Circumcision

United States
November 13, 2006 10:23pm CST
What do you think about male circumcision? Do you think it is becoming less popular now? Is it medically necessary or a social stamina? What are your thoughts?
5 responses
• Canada
14 Nov 06
I understand that circumcision is a religious practice as well as a cultural one, but I don't agree with it, and rarely is it medically necessary. If I ever had to have it done to a child, I would absolutely insist that anaesthetic be used, and even then, I would only allow it to be performed if it were indeed medically necessary. I've never understood why people would simply allow that to happen to a child because it's "what people do". It might be traditional or a cultural norm, but so are many other practices that shouldn't be allowed by law.
• United States
15 Nov 06
Just recently did they start using local anesthetics for newborn circumcision. Also, I heard that somehow the child remembers it subconsciously later on in life.
@lilaclady (28207)
• Australia
14 Nov 06
I am glad I have never had to make this decision, it must be very hard, I can see both sides of the argument....I feel for any one in that position...
@Jshean20 (14349)
• Canada
14 Nov 06
It depends on the doctor you ask...some say it should be done and others say not. My nephew was not circumsized and he's had a couple of bladder infections which doctors suspect could've been because he wasn't circumsized, however he hasn't had an infection for awhile now and he's fine.
• United States
15 Nov 06
I have found that doctors are biased when it comes to circumcision. You have those that are strongly for it and those that are strongly against it. Its best to get information from someone who gives the pros and cons of both.
@oresal (1350)
• El Salvador
15 Nov 06
Im not circumcised, and i actually think that this is a brutal act when done on newborn kids. Nevermind if this is some religion or cultural tradition, if i had a kid, i would only look for circumcition if there is really a necesity to have that done. its not necessary to be circumcised if you keep clean, plus i think it would be uncormftable to be circumcised. im 21 and never had any disease
@ladygator (3465)
• United States
15 Nov 06
I have 2 boys and we got them circ right after birth. I hated it, but my husband is circ, and I thought for our family thats what needed to be done, Plus I didnt want to do it later when they were older
• United States
15 Nov 06
Many of my patients do it to please the husband and I guess its nothing wrong with standing by your man.