Which one is the best season of Idol?

Whichever one chris daughtry was on! I think he was on the one with Taylor right?! I pulled for Chris, I really liked him, his singing, his personality, his affection for his family and everything, I wish he would have won, but I guess then he would have been stuck singing whatever he was told instead of following his dream and being able to do what he wanted. So I guess it all works out, but that was my favorite season!

I think the last season was the best! It had a lot of diversity in it and a lot of real talent. I was a "Soul Patrol" member from the first audition that I seen of Taylor Hicks. I knew that if America voted on talent alone that he would win! I think this season is okay, but doesn't have the talent that the other seasons have had. There is some talent this year,but not as much as in the past.

I agree with season 5 I liked a lot of singers better then Taylor Hicks. Chris Daughtry, Kellie Pickler and Katherine McPhee were all better to me then him. I still don't get how the Disco king won.