Is it right that Britain get the blame?

@oldchem1 (8132)
June 17, 2010 3:43am CST
I am referring of course to the oil spill in the gulf of Mexico. I find it rather ironic that the US is the largest polluter in the world and didn't contribute very much to the 2009 climate change summit in Copenhagen. Now the Americans are busy blaming the British as they themselves have completely failed in stopping the leak, Obama has never even mentioned that it was American companies that were actually operating this rig, under contract to BP. I am not saying BP is an innocent party, obviously they are not, but to blame Britain seems to me to be wrong.
2 people like this
11 responses
@rosie230 (1696)
17 Jun 10
I think it is always easier for other countries to blame the UK, and I think half the reason for this is because we do seem to do a lot more to stop these things than other countries. It is not really the way to go, since they should of course admit to their mistake and acknowledge their responsibility, but once they stop knowing what to do, they give up and pass the buck to someone like us, who naturally end up sorting the problem. That's just a personal view though, it just seems to be that way in my eyes.
1 person likes this
@allknowing (130064)
• India
17 Jun 10
I have been reading about this and no where have I seen any mention being made of blame being passed on to the British but surely BP is being quoted as being responsible and they are in the process of getting ready with a compensation package.
@mentalward (14691)
• United States
17 Jun 10
Oldchem, don't listen to our press or politicians... we don't.
1 person likes this
@oldchem1 (8132)
17 Jun 10
It is widely reported her that US press and politicians are laying the blame with the UK; the following passage is just a little from an article on http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1284125/Stop-blaming-UK-BP-oil-spill-disaster-Cable-hits-America.html [i]"American politicians and broadcasters have laid the blame for the accident on the Deepwater Horizon rig at the feet of the UK - despite BP being a multinational company. Mr Obama has continually referred to the company as 'British Petroleum' although it changed its name to BP more than a decade ago."[/i] Read more: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1284125/Stop-blaming-UK-BP-oil-spill-disaster-Cable-hits-America.html#ixzz0r6rJhaoS
@oldchem1 (8132)
17 Jun 10
Same here really!!
@cjgrooms (4456)
• United States
17 Jun 10
British people have no more blame in this than American citizens have in the idiocy our companies (and goverment ) comes up with. Not wanting to be to blunt and ticking anyone off but i believe this disater can be laid at the feet of GREED and STUPIDITY which all of those that run large companies (and goverments) seem to suffer from and no this condition is not monoplized by ANY one country but seems to be universial.
@cjgrooms (4456)
• United States
17 Jun 10
Thank You. Maybe you can explain to me why when someone gets in a position of authority they lose all common sense. Yes, this is one of my pet peeves and it drives me crazy just thinking about it. They seem to be perfectly rational people with as much sense as the rest of us but the min. they are put in charge of a company or in a goverment position they seem to lose any common sense God blessed them with. Does anyone understand this phenomenon?
@oldchem1 (8132)
17 Jun 10
Well said madam!! Exactly the point
1 person likes this
@Maggiepie (7816)
• United States
18 Jun 10
There were faults on both sides, but I take issue with your bogus, PC claim that we pollute more than anyone else in the world! On the contrary, we have boo-coos of rules & regulations to prevent pollution, whereas there are many countries which lack the technology (&/or the will) to prevent it or clean it up. A prime example of this was exposed when Germany's Wall fell, & the world saw what the Communists had done to the environment with their careless & unbridled ransacking of East Germany's resources to produce arms. Whole forests killed, leaving blackened trunks of trees consumed by strip mining & acid rain. Or take certain parts of India & Africa, too poor to afford the technology to purify their water, & the governments in Africa, especially, too corrupt to rescue their land from over-farming, & thus 100s of thousands of drought-stricken, starving, diseased & dying, dispirited people, whose help from the most generous & charitable people in the world--US--saw their food stolen & given to rich, evil rulers. Do NOT try to plop that PC crap here about us being horrible polluters. We know better! And as for "climate change," please. That fraud has been exposed. No such thing as MAN-MADE climate change! Oh, & I'm not blaming Britain, just our so-called president & BP. Maggiepie Life is hard; it’s harder if you’re stupid. ~ John Wayne
@oldchem1 (8132)
18 Jun 10
Top Five of World Table for CO2 emissions 1 China 6,103,493 per capita 4.62 2 United States 5,752,289 per capita 18.69 3 Russia 1,564,669 per capita 10.92 4 India 1,510,351 per capita 1.31 5 Japan 1,293,409 per capita 10.11
1 person likes this
@1anurag1 (3576)
• India
18 Jun 10
I think the biggest problem with the US is that they think themselves as perfect. Even they want to impose laws and rules on other countries but don’t want to be bound by them. I am not against USA but I am against their policies. Whether those are related to terrorism or Nuclear power. They can attack on any country saying that they are not good but if we do what will they say. I think some time they think even above themselves than the other international organisations. I think US can be a good role of a leader but not they are getting unpopular due to these habits.
