Favorite Scott brother

Are you in withdrawl yet? I miss 1 Tree Hill not being on right now! I like both of them-- I really like Lucas better- Nathan is great- but he starts alot of drama. I like the thought that Lucas is hopefully going to find out that Dan is a killer. Honestly I do like them both- Its a great show!

My favorite is Lucas Scott. I like his personality in the show and I love his relationship with Peyton. I knew it that Lucas and Peyton will be together again in the end...

How can you chose? They are so different and hot in their own way. I absolutely love them both. Nate is so sweet to Haley. Putting his dreams on hold for her. He was awful with Peyton. Lucas is so sweet and thoughtful to all his friends whether they are male or female. He would do anything to protect a friend from anything he could. I hope he will be in time to save Peyton.

Mine is definitely Lucas...he is HOT!! He's such a nice guy too. I really hate to see anything bad happen to him and Payton's relationship. I can't wait for the new episodes, I'm dying to find out what happens with Derek and Payton. I'm hoping for the best but expecing the worse!

Between the two Scott brothers, I chose Lucas. A true man, a fighter for what he believe is right. He is also a guy next door. A good friend but sometimes he encounters some bad experiences in life.

my favorite scott brother is definitly lucas

I would say my favorite is Lucas, I just love his character. He's an aspiring writer and I can relate with him easily. Nathan has definitely grown on me though and is becoming hotter by the moment!

I like Luke more at first He is a little weak and I am always on the weak side

for me it's Lucas, cause i like his personality and the he treat interact with others

lucas all the way

Lucas! Nathan has come a long way, but Lucas had me from the beginning (and still does!).