Do our dogs really need ALL the shots the vets recommend, or are they just

United States
March 4, 2007 4:49pm CST
trying to make more money? Every time I go in for one shot that is due, they suggest 4 other new ones that I never heard of. Also they gave me an "estimate" on teeth cleaning that is upwards of $160-350. When I ask about that they say that it depends on whether you want a heart monitor or something on them or this or that extra "just in case" there is a problem during the procedure (okay, if any extractions are needed also). I think they try and make us feel guilty for not getting "THE WORKS".... I have no problem with rabies, and the usual dog shots or heartworm, but isn't there somewhere that you have to draw the line or go broke?
6 people like this
19 responses
@lilaclady (28207)
• Australia
4 Mar 07
I don't know about dogs but I know a lot of vets insit on cats getting a cat flu needle every year I think it is, my vet simply asked me if I get a flu injection, I aif no he then said well a cat has as much chance of getting the flu as you do and he felt it does more harm to a cat by putting it through the stress of bring it to the vet than is good...
• United States
4 Mar 07
If your cat is an inside one, it seems to me they don't need shots for things that get picked up from other cats, though the vet says you can bring the germs in on your shoes.
2 people like this
• United States
5 Mar 07
I would look into a different vet. Maybe a different vet would be cheaper and be less likely to suggest things your dog doesn't need. Did you know that for some shots you can go to a feed store and purchase the shots yourself for less than $5 I think and give them yourself.
2 people like this
• United States
6 Mar 07
At one point a local pet store had reduced cost shots. We only have a couple of vets in town and the others from what my friends say are the same in price. I really do like my vet, but rarely see him anymore as he's taken on quite a few assistants. Woe is my dog if I wielded the shot! I would probably do him more harm than good not knowing how to do that.
@rusty2rusty (6751)
• Defiance, Ohio
5 Mar 07
Teeth cleaning should not cost that much. My vet cleaned my mini pin for free when they fixed her. because she needed it. But mine you I just got her back after she was stolen for 5 months.
2 people like this
• United States
5 Mar 07
The shots are ridiculous. My Aunt's dog was getting a shot to keep her from getting some disease from COWS. She's an indoor dog first off, and there are no cows within 100 miles of her. I do agree with rabies, distemper, and all puppy shots. Everything else is just for money. Kennel cough is another one that is necessary if you board your dogs. It costs as much (sometimes more!) to vet our pets than ourselves.
2 people like this
• United States
6 Mar 07
Yes, it wasn't til I asked about the kennel cough that I was able to at least say no if we weren't going to board the dog anywhere. I realize a dog can pick anything up from just being outside, but we don't let him roam around unattended and is in the house all the time, so I agree with you. I really have to add up what I spent in vet bills this year and compare it to vet insurance.
• Canada
5 Mar 07
I'm not so sure about Dogs, because quite frankly, with all the diseases out there these days, I would have thought the more protection the better to be honest. With Cats though, I don't have every single shot available to them because my cat is an indoor cat. We do have to have the rabies and feline Leukemia protection jab though this yr because we're going on vacation and she needs to go into a cattery. Most catteries insist on these jabs. More often than not, I find that vets can be ridiculously overpriced for the smallest of things. I take my cat to a family run practice. They don't have the cleanest of waiting rooms, but the vets are damn good and their prices are low. I also know they go to great lengths to make sure that their examination rooms and instruments are cleaned and sterilized to a very high standard. thats what counts the most to me.
1 person likes this
• United States
6 Mar 07
Yes, I have a couple of cats also. Pets are big business now... We boarded our dog for a week and it cost $300! They charge to feed your dog their own food (instead of theirs), give pills, walks are extra, charge to also put a rug in the kennel to lay on! But like you, I know this kennel was meticulously clean, the kennels had tops on them (for climbers) and the yards were all sturdily fenced and a going home bath was included. Don't take this wrong any of you, but when my little buddies are not with me any longer, I'm not sure I could make this long term commitment again at theses prices. I'm not sure I could live without a pet in my life either!
