Is Dhoni the best oneday Captain India ever had?

India
February 11, 2008 6:13am CST
This is regarding the the leading capacity of Dhoni. What you guys think about it. I am really confused. Some decision he takes is really admirable. On the other hand some are just does not make any sense. For example if we take yesterdays match (10th Feb 2008) with Australia some of his decision is really amazing. First of all giving Ishant Sharma the brand new ball was a fantasting decesion. And again calling Ishant shamra after australia was down with 4 wickets I think was a great idea as that was the last recognized pair of batsman and if India could manage with another wicket then the rest would be the tailenders. And in this case his tricks worked. On the other hand sending out Pathan as a pinch hitter does not make any sense as the target was not that so high. In that case sending out a recognized batsman like Yuvraj who is struggling with his current form would have been a better choice. So what you Guys say?
6 responses
@player143 (879)
• India
20 Feb 08
Dhoni is not the best captain India ever had.He is a good captain and has leadershipping qualities.He supports his team members very well.He is experimenting a lot.His batting average is good after taking captaincy.DHONI matured really well as a batsmen.
@player143 (879)
• India
20 Feb 08
Dhoni is not the best captain India ever had.He is a good captain and has leadershipping qualities.He supports his team members very well.He is experimenting a lot.His batting average is good after taking captaincy.DHONI matured really well as a batsmen.
@ndraj_2006 (1422)
• India
13 Feb 08
Dhoni is the best captain as of now. - dhoni
dhoni is leading india in good manner. it is very early to predict his captaincy. as of now he is good but, saurav was the all time best captain of india. lets see how dhoni will for years.
@subha12 (18462)
• India
12 Feb 08
I think its too early to say this. in all the mathches dhoni is captain, if india wins in most cases it is contrubution of mainly other players. Some decisions may be good. But i think that is wiith all human beings. some are good some are bad. we can say him best if most are good decisions.
• India
12 Feb 08
YOu are right. Dhoni always try to do some experiment and he never fails in the past. regarding that pathan sending out at no 2 for hitting the run rapidly. If india chased those run early then point benifit comes. Dhoni is not only thinking about winnig, he think about all the possiblitis during the match and try to give his best as captency to the team.
• India
12 Feb 08
YOu are right. Dhoni always try to do some experiment and he never fails in the past. regarding that pathan sending out at no 2 for hitting the run rapidly. If india chased those run early then point benifit comes. Dhoni is not only thinking about winnig, he think about all the possiblitis during the match and try to give his best as captency to the team.