Muslims in India are not ready to sing national song?
By amiksinha
@amiksinha (1960)
India
September 1, 2006 8:56am CST
Excerpts from one of my friend discussion: Where ever muslims go, they are not loyal to their motherland as long as that nation is not an Islamic nation. If the fact that they celebrate when Pakistan wins in Cricket match, the fact that they dont want to sing national song of India saying there is no place for it in Islam even though they want there place in india.. Why does government arrest all the muslims who oppose the national song as terrorist. They are social terrorist,. Help develop anti national sentiments.
21 responses
@shi_2000_21 (2680)
• India
30 Sep 06
I agree with you. 90% of Muslim are not loyal to their motherland. They have more respect to allah then to their motherland.
@chocklitchip (472)
• Pakistan
17 Dec 06
hey wat do u mean by comparing ALLAH to motherland? its two totally diifrent issues...don compare religion to nation...v respect our ALLAH as much as u respect ur gods...v never compare any...im a muslim n pakistani...half of my closest relatives belong to india...when ever they visit us they miss their homeland alot n ya they never wana hear anything agaisnt it...n same is the case wth us...listen u can never hate the place where u live or r born at....i have been working wth couple of ppl who r hindus but they belong to pakistan...they r pakistanis n favor pakistan in any case...shd they b supporting india as they r hindus?? no man they love their place of living...evry religion spreads a msg of love n peace...i hav got very good relations wth my collegues n majority r christians so shd i tell them to find a country where they can practice their religion? ya most among them r frm various religions n don like singing our pakistani national song but v neva force em or criticise,...but tht doesnt mean they hate their motherland...so peace.
@sj_chaudhry (1537)
• Canada
9 Jan 07
i agree with you chocolate chip... you give a very compact but good reply. Religion and motherland are 2 totally different things.
@dulheraja (436)
• United States
30 Sep 06
off course men. wat u think? we love ALLAH more than anything, more than our lives so wat is the country?country is nothing comparing to religion.
Even u tell me Who comes firs in your mind? offcourse your GOD not country.
Well I am Indian and Muslim. I think I love my country a lot than HINDU People. And I am proud to be an Indian. There is loads og people celebrates in my town when INDIA wins in cricket and offering free foods like ice cream, candies and fruits.
What u think, U guys are only Indian? I am INDIAN and proud to b an Indian.
According to ISLAM we must love our nation.
Koi maay kaa laal esa nahi he jo muje India se nikaale , aur na koi paida hoga.
@zotopec (307)
• Pakistan
9 Jan 07
Yeah, you are right amik. I think not only Muslims in India but Christians in India, Sikhs in India are not performing their duties toward their country and government. All these minorities should be arrested at once, no matter what the charge. Hindu Indians have been quite good to minorities, since India has long declared itself a secular state, burning churches, destroying Sikh Temples, and Muslim mosques. And yes, they are all social terrorists, a constant terror to hindus, threatening them their own part of civil rights, which I believe exist at random in india. Well, I believe Sikhs are more happier than Indian Moslems when Pakistan wins a match, Christians are angrier when any injustice is done to any min
@vampirestonez (1181)
• Pakistan
9 Jan 07
Well all I can say about reading your post is that you are one racist person that doesn't know the meaning of terrorists or Islam. you are most certainly an arrogant and an ignorant person that is heavily influenced by its own surroundings and about the national anthem doesn't it contain something religious to Hindus that is not acceptable with muslims? I think this issue had sparked a controversial debate before and no muslim would sing a religious song of your country and what has celebrating the match of pakistan has to do with this? Its not even relevant to the topic. Sports and religion are two different things and I don't think I have ever pakis say Jai Ram when the cricket team plays good. Well you have given your perspective from your side but how about if you think from both the sides? THINK about it my friend.
@killailla (1301)
• Canada
6 Jan 07
Why would they sing a song worshipping the place they live, you do not do that, there is only one person to worship, that is Allah
@Naseem00 (1996)
• Pakistan
8 Jan 07
Let us first of all look at what the Indian National song is.
It starts with the words 'banday matram....' (meaning: mother (india land), we are your servants)
Muslims believe in one God, Allah. And their faith does not allow them to serve anybody else than one God. Hindus do not mind worshiping monkeys, cows, trees, fire, stones and lot of other things. This is why they are not able to understand why do muslims refuse to sing such a song. It is not a sign that they are not committed to their country. It is just against their beliefs. I hope the Indian government will understand this and not force anybody to sing something against their beliefs.
@kirankurkimath1 (385)
• India
21 Nov 06
as some one above mentioned all muslims are not like that.. i personely have many muslim friends they are very loyal to their god and to their people.. but when it comes to us we are a matter of nothing... i agree that some of the muslim in india have soft corner towords islamic countries. thats quite common.. dont we have towords our community. just like that... when you are in the country shoud consider it priority.. not the god.. believe in god thats good not to the extent where you forgetour motherland.so who ever is not oyal plz shif your attention to grow...
@utsadetti (4589)
• United States
30 Dec 06
it's okay lol. it's not a big matter for that. moslem also should be moderate and tolerate to the song.
@Ahtaysham (30)
• India
30 Dec 06
I am not agree with u that muslims are social terriost U people unneccessary makin it a big issue among muslim this is not the question of a debate the total moatter is politisised by the people like you before telling a musilm a terroist lok what is happing in India where terrisom is at the peak and no muslim is involved,Ranbir sena Gujraat mizoram punjab and naxelite in andhra
and National anthem is compulsory not vande materm any way I can recite vane ma taram better than u pl learn it first I am sure that u can not recite it
@love_maniac90 (1237)
• India
21 Nov 06
i agree.the muslims are the most unfaithful religion in this world.
@dodododo3 (375)
• India
21 Nov 06
i agree with u...they should be punished .they are really the social criminal.it seems like they do not salute their mother since she is a mortal being....hope less
@valmiki9 (1171)
• India
19 Nov 06
There are certin elements in Muslim community in India which indulge in anti national activities.They do it for financial gain given by countries against india. it for the muslim Majority to come out and protest but they do not do it which makes the whole community responsible
