The Blame Game - who's responsible?

United States
April 17, 2007 1:42pm CST
In another thread the issue of personal responsibility came up. I'd love to discuss it but didn't want to go off topic for that thread so here's a new one just for "The Blame Game". It seems like people don't agree on just how much responsibility one should take onto themselves. On one end, there are people who believe that by their own moral/ethical code or religion they should take the fair amount of blame for everything having to do with them. At the other end there are those who seem to believe more of "the devil made me do it" blameless theory. And then there's people that fall somewhere between the two ends of the spectrum which seem to be the majority of people. So which are you? How much responsibility should a person take? Is it always, never, or sometimes your fault when something goes wrong? Do you think one way is better than another?
1 person likes this
2 responses
@nicolec (2671)
• United States
17 Apr 07
This is actually a great topic to be talking about in the midst of what just happened in Virginia. I certainly don't believe that these people were at all responsible for what happened to them. However, I suspect that some would say yes they are. They chose to go to that school. They chose to take that class. Therefore it was their choice that put them in the shooter's path. Yet, others will say, God works in mysterious ways and if it was their time to go, then there isn't anything they can do about it. Because God will take them home anyways. Me? I believe we are influenced by so many factors other then our selves. Parents, friends, teachers and the worst influencer of all is the media. I do believe we should take resposibility for most of the things in our lives. But even if you believe you have made the right choice, it does not mean all will turn out well. There are just too many outside forces. And not necessarily that of a higher being. Although, I suspect he has a little to do with it.
• United States
17 Apr 07
By "taking full responsibility" I just personally mean that yes, they'd take responsibility for making the choice to go to that school etc. But where does the responsibility lie for the actual shootings? None of them asked to be shot or did anything we know of specifically to entice getting shot so do they bear any responsibility? It's hard to say. Did any of them notice a person in trouble and didn't do anything to help out? Did any of them actually do something harmful in some way to this guy? If so then I say they do bear some of the responsibility. Note I didn't say he was justified in what he did! No doubt, I'd place most of the burden of responsibility on the shooter. It was his choice to do this, no two ways about it. But is there more responsibility to go around? Friends? Family? Teachers? Society? I suspect so. I believe in taking full responsibility for everything that happens in your life BUT no more than your fair share.
• United States
19 Apr 07
Yes, I'm getting a better picture as more details like those you mentioned are coming out. It sounds like there were at least a few who recognized he was in some kind of difficulty and tried to help at least a little. Is there anything else that could've been done though? I don't know. Did even the mental health professional(s) he was referred to realize how badly damaged this guy was? Could someone have had him forcibly committed and prevented this whole thing? Even now it's unclear and it's easier to see things in hindsight so how clear was it before the incident? Really most of what I have is more questions than answers. I do now put less blame on the shooter and more on the media. Still as much responsibility on the shooter as before but less blame, if you catch the difference. It looks to me like this was a severely ill person so I don't know how much of the blame is on him and how much is simply the result of his illness. I can't BLAME a person with a cold for sneezing, only hold them RESPONSIBLE for not sneezing on me! I do believe though that all this media attention directed at the people who do these things is only creating the likelihood that others will do the same. Lonely, bitter, angry, sick people seem to see this as their only shot at "fame". Kind of like some really awful expression of the saying "if you can't set a good example be a terrible reminder".
• United States
17 Apr 07
How much responsibility is taking responsibility? Unfortunately, I do think the devil gets blamed for a lot of things even he wouldn't stoop to.