Can anyone tell me how to discipline my 3-year-old son?

sean kirk - 3-year-old wonderful boy
Philippines
May 28, 2007 7:54am CST
I just don't know how to discipline my son whenever we are out of the house ie. mall, church, market, etc... He is super active as if he doesn't mind if he get lost. I know it is normal for a kid, but at least I want to minimize it. Any suggestion you can give me?
6 responses
• United States
28 May 07
Stickers. 3 year olds love stickers (at least every 3 year old I know) and they love to earn stickers. First, we started with a sticker chart at home and they would get stickers for doing good stuff and have them taken away when they were bad. We decided that this was working well so we took the stickers "on the road." We got a little notebook for each of the kids and anytime we went out we took these notebooks (and I kept a stash of stickers and a black permanent marker in my purse). We called them "sticker passports." At first, every time we went out we praised the kids over and over for good behavior, for everything! Each time they did something good, they got a sticker in their "passport." If they misbehaved (cried or screamed in the store when told "NO" or hit his brother, or something) we would mark through 1 sticker with the marker, that one no longer counted. When we first started, all they had to do was earn 10 stickers and they would get a reward (for our kids, it was a lollipop). As they got more used to the system, we increased the number of stickers they needed to be rewarded and as they've gotten older we give stickers only for excellent behavior now, not for just doing what is expected, but going above and beyond. It still works, and they are 7 and 5 now. They have several "sticker passports" that they now get to keep with their sticker "collections." Good luck! I hope you find something that works for you and your son.
• Philippines
28 May 07
That's a good idea but I think it will best work only if he has a rivalry. But atill reward really works. Thanks.
• Philippines
30 May 07
You are right. I will try what you're doing. It might really works. :-)
• United States
29 May 07
Well, I do hope you find something that helps with him. Children at that age can be difficult and what works for one will not necessarily work for another.
1 person likes this
@rapolu_cs (1184)
• India
29 May 07
This a critical to give suggestions although i think it is the thing depends on the way you treat youir son and control him by threating him or by saying him that he is not taken out for the next time if he does any mischive .
• Philippines
30 May 07
It is not that critical. I can try whatever way but of course the way that will not harm my son. Thanks for the concern.
@wmaharper (2316)
• United States
28 May 07
Many children will behave at home well, but when out in public will act out. If your son does this, he is most likely testing his boundaries. He wants to see if you will discipline him w/every one watching. he knows that it embarrasses you, and that you don't like it when he acts up in public, so he does. It's normal behavior, but not acceptable. I would suggest that when he acts up in public, lay down the law. Be even more strict then when you are at home, for awhile, until he begins to understand that you will punish him, regardless of the location, once he gets it, you can back off a bit, (but if you notice his behavior changing again, reign him in again). YOu may have to leave the grocery store, or the park. When my oldest (almost 3) hits at the park, he gets one warning, he is made to apologize to the kid he hits of course, but then I tell him, son, if you hit again, we will leave and go home. If he hits agian, we go home. that's it. Eventually they will learn that there are rules, and if they will not obey those rules, they will have a punishment. I also suggest to be very consistent with your punishments, and to let your child know beforehand what is expected of him. Good luck. Hope I helped.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
28 May 07
Absolutely! This tip will help me discipline my son. I am considering all of your suggestions. Thanks.
@raredog (743)
• Philippines
28 May 07
Stars and stickers are great. My suggestion is by looking them straight at the eye and telling them politely that what he's doing is bad and ask him to tell you that he won't do it again or you might get angry with him. And he wouldn't like you when your angry. incredible hulk. lol
• Philippines
28 May 07
Oh I've been doing that to him. When he did bad and I got mad, he keeps on saying "Sorry, I won't do it again" But still he do it again and again. But it is understandable for he is just a kid. :-)
@mama4kids (690)
• United States
28 May 07
it is a hard thing...discipline. but it needs to start in the home. if you discipline him at home, then threaten him out in public, quietly..lol. one thing that works for me is the star chart system. i have a poster board on the wall and in each of the four quarters, i put one of my kids names. under their name, they get stars when they do something good,like cleaning up after themselves, sharing with their siblings, etc... i use this out in public too by telling them that if they dont start acting good, i will take a star away. that scares them!! the deal is when each of them reaches 50 stars, then they all get to do something fun. but they all have to have 50 so this teaches them to work together so they can do something fun. this months fun place is chuck e cheese. 2-3 yr olds are just plain old difficult. it doesnt matter what you do, they will still act like monkeys from time to time...lol. my 2 yr old doesnt listen well outside of the house either. the older he gets, the easier it gets. my 4 yr old listens great. so just try, and give it time. at least you know he is normal because he is!!! good luck to you!!!
• Philippines
28 May 07
What funny is whenever he's inside the house, he is tame but once out of the house..... he became wild and untamed.... hahahaha... Ok as you said time will come that he will listen easily. Hope once he started schooling, everything will change.
• United States
28 May 07
It sounds like you need advice for running or wandering away. I had a child like that-he's 5 now and a little more sane, lol, but I really wish I'd bought a harness. I had some near misses with him that weren't necessary, b/c I was opposed to using a "leash". If he likes it, great-you have a way to keep him safe while shopping. If he hates it, let him know that he has one chance on each outing to stay with you and hold your hand (hold the cart, or however you want to keep up with him). If he runs away or wanders off, he has to use the leash to be safe, and he can try again next time to do without it.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
28 May 07
Yes you got my point. He wanders around whenever we are in a public place. I saw other parents using that leash also but I don't want to use it to him. However, it comes always in my thought. :-D