Do you watch Hollyoaks?
July 10, 2008 6:55am CST
Who do you think should keep Tina's baby? Tina or Jacki? I think it should really be Tina because its her only chance to have her own baby! Its not fair she has to give him away to her sister just because of an agreement. I know it wouldnt be fair on her sister as well but she cant ever have her own baby anyway, innit?
7 Aug 08
Yes, I think that Tina should keep him. I always think that with surrogacy there's a chance that the surrogate will not want to give them up, and the couple receiving the baby should always be prepared for this to happen, however difficult this thought is. Also, in Hollyoaks, Tina obviously has feelings for the baby and has bonded with him. That is an extremely strong attachment and it would be cruel of Jackie to make her sister break it. I also think it may have been different if the baby wasn't biologically Tina's. If, for instance, Jackie's egg had been implanted into Tina's womb then she would have more of a claim to him. However, it's Tina's baby, and so in my opinion she has the right to bring him up. Jackie should be sympathetic to Tina's point of view, however upset she is, as they're both in the same position now of not being able to have further children.
20 Oct 08
i completely agree with you in every thing... course by now we already know much more... now, who will keep baby max? Russ, Dom or Jacqui? and how unfair and bad from jacqui to let her mother dye just like that... i cried a lot in friday, call me what you want, but i couldnt stop it!
7 Aug 08
Yes! Obviously The truth will come out... What about Niall situation? Dont you think in real life it would be obvious a few things? Like... Myra or Michaela didnt have a key to the flat... Jonh Paul and Kieron should know only Niall had a key! And they were aware he knew the couple was there at that time! It is annoying me so much now!
5 Aug 08
I think Tina should have kept the baby. I totally agree with you - it would be bad for Jacki and Tony but at the end of the day, Tina carried baby Max and he's her last hope. Tony and Jacki can always adopt as the baby might not even be Tony's anyway!
7 Aug 08
Yeah! Is very selfish from Jacki after what Tina was willing to do for her! And Niall!!??? I love Hollyoaks and i think they always have great subjects but this Niall story... If i were Jonh Paul or Kieron i would ask how Myra or Michaela got the key from the flat??? Only Niall could have given them!!! But he knew the couple were there!!! So??? Hello??? In real life i think anybody would realize it, or not? Niall is really annoying me by doing too many bad things and never get caught!!!