Shocking American Idol elimination
By zukichucha
@zukichucha (991)
United States
March 18, 2011 12:15am CST
I was so surprised Karen went home tonight tears came to my eyes. She is amazingly talented. There are at least 5-6 other contestants that she is so much better than. I thought she was going to go alot further than she did. As a whole I am starting to get disgusted with this season. I don't think the talent is where it should be. I also think the judges are being way too nice! I AM GETTING IRRITATED!
3 responses
@jessa311 (15)
•
26 Mar 11
I think Karen is very talented, however so are the other contestants. Its all about the voting, people dont vote and the contestant wont stay. However this week was a shocker to me. The idol judges used their save on Casey! I like casey it just suprised me that they used the save so early in the competition! My fav.s are Lauren, scotty, and hailey. All three of them have a very long career in front of them!!
@zukichucha (991)
• United States
28 Mar 11
I was shocked to here they used the save on Casey too! Now 2 people will be going home this week. I hope it was worth it. We will have to wait and see. I think they should use the save on someone that they feel will make it to the finale. I don't love Casey but I don't see him going that far.
@dknkyle (446)
• Singapore
18 Mar 11
Well, the sad thing is that shocking elimination always happens in American Idol. So I am not surprise that it happens again this season, because there will be more then one every season. But now the good thing is that there is the judge's save and I really hope that judges would use it wisely this season and not waste it to save someone worthless and spoil the whole show.
@zukichucha (991)
• United States
18 Mar 11
I really wanted them to use the save last night but of course it is too early to use it. That would mean 2 people go home next week. If Pia was up there singing for her life they definitely would have used it. But I doubt that is going to happen. She is awesome and I hope she wins!
@jfranco1124 (13)
• United States
18 Mar 11
This elimination really suprised me because she was definately one of the better contestants in my opinion. Ashton last week was a good elimination, but this shocked me. Yeah, there are a lot of good singers this year, but Karen did not deserve to be voted off this early in the competition.
@zukichucha (991)
• United States
18 Mar 11
I thought Haley was going to go home. She definitely deserved to! I can barely understand her when she sings. If this is a singing competition they should at least have singers who sing coherently. She sounds like she has a good buzz before she goes on stage.
