Phantom or Raul

Well, the actor who plays the Phantom also plays Westly in The Princess Bride. He is very cute. For me, Raoul's face is too pointy...lol. I agree, the Phantom is hotter, even though the right side of his face is disfigured...

I def. think the Phantom is hotter. I dont really find raoul attractive at all...the phantom is more...dangerous lol. And his deeper voice helps a lot! I prefer deep singing voices.

I have seen both the opera and the movie and I prefer the phantom over Raul anytime. Especially the one in the movie...LOL. But everytime I watch it I keep thinking to myself that Christine should have chosen the phantom.

I prefer the Phantom in the movie version from 2004. Gerard Butler made the disfigured man look pretty good until the last scenes when the mask is removed. I usually prefer the Raoul character when I see the musical in person because it is harder to see the Phantom from far away.

i may be wrong, but i think that something that was portrayed, was to make the phantom more desirable, in a "bad boy" sense. raul is more of the innocent character who is handsome and what we would want to have, but the phantom gives a sense of danger that makes you want him. thats what i got, but if you disagree id love to know what you think. oh, and in answer to the question, i absolutely love the phantom much more than raul. rauls cute and all, but i cant get over his hair.

For me I personally like Raul better because of his devotion to Christine...the Phantom was cool but his 'affection' seemed to be borderline obsession :)

If I had to choose who was hotter, it would definitly be the phantom. He has that whole aura of mystic/mystery working for him and then when you throw in his deep voice, it's a done deal!

The phantom is by far hotter than Raul. It could be because I have always had a thing for guys that had a touch of darkness. Or simply the fact that Gerald Butler is so fine.