What do you do when you catch someone you believed was your best friend lying?

@alori61 (344)
United States
August 6, 2008 8:08pm CST
Recently I have caught my best friend lying to me more often then telling the truth. They don't know at this point that I know of their lies, as I have not talked to them much the past couple of weeks, but the few times we have spoken, I find most eveything they are saying is not true. The lies are about something very significant and life altering, but I know if I call them on the lies it will be used as a catalist to do something they have sworn not to do. So how do you handle a very close friend that lies to you, when you know why they are doing it, how it will turn out in the near and far future? I might add this is like the third time this situation has occured in two years. It always leads to a break in our friendship but their are a lot of people involved and some are children that will be hurt if I call them on the lies.
4 people like this
22 responses
@n30wing (4767)
• Philippines
7 Aug 08
I think I can't not give them my trust anymore I can be civil and that is all. I can still listen to them maybe but I won't believe them anymore. An apology is I will accept even a thousand lies, but I wont give my full attention. I'll still go but I'll just do it on my own with out them at my side I just don't want trouble. Have a nice day!
1 person likes this
@alori61 (344)
• United States
7 Aug 08
As much as I try I do not trust them no more, I know the routine, and a part of me just wants to end the game. thank you for responding
1 person likes this
@myahw20 (1115)
• Canada
7 Aug 08
I think the situation depends on the lies that your friend made. Personally I would assess the situation carefully. You should remember that sometimes there are situations where we need to make white lies to protect someone or to protect ourselves. Maybe there is a bigger picture than just her lying. If you trusted her for a long time you should give it more consideration/ Hope you guys can fix things. Good luck!
1 person likes this
@alori61 (344)
• United States
7 Aug 08
I can trust this person with my life on everything but this one matter, unfortunately this is a big thing, and it affects many lives. A very huge part of me wants to call them out and just end the situation once and for all, tell them I'm tired of it. Then I think about the big picture and the children and can't do it, if I do not accept their apology then children suffer deeply for it and I can not hurt the child.
1 person likes this
@lilaclady (28207)
• Australia
7 Aug 08
I think you have to weigh up your friendship is it worth causing a friction as I have found out life it way too short for that sort of thing, I think what you can do is maybe just be aware in the future, I think it is better to just not too much faith in anyone these days and just accept them for what they are....unless it is a malicious lie i would just put it aside for awhile....
@alori61 (344)
• United States
7 Aug 08
I do not believe the lies are malicious I think they are more like wishes to be honest. I think they really want what they are saying to be true, but they know they are not. I also think they are meant to spare feelings.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
8 Aug 08
For me, that would be the end of the friendship. I not good taking some kind of betrayal no matter how mild or profound betrayal that is. Once if enough and there will never be a second one.
@alori61 (344)
• United States
8 Aug 08
Depending on the friendship I can be this way also. I had a friend once that betrayed me and my children she never got a second chance. This time it's different, when children are involved I have to consider everyone not just myself, and there are children involved.
@Elixiress (3878)
7 Aug 08
I know that nobody is perfect and that everyone has lied at least once and most people whether they will admit it or not have lied more than once. It all depends what the lie was, if it was something significant then that will probably ruin our relationship, but if it was a little white lie then I would look at it in relation to the big picture and find that it is insignificant.
@alori61 (344)
• United States
8 Aug 08
These lies are ruining our friendship, all I've asked for is honesty in this matter and I continue to get the same lies. I don't know maybe they aren't lies at the time, maybe the intention is there to keep thier word but when push comes to shove it always turns out the same way. If they would just be honest and ask me to give them time to smooth things over I could handle that but they tell me one thing then do another every time.
@Elixiress (3878)
8 Aug 08
Yeah maybe something comes up and your friend does something different to what she said she would do. I would probably ask her why she is lying and she what her answer is, she might have a good reason for it.
@kissie34 (2294)
• Philippines
7 Aug 08
I had experienced before that my best friend had lied to me many times already.. Actually, I just found out accidentally when I asked him a question.. Well, at first I get mad at him but I just try to understand it.. But it seems that my trust to him had somehow lessen.. When everytime he tell something, I don't believe it at all.. I'll just listen to him and accept it then I don't mind whether it is true or not.. Well, I guess when a person had lied to us once or twice and if we found out of course definitely we will lose our trust to that person even he/she is our closest friend or our family..
1 person likes this
@alori61 (344)
• United States
7 Aug 08
It is getting so this friendship does not mean so much to me but there is children involved that will be hurt deeply if the friendship breaks again. I am trying to avoid that. And the fact is I know the situation is being caused by someone else and the friend is caught in the middle but at the same time I'm tired of getting the raw end of the deal.
