Do you like it when the author kills off one of the main characters?

@krayzee (1160)
Romania
April 9, 2007 7:40am CST
I have yet to decide which annoys me more. There are some thriller novels or horror ones that begin with a bunch of characters vaguely sketched and all but the main ones die. Those main ones managing to escape quite a few very tricky situations via some hardly believable means. There are other novels where the author presents us some characters in very much detail and just when we begun to know and like them he kills them off. So, what do you like more or what do you dislike? An author who does anything (believable or not) to keep the main characters alive or one who kills whichever character he pleases regardless of its importance?
7 people like this
20 responses
@seamonkey (1976)
• Ireland
9 Apr 07
I really dislike it when a main character is killed off, particularly in a series where the character has appeared in novel after novel. I was like that when JK Rowling axed Sirius, the Dumbledore, now I am holding my breath to see who she axes next.
1 person likes this
@Myrrdin (3599)
• Canada
9 Apr 07
You may dislike it, but the fact that you are "holding [your] breath to see who she axes next" show's how powerful killing off a character can be. Despite you disliking her killing off the characters you are still going to read the next, and in fact you are nervously awaiting the next book.
1 person likes this
• United States
10 Apr 07
I completely understand what you are talking about there are a few books that I have read that I feel have made me very upset to the fact that I just wanted to cry because right in the middle of the book the author kills my favorite person/ the lead character. I would have to say that I dislike the fact that the author does that I don't know if it's to get the reader half way thru the book or if it's just to keep you in suspense until the last minute.
1 person likes this
@krayzee (1160)
• Romania
10 Apr 07
Isn't that so? :) Thanks for the comment :)
@mslena75 (561)
• United States
10 Apr 07
I guess I never really thought about it...I know I pretty mad at the last Harry Potter book, that she killed off Dumbledore. I really liked him and how he kept Harry Potter under his wing. I was disappointed, but oh well. I suppose all good things must come to an end.
1 person likes this
@krayzee (1160)
• Romania
10 Apr 07
I felt the exact same way. Thank you for the comment :)
@Shaun72 (15959)
• Palatka, Florida
10 Apr 07
I hate it when a author takes away a good charcter like the Harry Potter books it is going to be over with the last book. Either one of the 3 will be gone. It will proberly be Harry since the story is about him.
@krayzee (1160)
• Romania
10 Apr 07
I'll be very sad so see one of the 3 die too. I'm actually kind of hoping it'll be Harry and not one of the others (because it's Harry's own fight and he's aware of the risks, the others are just there to help) Thanks for the comment :)
• India
10 Apr 07
When i am studing an interesting novel with suspense and the main characters find to be interesting, and it will be curious to know about the end how the main character is going to solve the problem. But suddenly if i come to know by reading that the author kills the main character, i feel very sad and my interest in continuing goes off.
1 person likes this
@krayzee (1160)
• Romania
10 Apr 07
Thank you for the comment :)
@ninong (110)
• Philippines
10 Apr 07
I think I would like an author more if he makes me care enough for the character that i would really be sad (even annoyed) if he kills the character. Characters can die depending on the story; any author can kill his characters at will but only good writers can make you wish they live.
1 person likes this
@krayzee (1160)
• Romania
10 Apr 07
That is very true. Thanks for the comment. :)
@MGjhaud (23154)
• Philippines
10 Apr 07
that really depends. if he is the villain then go ahead. but sometimes it would really take on me. i like i stop reading and trying to absorb what just the author did. hehe.. i get carried away sometimes.
@ahmar2 (682)
• Pakistan
9 Apr 07
I think first one is more realistic and better.
1 person likes this
@cutepenguin (6431)
• Canada
9 Apr 07
I once read a book by Guy Gavriel Kay in which you get very interested in several of the main characters, and throughout the book, it's kind of inevitable that one of them will die. In fact, they can't all survive in order for the book to work. I was quite upset.
1 person likes this
@Myrrdin (3599)
• Canada
9 Apr 07
Which book, I rather like Guy Gavriel Kay, but I haven't read much of his work.
