Do you think the Asian Girl part was totally unnecessary?

@Bell88 (370)
Malaysia
March 31, 2007 3:44am CST
I totally feel they should have made the Asian Girl part's plot that she impacted the other families in some other way. What do you think?
4 people like this
5 responses
@buldwgz (1483)
• United States
3 Apr 07
I have no idea what movie this is about. Sorry, but I am very curious now and will have to find out.
@DJ9020 (1596)
• United States
5 Apr 07
Babel.
@invana (11)
• China
24 Apr 07
well,to some extent,I agree with you.cause,until the last minute ,the director didn't tell us who was the real murder killing the mother.It leaves a puzzle.However,the Japnese Girl's plot also reveals the theme of the movie. I think the movie is trying to tell us,no matter where you are ,what color you are ,poor or wealthy,you can't avoid suffering and destiny?
@bornraf (229)
• United States
22 Apr 07
I do not think the Asian girl component of the movie was unnecesary. I believe it was one more of the "parts" of the movie message. The idea behing the Assian girl story, I believe, is to show how lonely a person can be in a fully developed country/society, where the multitude of gadgets, and entertainment is available to its citizens. However, the core values, the familry relationships, the friends, the culture, may be absent. Contrast her story with the story of the Morrocan boys where thjey did not have anything (materially speaking) but had a father and a mother who loved them and took care of them.
@DJ9020 (1596)
• United States
3 Apr 07
It seemed like the japanese connection was the weakest part of the movie. Not as intertwined as the other stories. Personally, this was not my favorite movie.
• Malaysia
1 Apr 07
Unnecessary but she is the most interesting part.