1 person likes this
@vanities (11395)
• Davao, Philippines
8 Aug 08
its a sad thing actually when you find out about the lies of friends..it did happen to me also..my first initial reaction was dismay and feel cheated..but i dont make a move to confront them...i dont think its necessary ..its useless anyway since from that time on i myself will give some distance on them unknowingly(to them)and not comfortable to be with them anymore..i hate confrontation since i can easily raised my voice and sometimes comments something bad which will hurt my friend...
@alori61 (344)
• United States
8 Aug 08
Yes it is sad to see. Oddly enough what bothers me most isn't the lies as much as the fact that they do not trust me enough to be honest.
7 Aug 08
It is difficult to advise on your situation aas you haven't said what your friend was lying about. I understand that you probably don't want to disclose something private on the internet. I would weigh up your friendship and work out what would happen if you did call her on the lies, and what would happen if you didn't. Whichever scenario is worse is the one you should avoid. I have had friends who lie but usually they are harmless white lies that are to make others or themselves feel better. This I have ignored thinking that there is no point confronting them over something so trivial. Best friends should respect you and not lie to you. I would probably speak to her openly about what I feel, however you said you would not be able to do this with her. I have learned over the years that havin friends who support you, make you happy and are a positive influence on you are the ones you should keep in your life.
@alori61 (344)
• United States
8 Aug 08
I can only say the lies involve children and doing what is right by them. They tell me what they believe I want to hear, maybe with the intention of doing it but never following through. When they fail to follow through people are hurt deeply, especially the children. We used to be so close it's hard to give up on the friendship, especially when I promised to always be there for them no matter how hard things got. I hate breaking a promise, but I can't keep letting them take advantage either.
7 Aug 08
I can relate to you about this subject. It is very disheartening with this happens. I am in the same situation as you. A close friend that is always lying and making things up. The best thing to do is to tell your friend how you feel and that you know they are lying. Most likely they will deny it but you need to get it off your chest. I am about to do this with a close friend but I don't see any other solution. Either the lies stop or the friendship ends. I can't have a friendship that is toxic. It is not worth it. I wish you the best of luck.
@alori61 (344)
• United States
8 Aug 08
Yes I'm feeling this friendship is about to come to an end. I hate hurting the children involved but at the same time I can not continue putting my own sanity on the line. My friend has made thier choises and now it's time for me to make mine. Thank you
@samijo719 (1052)
• United States
7 Aug 08
If they are a best friend or close friend I a gently confront them. Tell them you feel that you haven't been getting the full truth from them and your feeling are hurt because you thought you could count on them. Ask them if there is something going on that is causing them to lie. Just be honest and upfront but dont yell and be harsh.
@alori61 (344)
• United States
8 Aug 08
Well I know in the past any comments on this matter has caused a major arguement, and it's always been turned around on me. I know what is causing the lies and I've basically decided the relationship, and friendship are not worth the stress it causes. I do feel awful for the children though.
@glorybel (42)
• Philippines
7 Aug 08
In my part I'll get hurt when I found that she lied to me. Because I trust her and do believe her and we always been together in the past years. But lying is the sin that I can't forgive. But everything has reasons maybe I'll listen to her why she did it to me. I'll try to understand her and forgive her for the sake of our friendship. Well, anyways we didn't encounter that kind of problems and are friendship getting stronger year after year after year.
@alori61 (344)
• United States
7 Aug 08
I guess what I'm trying to decide is if our friendship is strong enough to withstand another episode of this. This person is very near and dear and it is someone else that is causing the interference but at the same time my friend is allowing it, so I guess I'm feeling they do not value the friendship as much as I do.
• United States
7 Aug 08
I dont do anything because well its not worth the stress and just shows me how she reallly is deep down and not take her all that serious
@alori61 (344)
• United States
8 Aug 08
Unfortunately you are wrong, I don't take freindship lightly. There are very few people in this world that I call friend, and I don't give up on them easily when I do. It's the way I am, this person was very near and dear to me at one time, I can't turn my back if it doesn't feel right, there is alot involved in this situation.
@cecelgay (563)
• Philippines
8 Aug 08
This is a third time? The first question there is is there anything or someone that she is protecting why she doing that? if none how worth is your friendship to be save? On my own definition best friend is someone who'll protect you and guide you, when you're down she's the first one who'll be there to lift you up, if your in trouble she'll be there to support you, if you're making a wrong decission she's the first one who'll object, that is a true best friend. In your case i may say she's the one who bring you in trouble, "one is enough two is too much" Maybe you should talk to her face to face and ask her frankly what she's up to or after why she did it to you, maybe there is a deep reason why she did it even she's your best friend. Everything will be fine if you'll be true to each other.
