Should 11 yr old girl be allowed to wear hijab well playing soccer

@red158 (333)
Canada
March 3, 2007 2:03pm CST
Up here in Canada the news as been filled all week with a girl being asked to remove her hijab, or remove herself from the soccer field. The reason is the wearing of any head wear or jewelery is against the rules for safety reasons. One side is screaming racism, but I would like to point out the referee in this case his, himself a Muslim. The other side says that there are rules to be followed, and they should be followed by everyone. The one point that I agree to is that wearing a hijab is not mandatory for her, and if she is allowed then the Catholic or Christian player should be allowed to wear their crucifix. What are your thoughts? Do you think we are going to far, in accommendating religions? Do you think that this is a racist or discriminating practice?
10 people like this
26 responses
@callarse1 (4783)
• United States
3 Mar 07
I agree that it is okay to wear hijab when appropriate. For example since she is playing football (soccer) then she may get it tangled and be injured. I think the team is just looking out for safety. If she is explained that then she has the option of withdrawing from the team. No one is forcing her to play and therefore she has to make a decision. I do not think it is racist or discriminatory because it could harm her safety as she is playing such as with head injury or something. Have a nice day and a big plus to you. Pablo
4 people like this
• New Zealand
4 Mar 07
Well said. She is not being forced to play.
1 person likes this
@gbolly54 (661)
• Nigeria
4 Mar 07
Certain modes of dressing are designed or appropriate for certain activities. To do otherwise is to create an oddity or even give room for unpleasant consequences. To this extent, if anybody or group feels that he/she/it cannot conform to the rules, it is better to opt out rather than seek a way to bend the rule. By the way, why can't people whose religious or cultural doctrines run counter to certain established rules of any game start their own exclusive sports, rules and so on? It is a free world.
2 people like this
@ESKARENA1 (18261)
4 Mar 07
For me, anyone wearing any kind of religious dress just looks silly. For a child, looking good is very important, i just wonder what damage is being done to the self esteem of an 11 year old by encouraging her to dress in this way? OK, if she was living in the middle east, or even the Asian sub continent, she may well fit in with her peers. However, I assume her parents chose to come live in Canada, maybe they need to leave the religious baggage at home with the buildings. Such stuff does not readilly travel to the rest of the world. Blessed be
3 people like this
@emeraldisle (13139)
• United States
3 Mar 07
This isn't about racism or descirmination. This is about safety not only for her but for others. When playing soccer it is far too easy for someone to get hurt. When you add in jewlery or head gear that can hit someone else, fly up to hit them, or give something for a person to grab hold of it just adds to the chances of someone getting hurt. If the rules state there isn't to be head gear of any sort or jewelry then that means for all not just for one group or another. If she cannot accept that then perhaps she shouldn't be playing. School sports are to help teach following the rules after all and if one makes exceptions for one then what type of message is that sending to the kids? That rules are to be bent if someone complains enough. That isn't right. We want them to learn that rules are meant to be followed by all not just select few.
@ganwn071 (1116)
• Singapore
4 Mar 07
Totally agreed with you, it is more toward safety rather than Racism or Descirmination. Everyone playing the games should follow it, else you might want to redraw from the team and quit playing the games. For the safety of everyone on the field all rules need to be followed
1 person likes this
@anonymili (3138)
4 Mar 07
Ooh you have no idea how bored I am of this topic coming up again and again (before you take offence I don't mean here on mylot I mean in real life, last year we had the incident over here where the hijab wearing teaching assistant lost her job because she wouldn't remove her hijab). Just another excuse for people to jump on the bandwagon and shout human rights violation and racism. It is NOT racism and NOT a human rights violation - it is purely a matter of health and safety, if people can't see that, they need their head tested. If this response gets me a 1000 - ratings then so be it, I'm sick of all this unnecessary media attention this sort of thing gets. I am a health and safety officer at my job and anything that puts individuals at risk is an issue, no one gives a hoot about religious issues. If you're putting yourself or others at risk then don't do it! There, my rant over now :)
3 people like this
@shajitha (12)
• India
4 Mar 07
I think it's not compulsory 4 a 11 year old to wear hijab.however if she has attained puberty it's compulsory.and if so its not advisable to remain in the team.
