book V/s movie

India
May 3, 2007 8:21am CST
The latest eragon movie was soo messed up u'l hate it if u've read the movie i could live with seeing a movie of 5 hours rather than 2 but why cut the main plot????
1 response
@juicemilk (2283)
• Australia
3 May 07
I've read the books and I didn't think the movie sucked. You do need to realise that the movie is separate to the books, and needs to be able to stand alone for people who haven't read the books so they can understand what is going on. My boyfriend really enjoyed the movie and is now going to read the books. Sure there were some things that annoyed me, I wish they had made Arya look more like an actual elf, I don't think they even mentioned anything about her being an elf. And also I didn't really like the King in the movie Are they definitely making the second book into a movie? I think that will be interesting to see, as there are more plot lines in that one, with Eragon's story as well as Roran's
• India
28 May 09
i understand what ur sayin.. but in actuality the book makes u feel closer to d characters while reading the book i wished that i could be a dragon rider...but d movie just doesnt giv u d same feeling i would rate the book a thousand times better anyday..