Scotty bagged the 1st place in American Idol!

For me, I would definately say YES. Even though Lauren is good, I just think she has a long ways to go to be a Big star. Scotty brang it to the table all the time, and knows how to perform for audiences. He is truly destined to be a Star, and I cannot wait for his first CD. I do wish the Best for him and know he will go far.

It's a matter of how many votes they received. Either one could have won, but Scotty had more votes. They will both be a success in my opinion. I wish them both well and hope they can stay grounded and not let success go to their head.