Buying vs Renting a home!

United States
October 13, 2010 6:00pm CST
My fiance and I currently live in an apartment and are considering buying a house. With the economy right now, I have heard now is the best time to buy a house. We have already talked to a mortage lender and he says we should make enough to buy a house in the range of 100,000 to 140,000 and it would should keep our mortgage around the same as what we are paying in rent. Now we have already decided we want out of the apartment. We have two kids and a couple of dogs and its gotten too much living in an apartment. The kids and dogs have no yard of thier own. So we definitly know we want to get into a house. We are just unsure as to whether we should buy a house or rent a house. My mom says we should rent because if anything breaks we don't have to worry about the repairs to fix it. Which is a good point, but I look at it from a different angle. Why would I pay rent for a house that will never be mine. It's pretty much throwing the money away when I could be paying a mortgage for something that will be mine. So I need some help. If anyone could shed some light on this subject I would greatly appreciate it. Please give me some pros and cons to buying vs renting a home.
4 responses
@puccagirl (7294)
• Israel
14 Oct 10
I see that someone listed some pros and cons already, and I think that was a really good post, so I have nothing to add there really. But I have to say that I would definitely buy a house. It can go up in value a lot too, so if you sell it eventually, you can even make some money off it (even if you did not finish paying the mortgage!).
1 person likes this
• United States
14 Oct 10
Yes, the first person did list a lot of pros and cons. But you do have a good pro for buying a house. Never thought about the fact that if the economy turns around, the value of a home is likely to go up and could make a profit off of it. Thanks so much for your input.
• United States
17 Oct 10
Coffeebreak, thanks for the detailed input on how property values work. This was very insightful and will definitly keep this in mind when making our decision.
@coffeebreak (17798)
• United States
16 Oct 10
Property values is part of the cause of the recession. First it was the inappropriate loans made, but then when things crashed with the foreclosures...that made property values decline very badly..so you couldn't refinance cause the value of the property is not what you initially had thereby you owe more than it was worth. If your property value was $800,000 and your mortgage was for $700,000 you were okay, but then PV's declined drastically once foreclosures and repos started hitting the areas and that made the value of the house now only $400,000.. yet you owe $more than that.. so you couldn't refi and therefore, foreclosed. When an appraisal and property values are determined, they scan the area for its ammenities. What the property is close to for the good and for the bad. If your property is surrounded by other foreclosures and repos etc...that drives value down. However if you buy now while property values are low...they will come up...maybe not to this hiatis they were at in the 90's but lot higher than they are now and you will make equity/property value. THings start looking better in the area and values will start going up. Buy one now for $200,000 and PV's go up and even just at $300,000 - you'll have $100k in equity and that is great "value" for your property. Then sell and you've already made $1k in profit!
1 person likes this
@angelic123 (1108)
• United States
13 Oct 10
Buying: Pros:"1. You will own the house. 2. You can do anything in your house, there are no nosy neighbors downstairs or upstairs. 3. The kids can play in your backyard, so as your dog. 4. You can have a property that you will call your own. cons: 1. You pay taxes for the house. 2. You also have to pay for the insurance. 3. You need to save money for possible repairs. 4. You will pay all your bills like water, PG&E, Telephone, Cable etc. 5. If you want to transfer location because your neighborhood is not good, you have to sell or rent the house which is too difficult at this economic condition. 6. If the house and lot you bought is small there will be no room for expansion. 7. You do not have too many chooses with the range you have.
1 person likes this
• United States
13 Oct 10
Renting: Pros: 1. You can choose the size and location of your apartment. 2. You can move out easily and choose another place to stay if you finished the contract/lease agreement. Cons. Sometimes the leaser raises the rental without notice. or they will even asked you to moved out with a shorter advisory. If you love to plant there is no place to plant or to have a garden. Though I list many cons on both choices I would love to have a house of my own. It gives you pleasure to know that despite the crisis , the joblessness, and poverty still you own something and that something will be the place where you will raise your kids. A place where you will build your dreams and make that dreams come true. So good luck. Either you buy or rent, I hope you will be happy and satisfied with your decision.
1 person likes this
• United States
14 Oct 10
Thank you so much for your very thought out list. You have listed some very good points. Especially for the cons with buying a house. Luckily some of those are ones that aren't too bad for me to live with. Like having to pay taxes and insurance. With us being first time home buyers (I know I forgot to mention that in my original post, LOL!) the taxes and insurance will be included in our mortgage payment. Also, if we start looking we plan on taking in the house size, lot size, and neighborhood into big consideration. Someone said to go to the neighbors houses before you buy and ask them what they think of the neighborhood. Which I think is a very good idea.
@coffeebreak (17798)
• United States
16 Oct 10
THere's all kinds of pros and cons for both sides. I rented houses for years and it was a nightmare to get the landlord to do any repairs on their own homes. Even serious repairs. And then when they would do them, they'd raise the rent the next year. And if you move out, they used the security deposit to make those repairs that were their responsibility. Plus you have to usually be the one to take care of the landscape.. the expense of the water...maintanence and care of it, but you aren't allowed to "do" anything to it the way you'd like. That water bill got rather high to water that grass all the time. We even had to do weed control. So if you buy, you have to do all that, but it is to your own home, not someone elses. however, you also have to pay things like homeowners insurance and property taxes on your own home where you don't (exactly) on a rental. Granted it is probably to a point included in the rent but it is something you yourself don't have to save and pay each year. I'd rather buy than rent, just can't keep the income up right to qualify.
1 person likes this
• United States
17 Oct 10
Well I have never rented a house, so I have never had to experience those situations. But we live in an apartment where they are really good at fixing things right away and the rent seems to stay the same. But those are very good points to keep in mind with renting a house from a private landlord. I am starting to think we are better off buying a house. Thanks so much for sharing!
@cyrri_ako (461)
• Philippines
14 Oct 10
i would rather buy one. since you dont have kids yet, it would be easier for you. it's an investment. well, money may be an issue but there would be options available like government funded housing. you have an option to pay in 5, 10 or 15..even 30 years. it's different if you can actually call it "my house/our house".
1 person likes this
• United States
14 Oct 10
Actually I do have kids which was stated in my original post. But I thank you for your feed back and the good points you have on buying a house. Still not sure if we will buy or rent, but I can't wait until the day that I do finally buy my first house and call it home.