they steal your partner from you. Besides i dont see anything wrong with this, your friend has been seperated from his ex and as you have mentioned for quite a while. But just to make sure, i would talk to my friend first and ask whats the real deal between him and his ex, if he still loves the girl- but i know that girl is now in love with me and does want to marry me, i would tell my friend about it. And hopefully ask for his blessing, if he tells me he will need more time to recuperate- i will give him the time he needs because he is my friend and i know he has been through a lot.
@WAHSIS (216)
• United States
1 Mar 07
As a matter of fact she did contact her friend first and all she asked her was "Are you two getting back together" and the Ex wife/friend told her she was reconsidering it. that's when she decided to marry the friends ex behind her back. Then the Ex husbund called his ex wife who he was reconsidering marrying again to let her know he was marrying the friend instead. The friend had the nerve to contact the ex wife after the marriage took place to try rekindle the friendship they once had and I don't need to explain the rest becasue you can figure out what the ex wife ( now ex friend )told her.
@marciascott (25529)
• United States
20 Feb 07
I would never dresm of doing nothing like that. I don't care if my friend and the other person split up for sometime. I wouldn't do it, I makes you wonder.
1 person likes this
@WAHSIS (216)
• United States
21 Feb 07
You sound like you would make a great friend! Good Girl!
• United States
22 Feb 07
I wouldn't do it. I think if you want to keep your friendship then you shouldn't do this. It would probably really make your friend mad at you if you did.
1 person likes this
@WAHSIS (216)
• United States
27 Feb 07
And that is exactly what it did I might add.
• United States
27 Feb 07
in this situation that i will be marrying my friend's ex , for the beginning of the courtship & relationship i would have confronted or clarify issues to my friend before going into the much intimate relationship as to going up to the point that we will be marrying. for this time all matters be cleared already to each & everyone of us that he & my friend have nothing to be intimadated or any upsetting situation with each other in time that we can be all together on occasions that call for us . make everything clear for friendship sake & won't sacrifice your happiness too!
@WAHSIS (216)
• United States
1 Mar 07
Well the Ex is not a Happy Camper because she has no more chance to get back with the ex now. So she has to move on happy or not. Meanwhile back at the ranch they are the happy campers now. The New wife does not seem to care about the friendship anymore and there is bad blood between them now.
@sidoney (1033)
• Jamaica
27 Feb 07
if you love him/her try to let your friend understand especially if they broke up for reason that you can handle or does not contain
@WAHSIS (216)
• United States
1 Mar 07
Well she took the side of the Ex husbund and just ditched the friends issues she once had with him. I guess she feels as though she can handle his problems but it is the same man and do you think he will change and be more compatible with her now that they are together?
@rb_baguio (288)
• Philippines
20 Feb 07
i believe its ok and not breaking any rule as long as you really love each other....coz if ur friend does love you too, he/she would understand, ayt?..
@WAHSIS (216)
• United States
21 Feb 07
That is your opinion but I don't think that is a friend that loves you very much. The Ex was the one that broke the news not the so called friend. That should tell you something.
• Philippines
20 Feb 07
i don't see any wrong in marrying ur friend's ex.. As long as you followed your happiness. their relationship is a past thing.. they may be not that compatible enough why the lost each other... Your friend will definitely understands you about that.. He/she must be thankful that her his ex is in ur good side... She won't be upset unless she dont treat you as a friend. Believe it will be ok...
@WAHSIS (216)
• United States
21 Feb 07
I don't think it will be Okay!
• India
22 Feb 07
Well this is a hard question.Actually speaking your friends spouse is of a sisterly relation yo u.But when they have broken up that is no longer valid and if your love is true for her/him it doesn't matter.
@WAHSIS (216)
• United States
27 Feb 07
Yes it is a hard question and I don't exactly know what you are saying.
@Joey322 (272)
• United States
20 Feb 07
this is a very good, yet tricky question. there are a lot of factors with this situation. should you DATE a friend's ex (bf or gf)??? NO. this is part of the code. you don't date your ex's anything. now, marriage means more than dating and so the situation gets more serious. no one should keep two people from marrying, except that how do they know they should marry without dating and they shouldn't have done that in the first place! also, the friend's feelings need to come into play. if they are going to be upset about it, then you shouldn't, but if it's truly meant to be with that person, then maybe you should get married anyway and lose the friend. anyway you cut it, it's a tricky situation and someone is most likely going to get hurt. people should stay away from their friend's exes, unless they are willing to lose their friend for a chance with that other person..... take care.
@WAHSIS (216)
• United States
21 Feb 07
Yes I feel like she did loose a good friendship. When she was in need the friend always came to her rescue.
• Canada
20 Feb 07
Love is love!! My boyfriend and I are on very good terms with our own exes, and eachother's! If a friend of ours decided to marry one of our exes, we'd hope that their union would work out better than ours did with that person, and since we are friends with all of our exes anyway, it wouldn't matter to us. It would work out quite well for all involved.
@WAHSIS (216)
• United States
21 Feb 07
well in this case the first wife was reconsidering marrying the Ex again. But before that happened the friend interfered and the Ex went with the new interest instead. This broke up the friendship if there was one. This makes you wonder if the so called friend was interested in the man before they even divorced.
5 Mar 07
for me it is a good question...mmm. for me it is depend on the person itself. but waht is important tell your friend not other people to tell them... at least we seem to be honest with them...it is ocay as long they are not engaged yet...
@nairjula (453)
• India
2 Mar 07
Nothign wrong. But after marriage, forget about the past and start a new life. Life is all about forgetting and forgiving. Come on, do it.