If A Friend Ask You If She's Beautiful, Will you Say Yes, Even if She's Not?

Davao, Philippines
January 4, 2012 9:00am CST
I have been through such difficult situation not only once...There are really times when your friend, usually a woman, will just suddenly ask you if she's beautiful...Good if she's really beautiful, but if not...it's really hard to be frank at times. Like this friend of mine, who can not hold on to long relationships. I knew that she is the one who makes first move in attracting guys. Because, she has stable job, there are guys who would just 'respect' her advancements...and she really runs after good looking guys...But it seems no guy will take her seriously. She has me asked several times, if she is beautiful...and why these men left her for younger and beautiful women...And several times, I lied..afraid to hurt her feelings. It might be, in so doing I'm boosting her morale and her ego. Yeah, I told her, she's beautiful even if she's far from being one...not even her character.
3 people like this
15 responses
@SIMPLYD (90722)
• Philippines
5 Jan 12
I am honest with all my friends. That's because i care for them and don't want them to be wayward later on by doing some things immoral. But i have never encountered any friend who asks me if she's beautiful. Maybe because they know that i am a frank person and i would say what i have to say, though i always do it in a loving way.
@enelym001 (8322)
• Philippines
5 Jan 12
So you'd really her a friend that she's ugly if one will ask you I can never do that... or maybe a nice term to use which would meant the word ugly will do...
@carmelanirel (20942)
• United States
4 Jan 12
I don't think she'd be much of a friend to ask you this, because I do believe that beauty is in the eye of the the beholder, it can't be measured by everyone's standards. For example, some people thing Leonardo DiCaprio is handsome, my daughter does not. Does that mean he is handsome or not? No, it means that some find him attractive and others do not. It's an opinion, not a fact..
• Davao, Philippines
5 Jan 12
carmelanirel, you're right that beauty is in the eye of the beholder. I too believe that. But this friend of mine failed to analyze her true self because of her pride and egoistic and selfish nature...so hard to tell her something she must do to improve herself. She's so superior, even among her so-called friends. There's hardness or roughness in her character which she exudes well in her arrogant ways, all reflected in her grim and loveless facial expression. If based on physical outward standard, she's not an attention getter. I think I'm just one of the few friends left for her, if not the only one...and I'm sure it's because I told her, she's beautiful when she asked me about it...
1 person likes this
• United States
5 Jan 12
You know, I guess some people live for lies if it makes them feel better..But there is a quote going around on FB that I totally took on for myself. It is, "Hurt me with the truth, don't make me feel good with lies" That is how I feel and perhaps next time, you can use that quote on your friend, see if she rather you lie or tell her the truth..I understand you not wanting to hurt her feelings, but truth does hurt, but it also builds up if one takes the truth and allow it to change them..
@airasheila (5454)
• Philippines
4 Jan 12
good day mercedes2053, it is quite hard to say the truth in real life. however there is a saying goes, the truth will set you free. and if i will be in your shoe, i will try to say it slowly and rephrase the words into more refine one. so my friend will not hurt directly to the words that she will going to hear from me. and at the end of it, i will really do a thorough effort in explaining that she is my friend and i want to be really really honest to her. as i have said, i will rephrase the words and will choose the best ones to prevent her to feel the hurt. although on the other side, she might feel hurted but it is somehow normal and understandable. but, what matters most is, i have told her the truth so she can change and improved for the better. that situation really needed sometimes for us to improve ourselves. thus, we should open our minds to accept criticism. it just only depends on how to deal with those.
• Davao, Philippines
5 Jan 12
Yeah,"The truth will set you free..." that's true...and that applies to the one who has to accept the truth though how much it hurts. Or in some cases, to the person who is holding the truth that she or he needs to divulge. Your comment, which is also an advice...really made me think...what if I didn't give in to what she wanted? What if I told her in a nicer way that she is not beautiful because of her rough character and selfish and egoistic nature. I really don't know...Maybe then, I've already helped her open her eyes to what really makes a person truly beautiful, and that could have already improved her, at least making her beautiful inside...and that is what is most important. Thank you for your worthwhile advice.