2 people like this
@grebsie (69)
4 Mar 07
I wish not to comment on this "sensitive" issue.Canada is a very tolerant country.All I have to say;in Rome, do as the Romans do.If this is your host country, please adjust. ...and I mean, no more comments.Have a pleasant day.
2 people like this
• Canada
4 Mar 07
i feel that they should follow there religion but while this girl is playing soccer or any other sport for that should have to remove it. because others have to remove things that could be religious to them such as a cross around the neck or in the ear. plus it can be in the way and be harmful to other players.. i dont feel that it is racist or anything its just them following the rules of the game.
1 person likes this
@cripfemme (7698)
• United States
5 Mar 07
If it's a safety concern, legitimately, then their are rules to followed by everyone, Muslim or whatever. But I would would worry that this is just racism wrapped in a nicer cloth.
@apostrofy (661)
• Romania
4 Mar 07
discriminating why? noone makes them play soccer, if they wanna join they have rules to obey, same way as if u would like to join muslim religion u have rules to obey. just because it's sport doesn't mean that everything is allowed. when u chose to practice something u first learn the rules and think if u can follow them. noone makes her play soccer, it's her own will and she should learn to obey the rules and if the rules are in contradiction with the religion then she just have to chose. letting her play with that veil would mean preferential treatment and that doesn't seem to me it's the right thing to do.
1 person likes this
@anandjee (282)
• India
4 Mar 07
i don't know why we are saying this type of topic , no one should take any type of hidden things , come forward , leave this type of topic , this is unnecessary open the complecated issue and some people take the advantages of this low lewel talk, we must pointout if anyone not wear cloths on public , not hijab etc. some terrorist are use this techniq to hide him self so must be ban on nay type of hide face. this is my personnel view
1 person likes this
@onabreak2 (1161)
• United States
4 Mar 07
It sounds like she was asked to remove it for safety reasons. It sounds like they are making a big deal out of something that is asked of everyone. She should have known the rules before she started playing. Probably now they will sue though since people like this are usually sue happy and will jump on any opportunity to make easy money. I dont think they would win though.
1 person likes this
@Ace2242 (111)
• India
4 Mar 07
well i think everyone should be treated the same way , no kind of discrimination should be made in any way , and sports is something that treats everyone involved in it as a part of the game not a community or society or raceor anything else, they are all the same . the girl should remove her hijab while playing the game and as the refree is also a muslim and does not have any problem with that then why can't everyone else behave in the same way . atleast throught this the difference between people will be resolved to some extent.
1 person likes this
@aksingh (20)
• India
4 Mar 07
I think refree is fine with his opinions . Game is more close to humanity then religion .So the rules of teh gane should prevail . I like it . Everytime one goes through such dicussion Humanity always wins. I dont hate religion. I only mean religion still needs to be devloped .We still few gods to come up on this earth and teach us what is humanity !!!!!!
2 people like this
• United States
4 Mar 07
i think if shes not required to wear it, then she should take it off for the safety of her and the other kids. the referee being muslim helps, because he would be the one to ask. i dont think it screams racism, its a legitimate issue that needs to be dealt with.
