Time out Technique?
By speedy1279
@speedy1279 (2665)
United States
April 4, 2007 10:56am CST
I am wondering how my parents have tried Super Nanny's time out technique? If you have tried it, has it worked for you? If it has not worked, why do you think it hasn't?
I have tried it and so far I have had no luck. I think it is because my husband refuses to use the technique. He doesn't think it will work and has a negative attitude to it. But when he does try it he doesn't do the steps right. I am at my wits end with it and ready to give up.
2 people like this
3 responses
@NewbieHelper (308)
• Canada
28 May 07
Try the time out technique on your husband and see if that works!Seriously!BE FIRM ABOUT IT and refuse to give in...
Once he sees, also - that you are firmly set - and that his interests are BLOCKED EFFECTIVELY by you setting a ROCK SOLID BOUNDARY with him about something...
He might finally come to the conclusion that the technique will be useful and effective for your children, that you and he must work co-operatively with each other, and mostly - it will firmly set a new requirement in your home where you are allotted some consideration for your efforts and for just setting boundaries.
You could do a 'TIME OUT' where you just ask him to give you some 'space' some time apart from a discussion or something that is not going well or coming to any conclusion. Give him an alternative that you will ENFORCE, should he make the 'time out' a difficult or impossible gesture...(much like he makes your authority with your children - minimized - by not working with you)...and then FOLLOW THROUGH NO MATTER WHAT.
Example - "I am enforcing a 'time out' here with this discussion - please go to another room and allow me some space (or 'please stop talking about this' and remain in the same space, if possible) for at least 1 hour - this discussion is OVER. If this is too much for you and you don't have enough respect for me to do this, my alternative, because it is the DISCUSSION that is OVER - is going to be that I will leave the house in order to have my needs met - discussion OVER"And make your plans to leave the house if necessary to ensure that the discussion ENDS by your terms, which are REASONABLE - especially if you were engaged in a discussion that was going around in circles and not coming to conclusions or any compromised ends.
You might have to do this several times, but it has worked for me with some room-mates I've had in the past who are the type that enjoy arguing, extending fight-conversations, and controlling the environment in passive-aggressive ways.
THe 'time out' might not exactly be the same as with kids, but the first thing people often need to teach their significant others is that they WILL NOT BE WALKED ON and disrespected. You have probably taught your husband that it's PERMISSIBLE for him to act the way he does in by-passing your rules for the children. You can teach him they way you want to be treated now.
Once he has some respect for you and allows boundaries to be made, maybe he will be more helpful with concerns surrounding the disciplining of your children.
BTW I outlined an 'activity' detail instead of a 'space' detail for this example because I realize that you can't exactly tell a grown man where to go in his own house lol
The issue isn't the 'where' - it's the behavior and lack of respect for boundaries and rules...
Tell him you're re-setting the rules because the current rules in the home aren't working. He should be perfectly able to deal with that statement - you're not calling anyone or anything wrong...you're just re-grouping.
Re-group the boundaries with him first, if you can. Your kids may not ever listen to you in a really respectful way while they watch your husband act disrespectfully toward you.
@NewbieHelper (308)
• Canada
28 May 07
This also worked on my husband - but I usually had to actually plan ahead and use the 'alternative' of leaving the house.
After a few times, when I would say "The discussion is pointless at this time - please stop for now" he would realize that I would, in fact, make sure the discussion was impossible - that I would leave the house, so he finally stopped acting so 'controlling' about things.
Shortly afterward, he stopped overpowering and undermining the rules I set for my son, too, and started saying "Your Mom is right - that is right, you need to listen" or "Before I say yes or no we will check and see if Mom has some rules already for this"
@vivasuzi (4127)
• United States
11 Apr 07
Yeah I think you both have to be on the same page for it to work. If the kid knows that one parent is gonna let them do whatever, than the other parent doesn't have the chance.
If your husband doesn't like the technique, then you two should really sit down and come up with a punishment that you are both willing to enforce. The important thing isn't the punishment, it's the fact that you stick together that will make it work. Good luck!!
@NewbieHelper (308)
• Canada
14 Apr 07
The 'Time Out' technique works!
Watch the SUPER NANNY some more and start using those techniques on your HUSBAND 'til he stops acting like a child!
LOL - okay - I'm being ridiculous, I know - the techniques might not work on an adult...but if you're really BRAVE you can seriously TRY them on your husband - if he is acting immature, (and he IS acting immature in thinking of his OWN NEEDS and 'authority' over the needs of your child, who REQUIRES DIRECTION from BOTH OF YOU) maybe Super Nanny techniques will work on him, anyway.
The 'Time Out' tips that Super Nanny gives used to work for me when I worked in a small day-home situation where there were, on average, 9-12 children sharing the same space throughout the day, from ages 3-14. I earned the name 'Super Nanny' while working there and honestly, I wasn't all that smart - I just listened to other people who were successful with dealing with child behaviors and employed their methods.
I wish you much luck with your husband - though this thread is supposed to be about you finding help for your child.
Use the 'time out' technique ANYWAY whenever you can. There will be times when your husband is not at home. At least, during those times, use the 'time out' and your child will learn how to manage behavior difficulties in small doses. Don't let the lack of co-operation from your husband simply interfere with how YOU and YOUR CHILD can interact together - and don't abandon good techniques altogether just because you don't have agreement with your husband about the 'rules in the home.'
Perhaps - once you have a few examples of how well the 'time out' has been working for you and your child during times that your husband is out of the house, you can show your husband, by example how excellent a 'tool' the 'time out' is! - Make sure explain to your husband (in case he's seeking 'respect' for his 'authority' in the home) that you're surely NOT TRYING TO UNDERMINE his 'authority,' but simply make your home more pleasant environment for everyone by ensuring that your child's behaviors are more enjoyable to be around.
@blackbriar (9075)
• United States
5 Apr 07
The only way time-out is going to work is if you and your husband are both using it. Consistancy is the key here. Sounds like you need Super Nanny for your husband since he's the one that is giving you trouble as well.




