Deathly Hallows Still Leaves Unanswered Questions ** Warning Spoilers**

United States
July 23, 2007 9:38am CST
I am sad to see Harry Potter End, but I first must say that The Deathly Hallows is the best of them all in my opinion. However it still left me with unanswered questions, Please share yours. Here are some of mine... What careers did everyone end up with, we only know Neville's?? Who raised Ted??? What happened with George? What happened to Fawkes, I thought he would return but he did not? How did Lupin & Tonks die, together/apart, by whoms hand? Who became Minister of magic, Kingsley was temporary? Who became headmaster, I assume it was McGonagal, but was she still head mistress when the children went? It gave Albus' full name as Albus Severus, but what about James? I assume it was James Sirius but is this assumption right? Luna, what happened to her?? and Kreature? I am sure there are more...
4 people like this
5 responses
• Philippines
24 Jul 07
I'm assuming that McGonagall is the headmistress now, if she's still alive in time of the epilogue. I guess Mrs. Rowling did that because she wanted us readers to fill it in for ourselves. Maybe she would answer those questions in an interview later on, but maybe she just wants the readers to have something to think about. That'll keep the HP world alive. :)
• Philippines
24 Jul 07
And I also found it a bit amusing, the epilogue. If we look at the timeline, harry's born in 1980 right? So the 7th book happened in 1997. He's 17. So add 19 years to that, he's supposed to be 36 already. But if he's born in 1980, he should only be 27 right now. Lol! So the epilogue should happen on 2016, 9 years from now! Just an observation. :)
2 people like this
@ElicBxn (60762)
• United States
25 Jul 07
We have no way of knowing where Harry & Ginny are living, I'm guessing in Sirius' house. I also assume that Kreature is there, even if he's a free elf now. House elves live to serve, even Dobby, while free, felt the need to be useful. No, they didn't give us James' middle name, but I also assume its Sirius - I wonder what Lily's is, maybe her other grandmother's. IF they were smart, Kingsley remained the Minister of Magic, but that was 19 yrs before & the magic people grow old & die just like normal humans. I'm going to be honest with you, I think that Nevil pulling the Grifidor sword out of his robe should prove to the Goblins that it needs to remain with the magicians and that Nevil was truely in the correct house after all. Maybe Bill is the new headmaster - actually, all I care is that Percy isn't! He's too rule bound & doesn't think well for himself for a job like that.
2 people like this
• Indonesia
25 Jul 07
WOAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH thx a lot for many spoilers guys I'm to lazy to read HP in English. I can waiting till Indonesian version come out but its sad to know Snape also die. He is my idol at HP T____T Once again thx a lot guys
1 person likes this
@jamie11982 (1662)
• United States
25 Jul 07
ok there are some unanswered question but to answer a few of yours. Ted was raised by tonks's mother because if you remember that's where she left him when she went to join lupin. i'm betting that lupin and tonks where both killed by the same person but at different times. When tonks heared who lupid was fighting that's when she took off to help him and i think that it was to late by the time that she got to him.the question of minister of magic was one of mine and the headmaster of hogwarts was another question that i asked myself. As for naming his son james i bet that it was his father's full name. Kreature was his house elf how protected him until he faced voldermort so there for knowing that kreature lived and that harry already had sirius's house then i'm saing that it's safe to bet that they got along great. the only other question that i asked myself was yes what did happen to George and who named their kid after Fred. I'm thinking that ron did but who knows for sure. I did like the little twist of Ted kissing Bill and flouri's daughter though. That was pretty cute. It's a shame that Harry Potter is now over i'll miss all of the new books about his life. If only she would write about their children as well. Just to keep us loyal fans on the edge of our seats to see what will happen next. I finished her book in three days but that was only because i had things to do and i was not able to bring the book with me. Other then that i would have had it done in two. I'll miss more but now i can't wait to see what they put into the movies.
• Malaysia
24 Jul 07
I think the writer ain't very concern about letting you know those things. Telling what everybody becomes will take damn lot of pages. I myself didn't ask such questions after I finish reading. I don't think I care a lot about them as well. Somehow, the book has explained things that's happening pretty good. They made sense. I guess you can always guess what happen to those people after 19 years. :)
1 person likes this