1 person likes this
@Bee1955 (3882)
• United States
4 Mar 07
Muslim women - 2 women and girl
What do you mean, "accomadating religion"? Thats like me saying go ahead and let Christians wear their religious jewelry while playing, so they can get stabbed by the sharp edges and choked if they swallow it during a rough play or hurt others with it. She's wearing a headscarf as mandated by her religion, whether someone else (Muslim or not) considers it her time to wear it or not. Her family has the final say on that and Canada has freedom of religion written into its Bill of Rights as we do. Girls in almost every country play football (soccer) with hijab. Therefore the "rules" have to be accomadating. Check this site out concerning PROFESSIONAL women's soccer in Moracco: http:/www.abroadviewmagazine.com/?p=31
@babykay (2131)
• Ireland
4 Mar 07
The article that you have posted a link to mentions that in every place in Morocco BOYS and MEN play soccer constantly. Usually, nowhere is there women to be seen playing soccer. How very sad. But the author of the article is researching a team in Morocco and she describes what they wear "Some women wore pants and long sleeved jerseys, attempting to cover all visible skin in accordance with Islamic law. They were the ones who tucked their hair under the traditional hijab, pinning it tightly to their heads so that even a hard sprint could not shake it loose. Most women, however, simply wore their short-sleeved jerseys and shorts, exposing their bare legs and arms." So it seems that in a Muslim country only some of the women wear the hijab. If the rules in Canada state that no headgear is to be worn for safety issues, safety needs to take precedence. Perhaps the hijab could be made tighter, but if this was the case I imagine that this would defeat the purpose of the hijab as it is supposed to cover the flesh and disguise the shape and form of the female body. I do feel very sorry for Muslim women who want to play sport, especially this 11 year old girl. I wonder if given a choice she would not just remove the hijab whenshe is playing soccer? Or perhaps her parents won't let her. In my opinion this is tantamount to child abuse.
• New Zealand
4 Mar 07
According to guidelines of FIFA, the international governing body of soccer, "a player shall not use equipment or wear anything (including any kind of jewelry) that could be dangerous to himself or another player." This was interpreted - and that is it.
• United States
4 Mar 07
the rules are for everyone and everyone should abide by them!
• Pakistan
4 Mar 07
Sister according to Islamic teachings about wearing hijab a person is not considered accountable until after reaching puberty.According to Prophet(peace be upon him); "the pen has been lifted from three:from the child until he reaches puberty,from the sleeper until he wakes up,and from the one who has lost his mind until he recovers."(narrated by Abu Dawood,4402) I thunk at first place you should have let her enjoy her life fully till she reached her puberty which differs from 12-15 among girls,meanwhile preparing her mentally what she was supposed to do after she grows mature so that in such problems she either could have refused to play or could have found any solution.Now when she is already wearing a hijab I think you should not let her take it off as it will reduce its importance for her.Try her understand thatthese kind of things are just temporarily an enjoyment for these few hours enjoyment we should not ruin our next life which surely is immortal. For this reason I believe that Muslims should preffer living in a Muslim country where they can atleaste perform our religious duties freely
@thyst07 (2079)
• United States
4 Mar 07
As long as it isn't a safety hazard, I see no reason why she should be asked to remove it. Jewelry ought to be removed (including crucifixes), because it can swing free and hit someone. And Catholics and Christians are not required by their religious beliefs to wear their crucifix or rosary at all times. However, for Muslims, their headwear is often required by their religious beliefs. If she removes it, it could be a serious offense to her religion. So as long as it isn't going to hurt anyone, I say let her wear it.
• New Zealand
4 Mar 07
Yeah! It would help to read the Rules of the Game. If you go into a mosque with your head uncovered, you are not following the rules. If in Saudi Arabia, you as a woman walk into the mosque without sack cloth, you can bleat all you want, but you will get the full attention of the religious police. Canada is no Saudi Arabia or another country flying the Lunatic Flag, but a Sports Field has rules. And that excludes wearing a half muslim garment.
1 person likes this
@nill_07 (1104)
• Bangladesh
4 Mar 07
I am a muslim.I know there is nothing in this world may be good for human beings which has forbidden in Islam.Ask a researcher or scientist they will tell you the truth by observing or experimenting.& the things which have allowed in Islam must be well for (All) Humanbeings in this world.Hijab is necessary for women & early practice of course weel.
4 Mar 07
With all due respect to you as a Muslim my friend, I shall remind you, that we're talking North America here in this issue.Not ALL human beings are going to accept your brought in customs.Hijab IS NECESSARY in Muslim countries.We are talking Canada here. You should not expect acceptance of your customs from all mankind, even though people here in Canada DO tolerate & respect it so far.
1 person likes this
@kkama67 (48)
4 Mar 07
I dont think there is anything wrong with it. It does not interfere with the game or practice. I could see where it would be a problem in a sport like wrestling or swimming where it could be a problem. If racism is the only problem then people are going to have to learn to deal with their OWN issues.