• India
5 Mar 07
everything in this world need maintenance pets do also need certain basic maintenance such as vaccinations, deworming,dental scaling,removal of secretionsin anal glands, hair clipping etc.,vaccinations (shots) are very much needed at a younger age since the pups or kittens immune system is not developed well. common vaccinations done in dogs: 1. combined vaccine consisting of live modified virus of canine distemper,parvo,hepatitis,para influenza 2. vaccination against leptospirosis 3. vaccination against rabies 4.vaccination against corona infection commonly followed vaccination schedule 1.at an age of 6 - 7 weeks - combined vaccine along with leptospirosis vaccine . its first booster repaeted after 21 days 2. at an age of 7 weeks - vaccination against corona infection.its booster repeated after 21 days 3. at an age of 12 weeks - vaccination against rabies should be done.its booster repeated in 21 days 4. depending upon on climatic conditions, endemicity of diseses at that area a second booster of combined vaccination can be done then yearly or once in 3 years boosters of the vaccines are repeated.. now coming to ur other point. as the pet grows older and older, there will be certain changes in their body.their life span is short(approx. 12 - 15 yrs) the first change is noted in teeth. teeth needed to be cleaned at least once in 2.5 yrs (since they dont brush) the second change is in appetite. as it grows older the digestive mechanics slows downs. moreover at older age dogs are prone to renal failure. therefore a regular check up is needed for our pets
• United States
6 Mar 07
I've never had my dog's anal glands expressed. (Is that the correct term, lol?) I don't think some dogs have a problem with that though. I've never heard of a corona vaccination? Can you tell me what that is? Not sure about leptospirosis either.
• Kuwait
5 Mar 07
i think you should bring your dog to the vet to give them the shots to keep them away from sickness which will turn to a big problem to you if it happens,you know the law?
• United States
6 Mar 07
Yes, my point is that I will get rabies, distemper, heartworm.. to abide by the law and keep my dog healthy, but there is a point to which there are so many vaccines and procedures that you have to draw the line.
@sharon613 (2321)
• United States
5 Mar 07
Just when you go to the Doctor Or Dentist for that matter. They are always looking for some excuse one way or another to try and bring you back into there office in order to soak you for as much money as they possibly can.
1 person likes this
• United States
6 Mar 07
That's a good point as I've run across the same sales pitch a few times at the dentist also.
@ronita34 (3922)
• Canada
5 Mar 07
I agree that once you take your pet into the vet it definately seems like a never ending battle with the bills and visits. I think that getting our pets there shots are only needed to a point as i do not think that all of this is really necessary but then again i am not a vet and i am not sure maybe they really are all needed!
• United States
6 Mar 07
It would be interesting if there was a vet in myLot, lol. You're right, we are no doctors, just observing what we experience, but I'd like to at least be informed of the odds of my dog getting a certain disease. Probably pretty high on some. Though I know if your dog got sick you'd be lamenting the extra $25 or $40 spent.
@reha07 (3)
• India
5 Mar 07
every little need of the dogs should be taken care of no matter what the cost since they are very close to our hearts.
1 person likes this
• United States
6 Mar 07
Yes, they are, but so are our children and money just goes so far if you know what I mean. Today they found our old doggy has a heart murmur also. My husband told them NO tests, and they were very understanding and agreed to prescribe pills for that with no testing before hand.
@colega17 (312)
• Romania
5 Mar 07
Poor dog . . . So many shots :( I don't think he needs all of them . He won't die if he doesn't make one or two . In general the vets over react so they could scare you in order to determine you to buy all those shots . . .
1 person likes this
• United States
6 Mar 07
Oh what a cute poochy on your avatar! Yes the scare tactic or the guilt card both work!
@mywords18 (645)
• United States
5 Mar 07
oh yes as dog are just like infant babies who can explain wat they want or wat they are sufferin from so its better to get our lovely companions properly checked periodically by vet and yes the shots and injections are must.
1 person likes this
• United States
6 Mar 07
That's so true, they can't speak for themselves or tell us where it hurts. Thanks for the comment.