@alori61 (344)
• United States
8 Aug 08
There are reasons for the deseption, there are reasons why I have allowed it, and there are reasons for me to stop allowing it but there are also reasons to allow it to continue. I realize my friend is not being a good friend right now, but I also know they have the capacity to be a good friend, and what kind of friend am I if I turn my back on a long time friendship because this person is going through an extremely bad time right now? This is just a part of what I think about now that the lies have begun again. I have stuggled with this for days now, I know what my mind says and what my heart says, I look in the eyes of the children being hurt by this and my resolve melts, if it was just me and my friend this would be easier but its not.
• United States
7 Aug 08
Well if she's truly your best friend then you should be able to ask her about these lies and tell her that you would like and deserve explaination for her actions. If she can't give you that and continues the deciet then end the friendship because a best friend doesn't do this to you.
@alori61 (344)
• United States
8 Aug 08
Any questions or confrontations or comments on how the lies effect me always bring the same results. They blow up saying they can't take any more stress, give them a break they're doing the best they can, I don't understand what they are going through. This is round three, it always ends up the same, they always come back, apologize for thier behavior, and it starts the circle again. I know I have to put and end to it, it's just hard to forget the way it used to be when we were really friends.
@subha12 (18441)
• India
7 Aug 08
it is one of the most difficult suituation i faced in life. Believe me my world came crashing when the so called best friend cheated me. he was telling lies for few days. that i could understand. but never could understand he can be so eman and play friendship just he wanted to take advantage of my real friendship.
@alori61 (344)
• United States
7 Aug 08
Yes the last time my friend offered to end our friendship to please this other person. When they forced a blow up I called them on it and they never did admitt what they did. Of course a little over a month later they were back and apologizing and I again forgave them, but now 6 months later we're back where we were then. I guess I'm trying to decide if I should just cut all ties this time, I just hate hurting the other people involved in this situation.
@izathewzia (5134)
• Philippines
7 Aug 08
I will surely feel hurt. I will confront my best friend regarding it. Since we never hide secrets eversince. i will asks her why she lied to me. If there is a problem that pushed her to do so. i know my bestfriend so well. If nothing will trigger her, she will not lie to me.
@alori61 (344)
• United States
7 Aug 08
My problem remains that I'm not sure that the person is intentionally lying. I suspect this person is attempting to keep please two people with opposing views and really wishes it could be both ways. It's just they always give into the other person. In the past I've always accepted thier apology and gone on but I'm thinking it's a waiste of my time, three times it's becoming a pattern and I just don't know if I want to keep dealing with it. I was hoping to avoid another confrontation and subsequent split, but I don't think that's going to happen.
@Mamagee (392)
• Malaysia
7 Aug 08
I would't trust her/him anymore. I only can hear but ignore it. I have to tell him/her the truth that she/he is lying and I know that for along time. I will advise him/her not to do it anymore because it will hurt many people and losen frienship with many friends. It is better for him/her not to talk too much about other people.
@alori61 (344)
• United States
7 Aug 08
Thank you your words have given me an idea of how I can put it to them.
@sumiirajj (1983)
• India
7 Aug 08
I would talk to them directly and ask the reason for their behaviour.I would also tell her the consequences in future.
@alori61 (344)
• United States
7 Aug 08
I think this is a good idea, something non confrontational, so they know I am aware of the situation and give them a choise to stop lying or just end the enire freindship.
@IInsanity (290)
• Malaysia
7 Aug 08
i've caught friends who lied to me on serious matters and the friendships never stays the same anymore.. i have no advice for you, but wish u luck =)
@alori61 (344)
• United States
7 Aug 08
Thank you. Your right about it not staying the same the trust is never there again. Oddly enough this person can't understand why I don't have faith in their word any longer.
• Philippines
7 Aug 08
Your best friend lying to you? If i were you, i wouldn't consider her/him a friend. Its very alarming that all of these years, both of you are sharing each own life secrets and all the while you have given them your trust. I think the best way is to gradually stay out of his/her sight and life. Its unhealthy and not worthy relationship to keep.
@alori61 (344)
• United States
7 Aug 08
I think that is the reason I have so much trouble with this entire situation we were the closest of close until they got married and thier spouse is the reason for the lies and the problems. The spouse hates me, has made a huge issue of ending the friendship, but my friend has fought as hard as I to remain friends, so if a part of me says it's easier on everyone to let it go, but we have been so close its not easier, I'm not one that gives up easy.