Spanking your children

United States
October 22, 2006 3:50pm CST
Do you/will you spank your children? I believe there are alternatives to spanking-what do you think?
2 people like this
16 responses
• United States
22 Oct 06
Yes sometimes that form of discipline is necessary.
• United States
22 Oct 06
In what situations do you think it's necessary?
1 person likes this
• United States
22 Oct 06
It is more like this-I always try to talk to my children first-sometimes communication doesn't work.....physical discipline can be essential for getting the point across bluntly-but it is never to be confused with abuse-my children are NEVER hit-it is always spanked and only on the rear end-never to arms, legs, faces, etc. Unfortunatley there is a very fine line and some people think spanking is abuse no matter what.
2 people like this
• United States
22 Oct 06
Thank you for your honest answer. I'm just trying to understand everyone's definitions of spanking.
1 person likes this
@Tanya8 (1733)
• Canada
25 Oct 06
Yes, I agree that there are many alternatives. Spanking is becoming less and less common here.
2 people like this
@Tanya8 (1733)
• Canada
27 Oct 06
I'm from Canada. (I hope I haven't offended any pro-spanking Canadians).
2 people like this
• United States
26 Oct 06
You said "less common here" May I ask where your from?
1 person likes this
@nextgen (1888)
• India
28 Oct 06
although i dont have children but even in future, i m not going to spank
• United States
28 Oct 06
You may change your mind when your child is acting like a Barbarian.
2 people like this
• India
28 Oct 06
I totally agree with you.I would never spank my child when i have one. Maybe if the situation demands I may spank him. But, that would be a light spanking. I feel in today's world parents have to become their children's friend if they want to have a healty relationship with them.
2 people like this
• India
1 Nov 06
i prefer not to .
2 people like this
@ladydi151 (202)
• United States
2 Nov 06
Yesterday we spanked. Now we count 1-2-3. I guess counting will teach them how to count. What number are you going end your counting? When the child hurts himself. Spanking is good.
2 people like this
@missyann73 (1454)
• United States
1 Nov 06
there is nothing like the hand. I was spanked being raised and I feel my parents did a good job by me. I spanked my daughter, NOT BEAT- and she has turned out wonderful. Kids now days get to much material things, and not enough family time.
1 person likes this
• United States
25 Nov 06
and that is what makes it very confusing-and some people look down on it-my children know 100% it is discipline and they fear a spanken-so usually they dont do wrong knowing it may come (as a bad punishment)
• United States
26 Oct 06
I am a parent, with a fifteen year old daughter and a nione year old daughter, along with a 19 yr. old stepson, and fifteen yr. old step-daughter. Understand that I will not claim to know all, and then state I do not have children. That is about as bad as having a woman teach a Divorce class about how to treat your children, and the turn around and say she has none...(this has happened to me and I got up and walked out). First, all children are different, and must be considered so. But... There is a time to get their butts, and if you don't then authority in your own house is lost, as they see you as weak and not willing to enforce the rules you have set down. I truly despise folks who do not understand that force is needed as a loving response when discipling your children, as it sets boundaries that they are to follow or consequences are paid. Life is not fair, and any fool who teaches their children that it is; is doing them a disservice. If you steal, then aren't there consequences? If you lie, should there not be consequences? If you break the rules of my house, then should there not be consequneces? I do not advocate smacking your child anywhere but on the bottom, except in cases where the mouth overloaded the a** when back-talking, of which I will not abide, and sometimes...it doesn't hurt for a child to know what Ivory soap tastes like. New Age, IRS's religion Scientology, and other ignorant social ideologies have sapped many parents of their will to actually teach their own children right from wrong, and allow the Public School (Fool) system to supplant them as parents. I wish for this to not be so, but fear that topics such as this one, will continue until parents finally take control of their children once again as described in Natural law. Think about it for just one moment, please...Did your grandparents turn out so terribly bad? Food for thought. Freedomrox
1 person likes this
• United States
26 Oct 06
I appreciate your honest answer even though I do disagree with you.
1 person likes this
• United States
28 Oct 06
Well I think you worded your thoughts greatly, and discipline is necessary in the form of spanking sometimes.
2 people like this
@jray721 (1969)
• United States
2 Nov 06
i dont spank my son. there are other ways to discipline than with hitting. plus i dont want to teach him that its ok to hit. ya know?
1 person likes this
• Australia
6 Nov 06
If you are a loving parent that nurtures your child and tries to teach him values then a spank when they need it isn't going to turn them into a wife beater.
@justnitya (1392)
• India
2 Nov 06
no
• United States
6 Nov 06
I myself agree with spanking, at least up to a certain age. At some age they arent going to listen anyhow. I do think that time out is for the birds. I think if we were able to punish kids like our parents did, kids wouldnt turn out the way they are.
@salex142 (686)
• United States
6 Nov 06
When ever my daughter is doing something that she isnt supposed to, I counted down from 5 and if she doesnt stop thaen she gets popped on the hand. My parents spanked me. I feel that the child starts to understand that if i dont do bad things, then i wont get popped. It teaches themabout Cause and Effect. But dont just beat on them. After I pop her hand I explain why it was wrong to do what she did.
• Australia
6 Nov 06
Thats exactly what i think, some of these people are getting carried away and confusing a light spank with flogging and beating etc. If it is a controlled smack and not just given out willy- nilly but when they absolutely need to learn the consequences of their actions it is fine.
@Brandi06 (2227)
• United States
2 Nov 06
some time they need to be spanked
1 person likes this
@ozangel82 (753)
• Australia
6 Nov 06
I feel that when your child is about to touch a hot stove or stick fingers in power points a smack on the bottom or hand is necessary for them to associate the shock and (minimal) pain with the bad action. If a kid tries to stick things in the power point and you just say no and put him in time out the child will still be curious and not realise the fact that a power point hurts. I dont advocate unnecessary spanking, but put it this way, how many of you were spanked as a child? Ok now how many of you are serial killers or rapists or 'bad' people? Really? Wow spanking mustn't be that bad if we all survived it and came out the other side with a few lessons on behaviour.
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Nov 06
Sometimes spanking is needed. It clears the air. The child is punished, the wrong-doing is forgiven and the slate is wiped clean. Spanking is done on the bottom, not a slap across the face or anywhere else.
@LoveRatt (12)
• United States
2 Nov 06
I believe that each child is different. With my first daughter I never spanked her, with my second child all I had to do was point, with my son I do at times. I believe there is a punishment for each child. As they grow spanking may be desirved but not as a little child, only if they are old enough to know why they are being spanked.