are we doing justice?

@magna86 (1787)
India
September 6, 2008 12:56am CST
well i am talking about giving the best response for a discussion!! are we doing justice!! i see some people receiving best responses even if their answer is not upto the mark!, and more over the same people receive it again and again! in my opinion i don feel thats right!!! when i choose my best response i keep in mind that i should give it to a person who tried his best responding to my discussion and it should be a person who has not received a best response!! in this way i feel that , the newbee, and other mylotters would be encouraged still more,, to respond to discussions and get the best response!! this is my view!!! feel free to share your opinion!
1 person likes this
2 responses
@salonga (27985)
• Philippines
6 Sep 08
What is right for you may not be right for others. If that is how you think you should grant best response then so be it. You are entitled to that. As for me, I don't consider whether my respondent is newbie or not. What is important is the content of the response. If he deserves on the basis of the substance of his post then he gets it. And even if he gets it a hundred times or even more from the rest of my discussions I will still give it to him if he really deserves. It is not the status here that I look into. It's not even if you are a friend or not, it's the substance, the usefulness and the quality of the response that matter to me when granting the best response. Well if two or three have given same ideas in their response which I consider best, my way to solve this is to give to the first one among the three who answered my discussion. I don't really consider whether he is a newbie or not. This way... I am sure that I did not make the mistake of giving best response to the person who could have possibly copied the ideas of the first respondent. Although this is not always true, at least I am safely giving it to the first and the original. Well each one has his own way of deciding how to give his best response. We can't really influence each other here. What is best for you may not be best for the other users. This issue is subjective so I believe we just have to give each other the freedom to do our own judgmet.
• United States
2 Oct 08
I agree completely, salonga, and that's how I'd do it too.
@vidhyavini (6112)
• India
6 Sep 08
I will give best response to the one who gives response that satisfies me. I don't see whether the person have already received any best responses or not. If all the responses are the same and if nothing is up to my expectation, I will give preferences to my friends. I don't think that its wrong. Ya I do understand that it will encouraging the newbies. But I hate to give best response if its just a single line from them.
@magna86 (1787)
• India
6 Sep 08
hmm i agree with you dear!! but i would prefer to give it to a person who has not received it !! and who has tried the best answering my discussions!