@areskya (398)
• Indonesia
4 Jan 12
What a bad story of your friend it is. As a good friend, it is better for you to tell her that beauty is so subjective. She is beautiful from her mind and heart, but love can't be forced to be existed on someone's heart. Someday she will find her true love and he will love him whatever she is
• Davao, Philippines
5 Jan 12
I know what you mean here, if I'm not wrong...You still think that she can be beautiful, you're right...if she has that inner beauty that comes from a pure heart and beautiful intelligent mind. Yeah...if she has already these traits, I'm sure she will soon find somebody to love and who will truly love her in return...
• Philippines
4 Jan 12
Hmmmm, that's really tough my friend, and I really can relate in your situation, but good thing I'm a frank person. Usually, some of my friends especially in girls asks me, if they are beautiful or not. And I usually tell them the truth , I won't fool them or fool myself for telling that they are beautiful, were in fact they are not. . and I'm doing it because I love them .. I wan't to emphasize on them that being beautiful isn't being everything, most of the time they should be in there selves and carry their selves with confidence . That's where the true beauty comes out, ATTITUDE . :)
• Davao, Philippines
5 Jan 12
Oh...well, carlotay, I have such great respect for your being a frank person. In fact, it takes a lot of courage telling a friend the truth, opposite to what she expects. But I know, for sure you can convey your answer to her in a way that it doesn't hurt. Maybe, your friend is a kind of person who knows how to receive love and concern from her friends and also knows to reciprocate them in being receptive and submissive to advices for her own good. That friend, I think has inner beauty that just needs a little encouragement, a little push for her to realize that...
4 Jan 12
everyone is beautiful both inside and out, looks are not important to some people but to others it's vital that they get praise, the ones who are beautiful like this praise because they are insecure about their looks or just plain self centered and shallow, people who are not gorgeous or attractive are the ones with the real beauty, it comes from the inside, i find that the most beautiful people do not have that beauty on the inside, the ones who are visibly beautiful are mainly the ones who don't have beauty on the inside either because they are too busy looking at what they look like on the outside, look at your friend and find her beauty from within, if you tell her she is not beautiful this may hurt her feelings, so don't tell her this, be truthful with her and tell her that her beauty is on the inside and doesn't need to look beautiful on the outside
• Davao, Philippines
5 Jan 12
I admire people like you who sees beauty in every person. That means, you look that something good in the heart of every human being. You're right, we vary in our standard of beauty. For most of us, physical appearance or looks is important. And there those, not really that great looking but want to be praised of their "beauty"...But in the case of my friend, I had a hard time dealing with her rude and stubborn character. If only she would be humble enough to listen to a constructive criticism from a friend like me, I think...her life will change for the better, and beauty will just spring out from her inner self, for true beauty as you said comes from within, from the beauty of ones character and a pure heart and a beautiful intelligent mind...
@djbtol (5493)
• United States
5 Jan 12
I hope I can. Such compliments should not be given insincerely, but who am I to say she is not beautiful. Beauty is in the eyes of the beholder. We should learn to judge people from the heart on out, and not try to compare each woman to the hollywood image that society uses to define beauty. I imagine that this woman has much more to offer a guy in a serious relationship than many of the 'younger and beautiful' women.
@smacksman (6053)
5 Jan 12
All women have something of beauty about them. I know. I have made a study of it over many decades! haha It is just that some women are luckier than others and have lots of beautiful points! However, it is not wise or polite to ask a friend if they are beautiful. 'Am I wonderful?', she says. Woa lady! Get real! Nobody is perfect (except me! haha) It reminds me of an old rugby song we sang in the communal bath after a match. Her lips are like petals --- bicycle pe(d)als! Her cheek are like peaches --- rugby pitches Her teeth are like stars --- they come out at night Her eyes are like pools --- cess pools Her ears are like shells --- artillary shells ... and so on So don't ask for compliments - you might get the truth!
