Who shouldn't have gotten in the top 12??

Philippines
April 6, 2007 7:05am CST
I really really thought that Hayley shouldn't have gotten in the top 12 because Stephanie was infinitely the better singer! I can't really blame Sanjaya going in the top 12 though because I wasn't impressed with the other guys too..
1 response
@gelamela (14)
• Philippines
6 Apr 07
i liked hayley during the auditions but i realized that there are far better singers than her who should have gotten the spot in the top 12. simon was right when he commented that her performances are a bit high school musical/broadway-ish... sanjaya also shouldn't have been included in the top 12!the show is supposed to be a singing competition.that's what the judges keep on saying. but the results only show otherwise. i think people are now voting for who they think is charming or something like that. i was really rooting for jared and aj to make it in the top12 but they didn't make it. while sanjaya, who has such a weak singing voice, made it through AND managed to stay longer than sabrina, stephanie, and gina. (sane goes with hayley).i just can't believe it.