@tinacaps (66)
• Philippines
5 Mar 07
I really don't think your dog needs all that shot. I think that most important ones are the anti-rabies and heartworm shots. These are the two shots that my dogs have and they are pretty healthy. If you're providing your dog the love, attention and care that they need, I think you'd keep them healthy for a long time.
1 person likes this
• United States
6 Mar 07
As a matter of fact I sent my hubby to the vet with the dog today. He got a nail trim, fecal sample, parvo shot, heart worm test and pills and a small bag of urinary diet cat food for a grand total of $200.27. Yikes. The nail trim was $10 and since his nails are black it's so hard for us to do it ourselves and they got too long, so the groomer advised us to have it done every two weeks or so til they recede a bit. They drew blood twice --that's why I didn't want to attempt it. Probabl would have been better at the groomer, but well, he was there with the dog... AND we always take him to McDonald's drive up for a small plain hamburger on "vet days", so add .99 cents, lol.
• Canada
5 Mar 07
Are all the shots necessary? No! I have 2 senior dogs, one over 13 the other is 10. They get the minimum necessary. Just the rabies shot because it is the law. They are both healthy. Any health issues they have I take care of with herbs and homeopathy. My last dog also lived a long healthy life and except for rabies shots never got any others. My original vet was a good old country vet that would not do anything to an animal unless it was needed. Our last dog had some fatty tumours, his attitude was if they are not bothering her don't touch them. I do have a different vet now that tries to pawn off different things but I just go and get the shots..And yes the vets are good at the guilt trip
• United States
6 Mar 07
Yes our dog has a lot of grape-like fatty tumors now. They told me they could remove them, but why put the dog thru that. They already tested one and we know they are benign. We adopted him at the local shelter at age five and he had a tough life back then, so I feel he's got a pretty cushy life at our house. It's not completely the no-frills version, lol.
• United States
5 Mar 07
You need to go to another vet and see how they treat you. Yes, your dog needs certain shots yearly for his healthy. The teeth cleaning is important, to keep tarter off, but not something you must do if you cannot afford it. Just make sure that he gets all yearly shots. It is important for dogs and cats.
1 person likes this
• United States
5 Mar 07
When I was a kid no one ever had their pets teeth cleaned. I doubt if they sold toothbrushes and paste for pets like they do today either!
• United States
5 Mar 07
I would get all the shots and get spayed or neutered but after that they are trying to get more money out of you. You can brush your dogs teeth, dosent cost more than 10$ for brush and toothpaste. Dont let them take you for all you got. Just tell them no.
1 person likes this
• United States
5 Mar 07
I'm wondering how I would like someone to brush my teeth if I was unable to rinse, lol. I guess you get beefy flavored toothpaste. I might try that after the next cleaning. They tell me not to feed my dog canned food for this purpose. I do feed my dog the main part of his food with dry, but put a couple of tablespoons of canned on top to make it taste good. He LIVES for that!
1 person likes this
• Philippines
5 Mar 07
I think you just need the basics for worms, rabies and some 4in1 or 5in1, other than those it really depends on the health condition of your pet, history also plays a vital role in the sense that if your pet has a history of a certain disease, you should ask for some vaccination for this to prevent this. If you are not sure on what a vet is suggesting, try to have a second opinion on other reputable vets.
1 person likes this
• United States
5 Mar 07
Good advice, thanks.
@Mollyjo (266)
• United States
5 Mar 07
Yes Actually you can, ask your vet what shots they need to be legal and you can decided on which other shots you think your dog needs. I know that legally they don't have to have the parvo shot but they do have to have their rabies. this is an easy way to know and be able to tell which ones you want and don't. Any way you need to consider you dog as well. It is entirely up to you. The vet will not tell you this cause they do want the income. After all this is "THEIR JOB"
1 person likes this
• United States
5 Mar 07
Well maybe some of the non-legal "extra" shots you can get every other year or every two years...
• United Arab Emirates
5 Mar 07
defenitely yes... its for safety not only for you but for everybody...
1 person likes this