My 5 year old has really started back talking...what do you recommend?

United States
April 16, 2007 10:10am CST
My 5 year old son has started backtalking A LOT! If I tell him to pick up his toys he will say for example.."Here are your choices..I'll pick up a few toys after you give me some ice cream or I want you to go away" What do you suggest? How can I curb this? I don't know where this behavior came from but it is DEFINATELY driving me crazy! Have any of your children done this? Please help!
2 people like this
4 responses
@wendee (359)
• Canada
16 Apr 07
My daughter started telline me no when I asked her to pick up her toys until one day I took a garbage bag and cleaned them up for her. I then put the garbage bag in the garage and slowly she earned her toys back. She really didnt want me to get rid of them.
@wendee (359)
• Canada
16 Apr 07
Awwwww! poor you! She doesnt talk to me like that, but she does get sulky and pouty. I jsut tell her that she was given the choice to clean them up or get them taken away. It was up to her.
2 people like this
@all4ucnc (861)
• United States
16 Apr 07
My son is also 5 and has started the lets make a deal, . . . "I'll do ------ If you give me some ------" . It never works for him, I just tell him, he's not the one that's makes the deals in this house and you will do what I ask. He still tries though, and now I'm watching a little girl who is almost 5, and she does the same thing, so it's just a phase, and they all must go through it. Take it one day at a time, you never know this phase may be better than the next they start to go through...
2 people like this
• United States
16 Apr 07
lmao! You sound just like me, but I have 3 of them to deal with. They all have went through this stage or are going through it. I am a no non-sense mom so I don't make deals. Period. My kids know this, but they still try anyways. My oldest son has said some pretty hurtful things to me also, and has also given me a black eye a couple of times. To his credit, he is diagnosed with bipolar and adhd also. So sometimes the little arguments over toys get to seem like the lesser battle. My only way of curbing these tendencies with my children was to just never start. I never gave in, never made a deal, and I still don't. It may be harsh, but at least it is completely fair to all of them. lol
@KissThis (3003)
• United States
16 Apr 07
If my child refuses to pick their toys up I give them two options. Either they pick their toys up themselves or I pick them up and they become mine. I have earned myself a few toys doing this but for the most part it has worked. If they are mouthing off for some other reason then I will take their favorite toy away till they show me the respect I feel I deserve.
2 people like this