A beggar asks you for money. What do you do?

@gsmile88 (151)
Canada
June 11, 2007 10:57pm CST
Do you give him/her the money or just ignore them? Some people think that beggars deserve what they get (i.e. they got kicked out of home because of something), and some people think beggars should be given another chance. I think that beggars should be given a little money. They might be sorry, so just give them a chance. But if they aren't, then they only have A LITTLE money; not a lot; what can they do with it... nothing?
1 person likes this
4 responses
• India
13 Jun 07
i would really check if the person asking for the alms is really in need of it... i.e. if he is not able to work (physically challenged) or old, then i would give him some money. but if the beggar is healthy, i will definitely not give any money to him/her.
@gsmile88 (151)
• Canada
13 Jun 07
Yes-- I would do that sometimes too. It actually depends on what mood I'm in when I give money-- how much and if I give.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
12 Jun 07
But mind you, not all beggars are beggar. There are some who are lazy to work and so that just sit on the street and extend their hands for alms. Sometimes they even forced people to give them. Not that I am against them. I give alms only to those who are physically handicapped. Those without limbs or arms. So before I give them some money or sometimes food, I size them up first. I witnessed a group of beggars in their attire that will make them really look like beggars sitting in a dark alley and gambling!
@gsmile88 (151)
• Canada
12 Jun 07
Wow. I thought that only happened to be in movies or shows! But giving them a little money for their next meal, but not for their whole fix would be good. Another chance. And also, there are some people who kidnap kids and break their arms and legs and tell them to beg. I heard about it in China. It happens there.
@magica (3707)
• Bulgaria
12 Jun 07
Most of them are actors and good manipulators too. I think that the people who are really in need are not aggresive and they just try to solve the situation. I prefer if i have some more money, to help a friend then to a beggar.
@gsmile88 (151)
• Canada
12 Jun 07
True. They are wasting talent on begging, those actors and actresses. If they are so good, they should be actors and actresses.
@portugirl (108)
• Singapore
12 Jun 07
I think that if you give in good faith and with sincerity, not wondering whether the beggar is genuine or not, it good. But you are right, a little money maybe to buy him his next meal (not his next fix) would be good enough!
@gsmile88 (151)
• Canada
12 Jun 07
Yes... I think everybody should do that... but there are people who think if they can get money out of one person, everyone would work...