17 Jun 10
I agree with you totally. Infact to be blunt I am getting quite annoyed with some people who are soemhow coming to the conclusion that Britian is to balme for something which is happening in the Gulf of Mexico. I am so tired of people trying to pass the blame onto this person and the other when the fault lies with BP and it's workers who were managing and controling the rig. BP is a british registered company and that's as far as it goes for me. BP are the ones who are responsible for it's equipment and the clean up operation. I was wathcing Sky news this morning and I can quote one American lady who said she was wondering where the Queen of England was!!! I mean what can she do about it? The only people who can stop this is BP, so why is the buck getting passed to the UK?
@oldchem1 (8132)
17 Jun 10
Perhaps her Majesty is donning her hard hat and overalls and is flyng over with a BIG spanner!!!!!! I see this morning that BP are starting a fund for people affected and have stopped all staff bonuses.
• Pamplona, Spain
17 Jun 10
Hiya chem, I can just see the Queen now getting ready and making haste preparing for that arduous task ahead of her (grin). You are right what on earth has the Queen got to do with it? I am pretty sure that others will remember what happened on a certain Coast of Spain a few years back and the Mess is still there too except that it´s now been brushed and shushed up under that political Carpet of theirs. They had their Hard Hats on too and their overalls and more than anything they were just Politicians doing and saying silly things about the Oil that was clogging up even the Buildings that were near to the Seafronts. The Oil got onto Buildings that were quite near the City Centre as well that´s how bad it was. On a lighter note will Charles be going with her or will she going on her own? Just kidding gal. They should not blame the UK itself for what has happened. Another big disaster was caused by a certain Country over here in Spain and nothing was ever done about that either. It was caused by industrial oil though but to me it´s the same thing.
@oldchem1 (8132)
18 Jun 10
Charles and the two princes are going to be her labourers!!
@urbandekay (18278)
17 Jun 10
No, Britain is not to blame because global corporation like BP are not really a business of a particular country but international. BP however is responsible and should be made to compensate all legitimate claims, they should, however, be allowed to take action against their subcontractors to reclaim some of that money, where those subcontractors are responsible for some of the problem all the best urban
@oldchem1 (8132)
17 Jun 10
Exactly they are a multinational company, that happen to be BASED in Britain.
@mentalward (14691)
• United States
17 Jun 10
Well, I, personally, am not blaming Britain. I just wanted that on record. Most of the U.S. citizens have extremely differing opinions from those in charge of our government. I blame no country. It is entirely those in charge at BP itself, no matter where they live in the world. I honestly think that placing blame is really stupid. The facts are the facts and they are that there is a massive oil leak that is not being contained. BP is entirely responsible for this and I'm happy to hear that they are not only claiming blame but also promised financial reparation to everyone affected by this. As far as I'm concerned, BP could be owned by anyone, anywhere in the world, and the situation would be the same so placing blame is a total waste of time and energy. I do not see this as a problem in the U.S. I see this as a global problem. Actually, "problem" seems a bit lame in light of the astronomical affects of this incident. (I even hesitated to call this an "incident".) Yes, those who live in the affected area are being hurt the worst but it still is not just those who are affected. I believe we should come together on this and find a solution instead of placing blame, which does nothing but create bad feelings. So, don't take it so seriously, those placing blame, that is. Just know that noone that I know of, personally, have been blaming Britain; we are extremely upset with BP, the corporation.
@oldchem1 (8132)
17 Jun 10
You are right, this is far more than a problem!! This is going to have a huge impact world wide
@picjim (3002)
• India
17 Jun 10
Regarding this discussion i'd like you and all our fellow mylotters to read an article in the Newsweek available on the net a couple of weeks back.The article gave a detailed account of oil spills and disasters all over the world.It seemed to imply that most oil companies have at one time or the other been involved in some mishap in some part of the world at one time or another.I'm not condoning British Petroleum but the record of most oil companies has not been that good.I think this particular disaster should be a fillip to enact new laws to safeguard environment in the U.S and world over.
@oldchem1 (8132)
17 Jun 10
Excellent point, but will the powers to be learn from these disasters? I doubt it!
@xasasa (321)
• United States
17 Jun 10
I am very angry with both BP and the US government. I do not blame Britain at all. BP is a company, even though I think of British Petroleum when I see BP, it does not cause me to blame the country. Actually if I remember right BP has a lot of American shareholders.
@oldchem1 (8132)
18 Jun 10
Yes it does Britain has 40% US has 39% !
@Riesu77 (16)
• United States
17 Jun 10
I think the procedure is it doesn't matter who's operating it or not but who's in charge of that rig and who ever owns it has to take responsibility for their equipment. at least that how i think it works, plus i think people are bashing on obama too much. In a lot of ways he is better than bush, I can't even think of one thing bush did for us in his whole 8 years.