@Archaiwy (599)
• China
5 Jan 12
I think we shouldn't take it seriously.someone,if he or she has a beautiful mind,is beautiful,although he or she is ugly. In addition, most people are ordinary,and they have a right to think themselves beautiful.If he or she has the mindset of being beautiful ,maybe he or she is beautiful.Here the meaning of beautiful is being pretty,smart ,beautiful,handsome,etc.
@yspmyl (3435)
• Malaysia
5 Jan 12
I will just tell her that she need to improve. Why lie when she is really not as beautiful as she though? But sometime, telling the truth may hurt her feeling even though she knew that she is not beautiful, but she just want someone to tell her that she is beautiful. I have this friend who look a bit out without makeup, so there was once she asked me if she is beautiful, so I told her that she need to put some make up and in that way she will look much nicer and prettier. So, she did what I told her and unexpectedly, after makeup, she really look very much nicer and prettier. Now she is more confident than before, and she always thanks me for telling her the truth.
@francesca5 (1344)
5 Jan 12
if she needs to ask you if she is beautiful then she must be very insecure, but it also sounds like she believes that physical perfection is the only thing that attracts men, which is very sad. maybe someone taught her that when she was young and she has just spent so long trying to be physically perfect and forgot the being nice bit. i have known a few arrogant people who underneath are very insecure, and i think they get very competitive and can also be very critical, and maintain their self esteem by finding faults in other people. it sounds to me like she needs a paid therapist more than a friend, but my advice would be to see if you can think of any successful relationship you know of where the woman is not physically very attractive but is so nice that the man obviously loves her, and show that to her as an example of a good relationship, and maybe she will get the message, though i suspect it is not one she would want to hear.
@enelym001 (8322)
• Philippines
4 Jan 12
Uhmmm well, I also lied when a friend who isn't pretty asked me if she is beautiful. 'Though I would tell myself, there is no ugly person in this world. Some people might think someone is ugly because of how s/he looks, but if you will get to know her character you would learn s/he is pretty. But you said her character's not - so she has a different case I have a friend who chase after good looking guys too. I have tried so many times to hook her up to guy friends. But no one seems interested on her. I don't find her ugly - I like her eyes and she has this nice and curly eyelashes. She is also nice, humorous and have a good profession. But guys don't find her attractive. And even the one she really likes only becomes her good friend but not a boyfriend. I just try to boost her morale like what you do to your friend and tell her she'd find who will love her soon.
• Davao, Philippines
5 Jan 12
enelym001, you were doing right in telling your friend she's pretty even if she is not, categorically speaking...It's not wrong to boost the morale of a friend. But you know, true beauty is not so much dependent on the outward physical attributes. It has to do with the beauty inside, in the character, in the mind... which gives so much strength to one's poise and self confidence..
@FluxNL (503)
• Netherlands
5 Jan 12
It is really hard to say, but sometimes you can't say yes. But even you say they are beautiful, they don't believe you. But sometimes you must say it in a nice way. Just don't say you are ugly!
5 Jan 12
I feel your friend asking you this on more than one occasion is strange and putting you on the spot. Did she not believe your answer the first time or is she just one of those people who don`t listen well? Either way, you can still be a good friend to her without being placed in the role of self-esteem booster. I agree with the others that beauty is subjective, that some people prize conventional beauty more than others and that ultimately it shouldn`t matter. But in our society people do place a high importance on appearance and it sounds like your friend is included. I personally see a link between someone feeling unattractive and going for partners they think are out of their dating bracket. Unfortunately, some people are so used to rejection they seek it out, which gives them the feeling of "going for it" along with the taste of rejection and failure they take too personally. I would tell her she is beautiful to you (if that is true) and help her to work on the real confidence she`ll need to meet a man with that same virtue.
@nezavisima (7408)
• Bulgaria
4 Jan 12
I understand completely. You are caught in a situation where you do not want to hurt your feelings of your friend, so you need to lie is a lie is a noble though. but you know that sometimes I get my hands is to tell the truth of man does not become a problem and then say you lied to me you are my friend. so you just have to decide yourself. success. nice day! interesting discussion.