@mashimaro (1094)
• Philippines
10 Apr 07
It is not worth it to see that kind of movie, you are spending 2 hours and a half to see that movie and then the main characters will die..hmmmmm..it is not worth it.
@krayzee (1160)
• Romania
10 Apr 07
LOL, I was talking about books :) Thanks for the comment though.
@mashimaro (1094)
• Philippines
12 Apr 07
Yah, but it is similar whatever it is a book or a movie..hmmmm...
@rizalcb (33)
• Malaysia
10 Apr 07
I don't like when the main character die. But if I not like that main character I don't mine the character die .. :D
@krayzee (1160)
• Romania
10 Apr 07
Definitely so. No one minds if the characters they don't like die :P Thanks for the commment :)
@nic_knick (739)
• China
10 Apr 07
well. i have seen a movie about this kind of killing. the movie is about a guy being narrated in a novel. and he is narrated to be killed, but he himself just thought that he was being followed by sb else. and it is pretty weird that finally he noticed sth , and he found the writer. who is about to kill him, and the author was quite surprised that the man she is narrating in her novel is standing in front of her. and it is prescribed that the man should be killed in teh car accidnet. but at last .he was saved by the author. i simly do not like it when the author kills off one of the main characters in his or he novels...................
@krayzee (1160)
• Romania
10 Apr 07
I seem to remember this movie. Is it Stranger Than Fiction by any chance? Thanks for the comment :)
@joanna08 (394)
• Philippines
9 Apr 07
I think it depends on the story. Some stories really need to kill off the main character for a reason. I mean, tha uthor didn't just do it just for fun. He/she did it for the story to be good and to also benefit other characters. I would understand the author for killing off the main, like maybe HARRY POTTER in the 7th book. But sometimes like you, authors kill off the main/protagonist but I dont see the reason behind it. That for me is a book not worth reading. Or not just in my list of favorite or most read for my friends.
• Philippines
10 Apr 07
hmmm not really..if its really needed in the story why not..and i wanted to have a story which is not the typical story.lets have something new..not the so happy ending story..the they lived happily ever after..
@krayzee (1160)
• Romania
10 Apr 07
Thanks for the comment :)
@nandans (1160)
• India
10 Apr 07
I hate this and hate those also who continue with the same spirit.
• Canada
9 Apr 07
I've been reading a fantasy series for a number of years now called A Song of Fire and Ice. It is told from the point of view of several characters -- mostly the members of a large noble family. In the third book of the series, I nearly stopped reading it altogether because the author killed off one of the three main characters! It was months before I picked up the book again (literally! When the character was killed off, I threw the book across the room and left it there). It is now two books later in the series and several more prominent characters have bit the dust. I'm still not used to it, and I felt angry all over again when a major character was killed off in the last book. I'm wondering who will be left after the last book in the series! On the other hand, I'm really enjoying the TV show Lost, in which several main characters have been killed off already.
@krayzee (1160)
• Romania
10 Apr 07
So you understand my annoyance LOL. Thanks for commenting :)
1 person likes this
@kogiro (124)
• Portugal
9 Apr 07
When reading a book or watching a movie or a Tv serie, I like when the authors keep me in my toes, and the stories are filled with twists and turns, and no character is "safe", regardeless of his importance, of corse I don`t like when one my favorites characters is killed of, but i think that is prefereble to a monotonous and eventful tone, where some books series fell.
@krayzee (1160)
• Romania
9 Apr 07
Yes, I think you are right (you and everyone else who said that in this discussion :) ). I have to admit I never thought about it like that :) Thanks for the comment :)
• India
10 Apr 07
killing of important characters may increase the rating of a novel.according to the story killing of that particular person may be apt.i heard that in last part of harry potter she is going to kill one of the main characters .
@Arkadus (895)
• Canada
9 Apr 07
I like the possibilty that the character could get killed off. It's far more realistic.
@krayzee (1160)
• Romania
9 Apr 07
That is also true. Thanks for the comment :)
@ml8284 (111)
• China
10 Apr 07
no