Is an affair between a student and a teacher acceptable to the society?

@kingatul (849)
India
March 30, 2007 11:37am CST
My friend is having an affair with our economics teacher. She is 29 and really beautiful . I even told my friend that this affair will finally yield nothing but he did not gave a thought to this and now his affair has become public. The teacher is on the verge of losing her job and my friend is undergoing a disciplinary action. He has lost the confidence of his family. I really want to help him but am afraid that this will even get me into doubt infront of my family members. Please tell me what should I do. According to me it was noone's mistake and just love.
8 people like this
29 responses
@nicolec (2671)
• United States
30 Mar 07
It is absolutely not acceptable. Parents send their children to school to learn, not to be romanced. It is supposed to be a safe place for kids, not a place to be manhandled by an adult who can't control herself. It's disgusting on the part of the teacher. You didn't say how old your friend is, but I would hope he would have known better as well. It is, in my opinion, mostly the teachers mistake and she should lose her job. I'm not really sure what you should do, except tell your friend he was being stupid.
@sweetsue (758)
• Philippines
31 Mar 07
You have a point nicolec. Parents do send their children to school to learn and not to get romantically involve with their teachers..hehe LOL. In any case, sometimes the world is just so unpredictable. Too bad they are in that situation but you know matters of the hearts are often unmanageable. If they've thought of the consequences beforehand they could have prevented the embarassment instead. But you see, in their case love prevails(I hope its really love)..love sometimes twists one's sanity..LOL In a way, I pity them. I just wish everything will be set in its proper places soon.
• United States
30 Mar 07
Unfortunately there are certain positions in life that we must always put aside any personal feelings and remain professional. A teacher's position is one of those. It's not ethical at all to have an affair with a student and in today's society there are prices to pay for doing so. You haven't commented on how old your friend is but I'm assuming not 18. If this is the case not only is it wrong for the teacher to allow it to happen but it's illegal in most every state I know of. I would say that yes, perhaps they were in love but SHE, as the older and supposedly more wiser adult should have had the sense to say no. If that meant when he turns 18 they still have feelings, then fine. But as a student/teacher relationship it's just not right. You can be there for him as a friend and I think you should be but really, taking a side as to right or wrong will make no difference anyways. It's done and over with. Help him move on.
3 people like this
@kingatul (849)
• India
30 Mar 07
no my friend is not 18 he is 20. I think you are right that she should have refused him .
@Melizzy (1381)
• United States
31 Mar 07
Teachers and Students - A classroom full of students and their teacher.
I don't know what country you live in, but here in America it is against the law, even if a student is of age to consent. It is against the law because a teacher and student are not on a level playing field. A teacher always has the dominant role in the relationship. And why is a 29 year old interested in a high school student?
@kingatul (849)
• India
31 Mar 07
I do not know about that but once that have happened we have to seek for a remedy.
• United States
30 Mar 07
well personally they are adults and it seems liek everyone should mind there own business. the only prob andyone should have is that maybe grades are not being done the way that they should. i think personally that people should mind there own business when it comes to adult relationships unless they are asked by the adults involved. as for your involvement it is up to you. i live my life as it is my life and if others dont agree with me ok fine i repsect your thoughts but at the same time i want them to respect mine. i speak my mind even if i will get flack from it it is just me. it just depends on you. you need to figure out if it is more important to you to stand up for your thoughts if asked or to keep quite to keep peace in your life. we dont pick who we fall in love with many times it just happens and it is a great gift to have that. it is there battle though it is up to you if you will stand in back , in front, to the side, or run.
2 people like this
@nelly5 (1424)
• United States
30 Mar 07
First of all, how old is your friend?? If he is a minor this is most certainly wrong!!! Now if you are in college and your friend is an adult, yes it is still wrong because teachers are not suppose to have relations with their students, with that being said. I think there would be nothing wrong with the relationship ending until he is done with his schooling and then they could pick up from there if they are still interested, that is unless she is married. The it is completely wrong..so I guess I need some more information..lol Is she married?? How old is he?? Thanks, have a great day.
2 people like this
@kingatul (849)
• India
30 Mar 07
Well my friend is 20 and we both are students of an under-graduate course. no she wasn't married but was engaged but now her fiance has refused to marry her.
1 person likes this
@nelly5 (1424)
• United States
30 Mar 07
Well she should have expected to not get married since she is having an affair. Not only should she have been thinking about her fiance but she better be worried about her job too, I am sure once the school board finds out she will most likely be without a job. But like I said before, if they want to continue, they should end the relationship and after he is done with his schooling if they still feel the same about each other then they could start seeing each other again.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
31 Mar 07
Hmmm you're right, there's no wrong when you love but this thing needs to be in its right place & time. It's pretty serious on the thing that's happening between your friend and his girlfriend. If they really do love each other, they can surpass all of those amidst those difficulties they are having right now. All you can do is to be there for your friend no matter what, that's the only thing that he needs and someone who will understand both of them.. =)
1 person likes this
@kingatul (849)
• India
31 Mar 07
I will always be there for him because he's my best friend.
@xbrendax (2662)
• United States
31 Mar 07
If you want to find out if this kind of stuff is acceptable in today's society, just go and ask all the teachers who went to prison for it!
1 person likes this
@kingatul (849)
• India
31 Mar 07
thanks for the advice but all of them wouldn't have undergone the same situation
@magnel (2263)
• India
31 Mar 07
The society takes it very wrongly when a teacher has an affair with his/her student and then all the problems starts. But really can't about it, if it is wrong or right to have an affair with your students or your teacher...
1 person likes this
@kingatul (849)
• India
31 Mar 07
Its not like nothing can be done. The institution authorities should take some hard measures to tackle this problem.
