i'm not beleiving this!

I was most disappointed when Sabrina was choosen over Haley...she is way much better and is really good.Sundance should have stayed,even Jared over Sanjaya.But im glad Antonella ws gone,she shouldnt have been as a finalits in my opinion.No one was really happy with the results(except maybe Sanjaya and Haley supporters),even Paula,america's good girl was left with her mouth open.It was a disappointing night.

i think he should go on lol. but just cause im in love with him lol i dont think he's all that great. and sundance should have stayed i agree. but its probably only like young girls voting and thats why the cute kid gets to stay. its happened every year in the past too.

This happens every season (remember Chicken Little?) and I am just sick of it. Sundance could sings "suns" around Sanjaya. The whole problem is that people are allowed to vote unlimited amounts of times, and these little girls with nothing better to do with auto dial two hours straight for the boy (Sanjaya) that they think is the "cutest" or the most like them. In turn, the more talented ones get the boot because of this lopsided voting. I say allow ONE VOTE per phone. That way people will choose more wisely and also give all singers a fair chance.

I've read a lot of discussion on mylot and everyone agree that sanjaya and haley should not be there. So if everyone who wrote on this board and are from the usa didnt vote for them, who did? I can understand that some people think that sanjaya is cute so that gave him some votes from the teenage girl. But for Haley? Who vote for her. Paula was shocked when she saw Sabrina leaving. She was one of the greatest.

i totally agree! i really hate that kid, because he looks like a girl and has NO talent. i was very disapointed sundance left instead of him. i hope he gets kicked off next week.

The result was a really a disppointment. Sundance sang better than sanjaya... even jared should be in the top 12, i think he's good. Sabrina was better than haley, who should have been in the top 12 also. Maybe, they're trying to make Sanjaya, the underdog in the competion, just like they were saying about Kevin last season, at least kevin could sing. Hopefully, next week Sanjaya will be voted off

I agree with you completely Sanjaya should have gone home and Sundance should have stayed. Also Hayley should have gone home and not Sabrina. Very disappointing.

I was REALLY surprised that Sundance was the one to leave . it broke my heart coz I loved his voice and also his personality (atleast from what they have shown) Sure Sanjaya is a timid cute boy, but he will never make it to be a BIG star... I was also glad to see antonella go home =)

Sundance should still be on American Idol. It was a shock to me. I wanted him to go on. I guess Sanjaya is moving on, but I don't think he will make it. I like Chris Sligh. He is really good. I was hoping Sundance would make it to the tops with Chris Sligh, but you never know who is going to win. But I'm sure Sanjaya will not make it. I can't believe he is still there. Sundance was way better. Oh well. I guess America already voted.

I really don't understand the show this year. For Sundance, I am not really that upset. He had a decent enough voice but he was wildly inconsistent. Sanjaya has gotten by on sympathy and his personality (not a first for American Idol, but certainly one of the more surprising.) Sabrina, however, was robbed. She was considered to be one of the favorites, not by me but by the judges themselves. I can't understand why she went home. Haley was forgettable, I think Simon hit it right on the head with her. But it will be interesting now that the guys are mixed with the girls. I think we'll see two guys go before any of the girls, regardless of Haley still being there.

I'm not even an American Idol fan, but I heard that kid sing this morning and he is horrible. How did he manage to make it this far in the competition? Shoot, maybe I should try to get on the show next time, I'm better than he is, even.

What is this ?Looks like a beauty pageant. If Sanjaya sing a song on how much he hates america,he would still be in the competition. think the people that voted are deaf.I think the judges must vote trought the whole competition,except the big final.

I agree. I was mortified last night that Sanjaya was not sent home...and that Sundance was. I think Sundance is awesome! Sanjaya is not ready for American Idol. His voice is very weak to the point he mumbles the words at times. I think people vote purposely for the worst ones in an attempt to be cute or funny, and it is terribly unfair to those who are really talented.

Well....I was thrilled to see Antonella go. She needed to go for awhile now. I was shocked that Haley was still in, but what really got me was Sanjay. I guess it must be young girls with crushes voting for him. Although I really dont get that either. He creeps me out. I'm only 24, it wasn't that long ago that I was a teenager, and he SO would not have been my type or any of my friends' type either! I'm just crossing my fingers that he leaves next week.

sanjaya should be voted out next week! he doesn't deserve to be in the top 12... I agree that sundance should be in sanjaya's place.... i'm glad antonella was finally gone! hahaha.