@vanities (11395)
• Davao, Philippines
31 Mar 07
thsoe kind of relationships are not allowed in school..and the teacher knows that..its the call of the teacher to accept him or not...but if they think they are meant for each other one must sacrifice and resign from the job...
1 person likes this
@kingatul (849)
• India
31 Mar 07
i agree with you on this point
@gemini1960 (1161)
• Philippines
31 Mar 07
if im the student and i like or love a teacher i will really profess my good intention to her and i will study more to be able to pass and have a career of my own that she will be proud of me..i know its not tolerated or not acceptable but i prefer to make it secret in the meantime...well since it was been known of all the affair of the two then one must be gone in the school for decency reasons to avoid any controversies that will arises then...maybe the teacher can go..
@kingatul (849)
• India
31 Mar 07
Believe me I felt none of them were having any bad intentions but it was unfortunate that things turned out in this fashion.
@Denmarkguy (1845)
• United States
30 Mar 07
This is really a bit of a gray area. Society likes to put up some very narrowly defined "boxes" around what's appropriate, and what's not... but it's not always so clear. At first, I thought this was an issue of an adult and a child, which clearly would be wrong, but you say your friend is 20, so this is really a relationship between two ADULTS (assuming "adult" means 18, in your part of the world). The reasons I say it is a "gray area" is that let's say your friend was in love with this teacher, but not in her CLASS. Would there be as much of a "stir" going on? Probably not. Sure, people would perhaps give them funny looks on account of the age difference... but nine years is really NOT a huge age difference. The issue really becomes about "ethics" and the appropriateness of the relationship IN THE CONTEXT of "authority/dependent." It's just a variation on "dating your boss." There's nothing "wrong" with it, from a relationship standpoint, but you have LOST any objectivity in the "professional" relationship between a TEACHER and a STUDENT. In this case, I think both of them just made an unwise CHOICE. If the teacher valued her JOB, she could at least have said "this is not going to happen until you are no longer my student." But love makes people do strange things....
@kingatul (849)
• India
30 Mar 07
Yes its true that my friend is an adult but he cannot be given the liberty to have an affair with the teacher. still I feel bad for him because he was pretty serious about her and both of them have suffered too much because of this incident. She have lost her job and my friend has lost the confidence of his family. still he cries for her and says all this has happened to her because of him.
• India
31 Mar 07
It is absloutely not accepted in the society that a student is going sround with his teacher. Teachers are only supposed to teach and guide the students they are not supposed to go on dates with their students. That would be a strange thing to do. I am completely against it.
1 person likes this
@kingatul (849)
• India
31 Mar 07
Yes that is not right but once it happens you should not punish them both so severely without taking the situation into account.
• Malaysia
31 Mar 07
i think it depends on the country whether it is acceptable.at 1st i wanted to say maybe we do not have the right to comment on that because its really none of our business.but after hearing that she got fiance but still wanna involve with her students in affair then definitely it is wrong & non-acceptable.if she have a fiance why she wanna involve in affair??she should have just stick to that guy having a good job & get married later on.but now she do not left anything since she's in the process of losing her job & losing her fiance as well.i am sure her parents would be so ashame about her too.while for your friend i do not think its a love.its more to a crush.so he shouldn't get so over & now this is causing him a lot of problem as well.if he reali love her he would find out first whether that girl is having another guy in her life or not??he should finish his studies first then only continue after tat if he really love that girl
1 person likes this
@kingatul (849)
• India
31 Mar 07
Yes in India it is unacceptable. My friend was aware of the fact that she was engaged and she herself told him. Whatever the outcome may have been I know just that none of them had bad intentions according to me.
@Bell88 (370)
• Malaysia
31 Mar 07
Imagine, first parents have to worry about their kids being bullied or being a bully. Now that next problem, their kids falling in love with their teacher. IT's like before they leave for school,the parents say,"remember kid, it's not right to fall in love with your teacher."
1 person likes this
@inovator (603)
• Philippines
31 Mar 07
well i understandyour situation,,,if we analyze theres no wrong about it,,,as much as they love and single,,,its normal,,because they are humen,,,but we need to accept that in our society its notacceptable coz we treat our teacher as our second parent,yah its hard to decide what you have to do,,,all i can say is just pray for them that lighten their mind,,,and i hope they can solve it....good luck,,,
@kurtbiewald (2625)
• United States
30 Mar 07
half plus 7 she is 29, lets say 30 your friend must be 22 then if he gets in the other Economics class its ok for them to date, if he is 21, its illegal and he must wait
@kingatul (849)
• India
30 Mar 07
I don't think its that simple
@wooitsmolly (3613)
• United States
31 Mar 07
The way I see it is.. if they want to have a public affair then either he should drop out of that school or she should find a new job. I don't see a problem with a relationship between two adults, but when they know that it is something that will bring them troubles (disciplinary action/possibly being fired) then they should be adult about it and fix the situation so that it can work. Other than that, there is probably nothing anyone can do as people will just do what they want and not listen anyway. They will learn their lessons!
@chyszh88 (56)
• China
30 Mar 07
If it was just love,we should do nothing but bless them.Love is the most important thing in this world.
30 Mar 07
Love is very important and everyone deserves it but there are certain people liek teachers who are in positons of responsibility and trust. Surely this woman didnt' need to turn to a pupil for love. Even if it was another teacher or something. Okay so the boy isn't young but he could of easily been.
• Pakistan
31 Mar 07
well this is strange and i think childish and it is not acceptable in our society
• Pakistan
31 Mar 07
well it is little bit strange and i think it is not acceptable to our society